Acción de Lucha Anti-Petrola

Formed in December 1999, Acción de Lucha Anti-Petrola (ADELA) is a Costa Rican grassroots environmental group created to oppose offshore oil exploration and drilling. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration;] Mark Engler & Nadia Martinez, "True Gold of Our Future," "New Internationalist", Oct. 2003, at 26.] Translated into English as "Anti-Petroleum Action," [Mark Engler & Nadia Martinez, "True Gold of Our Future," "New Internationalist", Oct. 2003, at 26.] ADELA is named after a local indigenous woman who was "struggling to defend her culture and local environment against outside forces." [ [http://www.macalester.edu/environmentalstudies/MacEnvReview/costarica.htm/ Michael Gelardi, "Environment, Economy, and Energy in Costa Rica: The Case Study of Petroleum Exploration in the Province of Límon" (May 2001).] ] ADELA initially consisted of 30 local citizen's groups ranging from farmers' organizations and the fisherman's union, to religious groups, small business owners, and marine biologists. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration;] Mark Engler & Nadia Martinez, "True Gold of Our Future," "New Internationalist", Oct. 2003, at 26.] ADELA now comprises over 100 local citizens' organizations. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ] The various groups came together to form ADELA after becoming aware of the negative environmental impact of seismic reflection explorations being conducted by Harken Costa Rica Holdings in November 1999. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration;] [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=6&lang=eng/ ADELA, Welcome to ADELA.] ]

ADELA's Mission

The primary goal of ADELA is to effectuate a complete national moratorium on oil exploration. [ [http://www.ifaw.org/ifaw/general/default.aspx?oid=12773/ IFAW, Latest Updates on ADELA!, 8 May 2002: A Victory for the Environment and People of Costa Rica.] ] In carrying out its mission, ADLEA informs and educates both the Caribbean community and political actors about the environmental risks the oil industry poses for Costa Rica, as well as for the Caribbean generally. ADELA also works with members of local communities to promote sustainable development, and to develop more environmentally friendly energy practices and policies. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=6&lang=eng/ ADELA, Welcome to ADELA.] ]

With little material resources, ADELA largely relied on the grassroots efforts of its own members until 2001. [ [http://www.nrdc.org/OnEarth/02fal/field.asp/ Sam Martin, "No Rigs Allowed: Costa Rica Gives the Boot to a Texas Oil Company with Ties to George W. Bush," "OnEarth", Fall 2002.] ] ADLEA was largely successful in its efforts, and managed to stage protests, voice their opinions over the radio, and even bring lawsuits in the Costa Rican national court. [ [http://www.nrdc.org/OnEarth/02fal/field.asp/ Sam Martin, "No Rigs Allowed: Costa Rica Gives the Boot to a Texas Oil Company with Ties to George W. Bush," "OnEarth", Fall 2002.] ] After recognizing that their message was not reaching the United States, home of the oil companies seeking to drill off the Costa Rican shoreline, ADELA contacted the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) in early 2001. [ [http://www.nrdc.org/OnEarth/02fal/field.asp/ Sam Martin, "No Rigs Allowed: Costa Rica Gives the Boot to a Texas Oil Company with Ties to George W. Bush," "OnEarth", Fall 2002;] Mark Engler & Nadia Martinez, "True Gold of Our Future," "New Internationalist", Oct. 2003, at 26.] ADELA's cause received international exposure when the NDRC included Talamanca, a tropical forest region in southern Costa Rica, in its BioGems initiative. [ [http://www.nrdc.org/OnEarth/02fal/field.asp/ Sam Martin, "No Rigs Allowed: Costa Rica Gives the Boot to a Texas Oil Company with Ties to George W. Bush," "OnEarth", Fall 2002.] ] ADELA also began to receive financial support, research, and legal resources from the following groups: NRDC, Environmental Law Alliance Worldwide, Global Response, Caribbean Conservation Corporation, InterAmerican Association for Environmental Defense, International Fund for Animal Welfare, World Conservation Union, Forest Conservation Action Alerts, Environmental News Network, Project Underground, and Radio International Feminista. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration;] Mark Engler & Nadia Martinez, "True Gold of Our Future," "New Internationalist", Oct. 2003, at 26.]

