Teredo tunneling

Teredo is a tunneling protocol designed to grant IPv6 connectivity to nodes that are located behind IPv6-unaware NAT devices. It defines a way of encapsulating IPv6 packets within IPv4 UDP datagrams that can be routed through NAT devices and on the IPv4 internet.

Purpose

6to4, the most common IPv6 over IPv4 tunneling protocol, requires the tunnel endpoint to have a public IPv4 address. However, many hosts are currently attached to the IPv4 Internet through one or several NAT devices, usually because of IPv4 address shortage. In such a situation, the only available public IPv4 address is assigned to the NAT device, and the 6to4 tunnel endpoint needs to be implemented on the NAT device itself. Many NAT devices currently deployed, however, cannot be upgraded to implement 6to4, for technical or economic reasons.

Teredo alleviates this problem by encapsulating IPv6 packets within UDP/IPv4 datagrams, which most NATs can forward properly. Thus, IPv6-aware hosts behind NATs can be used as Teredo tunnel endpoints even when they don't have a dedicated public IPv4 address. In effect, a host implementing Teredo can gain IPv6 connectivity with no cooperation from the local network environment.

Teredo is a temporary measure: in the long term, all IPv6 hosts should use native IPv6 connectivity. The Teredo protocol includes provisions for a "sunset procedure": Teredo implementation should provide a way to stop using Teredo connectivity when IPv6 has matured and connectivity becomes available using a less brittle mechanism.

Overview

:"For a complete explanation, see Teredo Overview in External links."

The Teredo protocol performs several functions:

# Diagnoses UDP over IPv4 (UDPv4) connectivity and discovers the kind of NAT present (using a simplified replacement to the STUN protocol);
# assigns a globally-routable unique IPv6 address to each host using it;
# encapsulates IPv6 packets inside UDPv4 datagrams for transmission over an IPv4 network (this includes NAT traversal);
# routes traffic between Teredo hosts and native (or otherwise non-Teredo) IPv6 hosts.

Teredo node types

Teredo defines several different kind of nodes:

* A Teredo client is a host which has IPv4 connectivity to the internet from behind a NAT and uses the Teredo tunneling protocol to access the IPv6 Internet. Teredo clients are assigned an IPv6 address that starts with the Teredo prefix (2001:0000::/32).

* A Teredo server is a well-known host which is used for initial configuration of a Teredo tunnel. A Teredo server never forwards any traffic for the client (apart from IPv6 pings), and has therefore very modest bandwidth requirements (a few thousand bytes per minute per client at most), which allows a single server to support large numbers of clients. Additionally, a Teredo server can be implemented in a fully stateless manner.

* A Teredo relay serves as the remote end of a Teredo tunnel. A Teredo relay must forward all of the data on behalf of the Teredo clients it serves, with the exception of direct Teredo client to Teredo client exchanges. Therefore, a relay requires a lot of bandwidth and can only support a limited number of simultaneous clients. Each Teredo relay serves a range of IPv6 hosts (e.g. a single campus/company, an ISP or a whole operator network, or even the whole IPv6 Internet); it forwards traffic between any Teredo clients and any host within said range.

* A Teredo host-specific relay is a Teredo relay whose range of service is limited to the very host it runs on. As such, it has no particular bandwidth or routing requirements. A computer with a host-specific relay will use Teredo to communicate with Teredo clients, but it will stick to its main IPv6 connectivity provider to reach the rest of the IPv6 Internet.

Teredo IPv6 addressing

Each Teredo client is assigned a public IPv6 address which is constructed as follows (the higher order bit is numbered 0):

* Bits 0 to 31 are set to the Teredo prefix (normally 2001:0000::/32).
* Bits 32 to 63 embed the primary IPv4 address of the Teredo server that is used.
* Bits 64 to 79 can be used to define some flags. Currently only the higher order bit is used; it is set to 1 if the Teredo client is located behind a cone NAT, 0 otherwise. For Microsoft's Windows Vista and Windows Server 2008 implementations, more bits are used. In those implementations, the format for these 16 bits is "CRAAAAUG AAAAAAAA", where "C" remains the "Cone" flag, and the 12 "A" bits are randomly chosen by the Teredo client to introduce additional protection for the Teredo node against IPv6-based scanning attacks.
* Bits 80 to 95 contains the "obfuscated" UDP port number. This is the port number that is mapped by the NAT to the Teredo client with all bits inverted.
* Bits 96 to 127 contains the "obfuscated" IPv4 address. This is the public IPv4 address of the NAT with all bits inverted.

As an example, 2001:0000:4136:e378:8000:63bf:3fff:fdd2 refers to a Teredo client:
* using Teredo server at address 65.54.227.120 (4136e378 in hexadecimal),
* located behind a cone NAT (bit 64 is set),
* using UDP mapped port 40000 on its NAT (in hexadecimal 63bf xor ffff equals 9c40, or decimal number 40000),
* whose NAT has public IPv4 address 192.0.2.45 (3ffffdd2 xor ffffffff equals c000022d, which is to say 192.0.2.45).

