Fatima Tlisova

Fatima Tlisova (Adyghe: Фатимы Тлисовой) (b.1966) is a Russian (Cherkes) journalist from the violent North Caucasus region, who has been facing severe intimidation for reporting on the ham-handed attempts to counter increasing Islamic and Chechen insurgency in the region. She has been assaulted repeatedly since 2002 for filing reports not favourable to strongman-president of Karachay-Cherkessia, Mustafa Batdyyev, as well as the federal government of Vladimir Putincite news
title = For the Sake of One Man: Getting the facts straight about the old-new Russia.
author = Bret Stephens
publisher = Wall Street Journal
url = http://www.opinionjournal.com/columnists/bstephens/?id=110010345
date = July 17, 2007 12:01 a.m. EDT
accessdate = 2007-07-17] . Her travails included being beaten and having her ribs broken, being poisoned (thrice), kidnapped and having cigarettes extinguished on her skin, and finally, her teenage son almost disappearing for good.

After more than a month of speculation in the media [cite news
title = Fatima Tlisova: “I am not acquainted with authors of article in the Sunday Times”
publisher = Regnum news agency
url = http://www.regnum.ru/english/794441.html
date = 2007-03-12
accessdate = 2007-07-17] , on 2007-06-28 the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists announced that Tlisova, along with Radio Liberty reporter Yuri Bagrov, had been granted political asylum in the USAcite news
title = Reporters, CPJ brief Congressional caucus on dangers facing Russian journalists
publisher = Committee to Protect Journalists
url = http://www.cpj.org/news/2007/europe/russia28jun07na.html
date = 2007-06-28
accessdate = 2007-07-17 The paragraph seven of this release was edited to read: :This spring, unable to continue their work unobstructed, Bagrov and Tlisova resettled in the United States after receiving refugee status.where the earlier text had said::This spring, unable to continue their work unobstructed, Bagrov and Tlisova were granted political asylum, and they resettled in the United States.which differs in that instead of being granted political asylum, they are being given
refugee status. According to the United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, these two terms appear to be the same. See earlier version of the report at [http://www.ifex.org/en/content/view/full/84529 IFEX.org] . ] , but after reports by her denying thiscite news
title = Fatima Tlisova denies reports about being granted asylum in the USA
url = http://www.regnum.ru/english/850646.html
date = 2007-07-02
publisher = Regnum news agency
accessdate = 2007-07-17] , the announcement was changed to say that they had received "refugee status".

Persecution

Tlisova started her career with the liberal biweekly Novaya Gazeta, one of whose reporters, Anna Politkovskaya, was murdered by a contract killer in October 2006. The paper is not officially banned, but sales are strongly discouraged, so much so that vendors will sell it only to known customers. Subsequently she became the Editor-in-Chief of the Caucasus desk for the Regnum News Agency. Since 2005, she was also working with the Associated Press. She had travelled widely in the region, filing reports from
Adygea to Dagestan. Her conflict with the authorities started in 2002, "a couple of days after her article on abusivepractice of militaries in Chechnya was published by the "Obschaya Gazeta"cite news
title = Lady-journalist from Kabardino-Balkaria moves to the States because of persecutions
publisher = The Correspondent magazine; reported in Caucasian Knot
url = http://eng.kavkaz.memo.ru/newstext/engnews/id/1190620.html
date = 2007-06-29
accessdate = 2007-07-17] . One night, after a birthday party celebrating her 36th birthday, she had gone to the door of her apartment building to see off her guests. After they left, "a hand grabbed her and she says she was dragged around a corner and beaten by twolarge men. She spent several days in intensive care with broken ribs, aconcussion and other injuries.".

In January 2005, she faced considerable harassment for a series of articles about the murder of seven shareholders in the firm Kavkaztsement. A few months earlier, they had dared challenge the firm's majority shareholder Ali Kaitov, nephew of the corrupt and unpopular Republic president Mustafa Batdyev. Shortly after they went to see Kaitov at his dacha, gunshots were heard from the vicinity, and these seven people simply disappeared. They included Rasul Bogatyrev, a deputy in the state legislature; the family of the murdered raised vigorous protests, and the case drew considerable attention in the international press: :The relatives of the murdered wrote Vladimir Putin that considering the dacha near which their sons disappeared belonged to the son-in-law of the republic's president, they were compelled to express "categorical distrust in both the law-enforcement organs and the organs of state power of Karachaevo-Cherkessia" in investigating this case [cite news
title = Karachaevo-Cherkessia hit by Criminal Violence
author = Charles Gurin
publisher = Eurasia Daily Monitor, Jamestown Foundation
url = http://www.jamestown.org/publications_details.php?volume_id=401&issue_id=3117&article_id=2368735
date = Volume 1, Issue 111 (October 22, 2004)
accessdate = 2007-07-17] . After a month of official inaction, four of the seven dead bodies were found at the bottom of a mine; they had been dismembered and burnt with tyres as fuel. Subsequently a large rally protesting the local government overcame teargas and reinforced police lines to take over the presidential palace [cite news
title = Crisis in Karachaevo-Cherkessia turns into mass uprising
author = Andrei Smirnov
publisher = Eurasia Daily Monitor, Jamestown Foundation
accessdate = 2007-07-17
url = http://www.jamestown.org/edm/article.php?article_id=2368824
date = 2004-11-10] . Fatima Tlisova was directly quoted in the international media as reporting from the scene::RFE/RL Russian Service correspondent Fatima Tlisova witnessed the incident. She sent the following report: "Almost all of offices in the White House [government building] have been ransacked. There is no information available yet about the whereabouts of President Batdyev. Almost every window in the building is broken. The surrounding area is filled with paper and broken furniture. Some government officials and ministers are watching the events from the streets adjacent to the White House."< [cite news
title = Russia: Protesters Ransack Government Building In Karachaevo-Cherkessia
author = Jean-Christophe Peuch
publisher = Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty
url = http://www.rferl.org/featuresarticle/2004/11/3ac7d840-6775-433f-8e5a-f948950dd53a.html
date = 2004-11-09
accessdate = 2007-07-17]

Following Tlisova's coverage revealing further details of the murders, the Kabardino-Balkarian Interior Ministry withdrew her accreditation. She was accused of illegally receiving a pension and criminal proceedings were initiated but were later dropped [cite news
title = Local functionaries 'take journalists as servants', says journalist
author = Lyudmila Maratova
publisher = Caucasian Knot
url = http://eng.kavkaz.memo.ru/newstext/engnews/id/753101.html
date = 2005-01-05
accessdate = 2007-07-17.] .

Shortly after this, "a car with tinted glass pulled up to her on a Nalchik street and she was told to get inside if she wanted to see her children again." Federalnaya Sluzhba Bezopasnosti (Federal Security Services, FSB) agents then took her to a nearby forest and extinguished cigarettes on every finger of her right hand, "so that you can write better". She also reports two occasions when she feels she had been poisoned - once when she applied face cream, from a jar in her own home, which peeled the skin from her face and fingers (October 2003), and another time when she lost consciousness after sippng some tea., and ended up with serious heart damage [cite news
title = Russia’s Press Repression Triggers Pinprick Protest
author = Larry Martz
publisher = Overseas Press Club of America
url = http://www.opcofamerica.org/press_freedom/russia_repression.php
year = 2004
accessdate = 2007-07-17] .

But the final straw came on October 8, 2006, one day after the murder of Anna Politkovskaya in Moscow. She sent her 16-year old son on an errand and he failed to return. Eventually she traced him to a police station in the custody of a drunken policeman who had put his name on a dreaded "list" of Chechen sympathizers. According to humanrights advocates people on these lists are usually savagely beaten, and may even vanish forever. In an interview to Jim Heintz of the Associated Press, Tlisova explained her desire for asylum::Do you know what these lists are? These are lists of broken lives. The fact that a drunken policeman can drag an innocent young man into a police station in broad daylight and put him on such a list - I didn't want that to happen to my son.cite news
title = Russian Journalist Details Ordeal
author = Jim Heintz
publisher = Associated Press / The Guardian
url = http://www.guardian.co.uk/worldlatest/story/0,,-6742400,00.html
date = 2007-06-28
accessdate = 2007-07-17The same AP report appears in [http://english.pravda.ru/news/russia/28-06-2007/94227-tlisova-0 Pravda] , but without a byline.]

A few weeks later, she came homeone night to find signs that her apartment had been broken into. The next morning, she fell violently ill, and fainted. Medical tests revealed acute kidney failure, but in a few days she had recovered, and her her kidneys were functioning normally. Given the past history, and the Russian propensity for poisoning, she believes that an intruder put poison in her food.