Teredo servers

:"For a list of existing Teredo servers, see the list in External links."

Teredo servers are used by Teredo clients to autodetect the kind of NAT behind which they are located (if any), through a simplified STUN-like "qualification procedure". Teredo clients also maintain a binding on their NAT toward their Teredo server, by sending a UDP packet at regular time intervals. That ensures that the server can always contact any of its clients, which is required for hole punching to work properly.

If a Teredo relay (or another Teredo client) has to send an IPv6 packet to a Teredo client, it will first send a "Teredo bubble" packet to the client's Teredo server, whose IP address can be inferred from the Teredo IPv6 address of the Teredo client. The server can then forward the "bubble" to the client, so the Teredo client software knows that hole punching must be done toward the Teredo relay.

Teredo servers can also transmit ICMPv6 packet from Teredo clients toward the IPv6 Internet. In practice, when a Teredo client wants to contact a native IPv6 node, it must find out where the corresponding Teredo relay is (i.e. which public IPv4 and UDP port number to send encapsulated IPv6 packets to). To do that, the client crafts an ICMPv6 Echo Request ("ping") toward the IPv6 node, and sends it through its configured Teredo server. The Teredo server decapsulates the ping onto the IPv6 Internet, so that the ping should eventually reach the IPv6 node. The IPv6 node should then reply with an ICMPv6 Echo Reply, as mandated by RFC 2460. This reply packet will be routed to the "closest" Teredo relay, which will finally try to contact the Teredo client.

Maintaining a Teredo server requires little bandwidth because they are not involved into the actual transmission and reception of IPv6 packets. Also, it does not involve any access to the Internet routing protocols. The only requirements for a Teredo server are:
* the ability to emit ICMPv6 packets with a source address belonging to the Teredo prefix,
* two distinct public IPv4 addresses (although not written down in the official specification, Microsoft Windows clients expect both addresses to be consecutive); the second IPv4 address is needed for the purpose of NAT detection.

Teredo relays

A Teredo relay potentially requires a lot of network bandwidth. Also, it must export ("advertise") a route toward the Teredo IPv6 prefix (2001:0::/32) to other IPv6 hosts. That way, the Teredo relay will receive traffic from the IPv6 hosts addressed to any Teredo client, and forward it over UDP/IPv4. Symmetrically, it will receive packets from Teredo clients addressed to native IPv6 hosts over UDP/IPv4 and inject those into the native IPv6 network.

In practice, network administrators can set up a private Teredo relay for their company or campus; this will provide a short path between their IPv6 network and any Teredo client. However setting up a Teredo relay on a scale beyond that of a single network requires the ability to export BGP IPv6 routes to the other autonomous systems (AS).

Unlike 6to4, where the two halves of a connection can use different relays, traffic between a native IPv6 and a Teredo host will use the same Teredo relay, namely the one that is closest to the native IPv6 host network-wise. The Teredo host cannot localize a relay by itself (since it cannot send IPv6 packets by itself); if it needs to initiate a connection to a native-v6 host, it will send the first packet through the Teredo server, which sends a packet to the native-v6 host using the client's Teredo IPv6 address. The native-v6 host then responds as usual to the client's Teredo IPv6 address, which will eventually cause the packet to find a Teredo relay, which will initiate a connection to the client (possibly using the Teredo server for NAT piercing). The relay is then used for communication between the two hosts for as long as is needed. This design means that neither the Teredo server nor client needs to know the IPv4 address of any Teredo relays; a suitable one is automatically found by means of the global IPv6 routing table, since all Teredo relays advertise the network 2001:0::/32.

:"For near-realtime information on Teredo and BGP, see the External links."

On March 30 2006, Italian ISP [http://www.itgate.net/ ITGate] was the first AS to start advertising a route toward 2001::/32 on the IPv6 Internet, so that RFC 4380-compliant Teredo implementations would be fully usable. Note: as of 16.2.2007 it is not functional.

It is expected that large network operators will be maintaining Teredo relays. As with 6to4, it remains however unclear how well the Teredo service will scale up if a large proportion of Internet hosts start using IPv6 through Teredo in addition to IPv4.

While Microsoft has been operating a set of Teredo servers ever since the first Teredo pseudo-tunnel for Windows XP was released, it has never provided a Teredo relay service for the IPv6 Internet as a whole.

Public teredo servers:

* teredo.remlab.net (France)
* teredo.autotrans.consulintel.com (Spain)
* teredo.ipv6.microsoft.com (USA, Redmond) (default for WindowsXP/2003/Vista/2008 OS)
* 203.233.154.10 (NCA, Korea)

Limitations

Teredo is not compatible with all NAT devices. Using the terminology of RFC 3489, full cone, restricted and port-restricted NAT devices are supported, while symmetric NATs are not. National Chiao Tung University proposed [http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/freeabs_all.jsp?arnumber=1633339&fromcon SymTeredo] which enhanced the original Teredo protocol to support symmetric NATs, and the Microsoft and Miredo implementations implement certain unspecified non-standard extensions to improve support for symmetric NATs. However, connectivity between a Teredo client behind a symmetric NAT, and a Teredo client behind a port-restricted or symmetric NAT remains seemingly impossible.