Background of Journalist Persecution under Putin

Fatima Tlisova's harassment is part of a well-recognized pattern for silencing critics which accelerated during the Vladimir Putin regime.

In October 2006, another Novaya Gazeta journalist Anna Politkovskaya was murdered in her apartment elevator in what appeared to be a contract killing [cite news
title = A Death in Moscow : Book review, A Russian Diary by Anna Politkovskaya. Tr. Arch Tait.
author = Andrew Meier
publisher = New York Times
url = http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/01/books/review/Meier-t.html?ex=1184817600&en=a26330de1a8d514d&ei=5070
date = 2007-07-01
accessdate = 2007-07-15] . She had faced many threats for her coverage of Russian actions in Chechnya. At the time, the World Association of Newspapers posted::The brutal murder on 7 October 2006 of Novaya Gazeta journalist Anna Politkovskaya, known for her critical reporting on the conflict in Chechnya in which she sought to expose human rights abuses, was yet another reminder to Russian journalists that violence awaits those who investigate or criticise... It is estimated that 21 journalists have been killed since Russian President Vladimir Putin came to power in March 2000. In the great majority of cases, no one has been convicted and sentenced for the murders. [http://www.wan-press.org/print.php3?id_article=14269] News release from the World Association of Newspapers, "World’s Press calls for Justice in Murder of Russian Journalists", dated June 5, 2007, release dateline: Capetown, South Africa, accessed July 8, 2007] Other journalists whose murders are unaccounted for include:
*Paul Klebnikov, Russian-American Editor of Forbes Russia, shot dead on the street in July 2004.
*Ivan Safronov, whose mysterious death from a stairwell window in March 2007 is widely viewed as an assassination
*Yuri Shchekochikhin, deputy editor of the daring Novaya Gazeta, killed in 2003 by thalium poisoning, similar to the polonium administered to Alexander Litvinenko. (see List of journalists killed in Russia)

Yuri Bagrov, a journalist from Vladikavkaz who sought asylum along with Tlisova, was also being persecuted for his revelations regarding the extent of federal forces' losses in the Second Chechen war. He also has criticized the role the FSB in kidnapping opponents in the Ingushetia region. In 2004, the North OssetiaFSB department confiscated his Soviet passport and he had to face accusations of having forged documents.

Asylum and impact on US-Russia relations

In March 2007, Tlisova went to the United States for a two-year program to study journalism. In early March, the Sunday Times reported that she had asked for asylum, but she denied thiscite news
title = Fatima Tlisova: “I am not acquainted with authors of article in the Sunday Times”
url = http://www.regnum.ru/english/794441.html
date = 2007-03-12
publisher = Regnum news agency
accessdate = 2007-07-17] . On June 1, the paper "Caucasian Knot" reported that she had been granted asylum, and rumours persisted.

On 2007-06-28, Tlisova and Bagrov, along with the Committee to Protect Journalists, met the Congressional Human Rights Caucus chaired by Rep. Tom Lantos. In a press release on the event, the CPJ announced:This spring, unable to continue their work unobstructed, Bagrov and Tlisova were granted political asylum, and they resettled in the United States.However, a report a few days later from her workplace, Regnum news agency, quoted her as denying this::There is only one thing true in what has been reported about me: I did take place in a round-table discussion at the US Congress. I am staying in America to study; after it I intend to continue working in Caucasus.The report labelled rumours of her asylum as an "information campaign". At some point, the relevant paragraph in the CPJ announcement was also revised, with an Editor's note. The new text says that Tlisova and Bagrov had received refugee status".

In her interviews about moving to the USA, Tlisova appears ambivalent; while welcoming the security it gave her family, she also feels she cannot "remain silent" about the violence in her homeland. At another point, she says: "I see my further work only in Caucasus". This may reveal a dichotomy in her about the asylum situation.

The asylum for the dissident journalists has given rise to speculation that the United States and its allies are playing hardball with Russia, especially when shortly afterwards, four Russian Diplomats were expelled from the United Kingdom, for Russia not agreeing to extradite FSB agent Andrei Lugovoi, who is suspected of poisoning Alexander Litvinenko.

However, the asylum may be more a result of increasing internationalawareness of the dangerous conditionsfor journalists in Russia, than political hardball.

References