Indeed, Teredo assumes that when two clients exchange encapsulated IPv6 packets, the mapped/external UDP port numbers used will be the same as those that were used to contact the Teredo server (and building the Teredo IPv6 address). Without this assumption, it would not be possible to establish a direct communication between the two clients, and a costly relay would have to be used to perform triangle routing. A Teredo implementation tries to detect the type of NAT at startup, and will refuse to operate if the NAT appears to be symmetric. (This limitation can sometimes be worked around by manually configuring a port forwarding rule on the NAT box, which requires administrative access to the device).

Teredo can only provide a single IPv6 address per tunnel endpoint. As such, it is not possible to use a single Teredo tunnel to connect multiple hosts, contrary to 6to4 and some point-to-point IPv6 tunnels.

The bandwidth available to all Teredo clients toward the IPv6 Internet is limited by the availability of Teredo relays (which are no different in that respect from 6to4 relays).

Alternatives to Teredo

6to4 requires a public IPv4 address, but provides a large 48-bit IPv6 prefix for each tunnel endpoint, and has a lower encapsulation overhead.

Point-to-point tunnels are usually more reliable and accountable than automatic pseudo-tunneling schemes (Teredo and 6to4), and typically provides permanent IPv6 addresses that do not depend on the IPv4 address of the tunnel endpoint. Some point-to-point tunnel brokers additionally support UDP encapsulation to traverse NATs (for instance, the AYIYA protocol can do this). On the other hand, point-to-point tunnels normally require registration. Automated tools (for instance AICCU) exist to make it easy to use Point-to-Point tunnels.

Security considerations

Exposure

Teredo increases the "attack surface" by assigning globally routable IPv6 addresses to network hosts behind NAT devices, which are otherwise mostly unreachable from the Internet. By doing so, Teredo potentially exposes any IPv6-enabled application with an open port to the outside. It also exposes the IPv6 stack and the Teredo tunneling software to attacks should they have any remotely exploitable vulnerability.

The Microsoft IPv6 stack has a "protection level" socket option. This allows applications to specify whether they are willing to handle traffic coming from the Teredo tunnel, from anywhere except Teredo (the default), or only from the local Intranet.

Firewalling

For a Teredo (pseudo-)tunnel to operate properly,outgoing UDP packets must not be filtered.Moreover, replies to these packets (i.e. "solicited traffic") must also not be filtered. This corresponds to the typical setup of a NAT and its stateful firewall functionality.

Blocking

Teredo tunneling software will detect a fatal error and stop if outgoing IPv4 UDP traffic is blocked.

Implementations

Several implementations of Teredo are currently available:

* Windows XP SP2 includes a client and "host-specific" relay (also in the Advanced Networking Pack for Service Pack 1).
* Windows Server 2003 has a relay and server provided under the Microsoft Beta program.
* Windows Vista has built-in support for Teredo with an unspecified extension for symmetric NAT traversal,
* Miredo is a client, relay and server for Linux, *BSD and Mac OS X,
* [http://www-rp.lip6.fr/teredo/ ng_teredo] is a relay and server based on netgraph for FreeBSD from the LIP6 University and 6WIND.
* [http://sourceforge.net/projects/nici-teredo/ NICI-Teredo] is a relay for the Linux kernel and a userland Teredo server, developed at the National Chiao Tung University.

Choice of the name Teredo

The initial nickname of the Teredo tunneling protocol was"shipworm". The idea was that the protocol would pierce holes through NAT devices, much like the shipworms bore tunnels through wood. Shipworms are responsible for the loss of very many wooden hulls, but Christian Huitema in the original draft noted that "the animal only survives in relatively clean and unpolluted water; its recent comeback in several Northern American harbors is a testimony to their newly retrieved cleanliness. Similarly, by piercing holes through NAT, the service would contribute to a newly retrieved transparency of the Internet."

Christian Huitema quickly changed the name to Teredo to avoid confusion with computer worms [cite web | url=http://www.atm.tut.fi/list-archive/ngtrans/msg00776.html | title=(ngtrans) Renaming Shipworm as Teredo? | author=Huitema, Christian | date=2001-12-19 | publisher=IETF ngtrans wg mailing list] . "Teredo navalis" is the Latin name of one of the best known species of shipworm.

References

* C. Huitema. "Teredo: Tunneling IPv6 over UDP through Network Address Translations (NATs)". RFC 4380, February 2006.

External links

* [http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb457011.aspx Teredo Overview] on Microsoft TechNet
* [http://www.sixxs.net/tools/grh/lg/?find=2001::/32 Current anycast Teredo BGP routes]
* [http://www.sixxs.net/tools/whois/?TEREDO-MNT TEREDO-MNT] : list of operators advertising the Teredo prefix via BGP
* [http://www.sixxs.net/tools/aiccu/brokers/ List of Teredo servers] maintained by SixXS