Talamanca and Potential Environmental Damage

Much of the oil exploration to date has occurred in the 1,300 square mile region of Costa Rica known as Talamanca. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration;] [http://www.nrdc.org/OnEarth/02fal/field.asp/ Sam Martin, "No Rigs Allowed: Costa Rica Gives the Boot to a Texas Oil Company with Ties to George W. Bush," "OnEarth", Fall 2002.] ] Talamanca is recognized as being one of the richest marine ecosystems on the planet, [ [http://www.foe.org/camps/intl/harken.pdf/ NDRC & Friends of the Earth, The Threat to the Environment from the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA): The Case of Harken Costa Rica Holdings and Offshore Oil;] ] and its mountainous terrain and tropical vegetation are considered to be equally rich. [ [http://www.elaw.org/campaigns/info.asp?id=495/ ELAW, Stop Development on Costa Rica's Caribbean Coast.] ] Due to its biological significance, Talamanca is protected as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. [ [http://www.nrdc.org/OnEarth/02fal/field.asp/ Sam Martin, "No Rigs Allowed: Costa Rica Gives the Boot to a Texas Oil Company with Ties to George W. Bush," "OnEarth", Fall 2002.] ] Talamanca is also home to three indigenous community reserves, the Cahuita National Park, and a UN-designated wetlands site at the Gandoca-Manzanillo Wildlife Refuge. [ [http://www.foe.org/camps/intl/harken.pdf/ NDRC & Friends of the Earth, The Threat to the Environment from the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA): The Case of Harken Costa Rica Holdings and Offshore Oil;] ] In total, 88% of the Talamanca region has some level of environmental protection. [ [http://www.elaw.org/campaigns/info.asp?id=495/ ELAW, Stop Development on Costa Rica's Caribbean Coast.] ]

Talamanca's marine resources include coral reefs, mangroves, rare manatees, over 100 species of fish, and sea turtle nesting beaches. [ [http://www.elaw.org/campaigns/info.asp?id=495/ ELAW, Stop Development on Costa Rica's Caribbean Coast.] ] In fact, Costa Rica's Caribbean coast is a migratory pathway for at least three endangered species of sea turtles, and sea turtles are recognized as being especially susceptible to oil pollution. [ [http://archives.cnn.com/2002/TECH/science/02/01/costa.rica.oil/index.html/ Gary Strieker, "Texas Oil a Slippery Issue in Costa Rica Vote," CNN.com.] ]

Protection of the sea turtles is a primary concern for conservationists, but it is likely that mangroves and wetlands, generally, would not be able to recover from an oil spill. [ [http://www.foe.org/camps/intl/harken.pdf/ NDRC & Friends of the Earth, The Threat to the Environment from the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA): The Case of Harken Costa Rica Holdings and Offshore Oil;] ] Oil pollution would also significantly impact the coastal communities and local economic infrastructure, as it would likely result in hundreds of fishing jobs being lost and a decrease in eco-tourism. [ [http://www.foe.org/camps/intl/harken.pdf/ NDRC & Friends of the Earth, The Threat to the Environment from the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA): The Case of Harken Costa Rica Holdings and Offshore Oil;] ] Eco-tourism remains Costa Rica's primary source of revenue from other countries. [ [http://archives.cnn.com/2002/TECH/science/02/01/costa.rica.oil/index.html/ Gary Strieker, "Texas Oil a Slippery Issue in Costa Rica Vote," CNN.com.] ]

Efforts to Hault Exploration and Drilling by Harken Costa Rica Holdings

Background

In 1994, the Costa Rican legislature passed a Hydrocarbons Law which divided the country into 27 blocks for oil and natural gas exploration, and it allowed firms of foreign countries to bid for oil concessions. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ] In July 1998, Costa Rican President Miguel Angel Rodriguex (1998-2002) granted one concession of four exploration blocks to MKJ Xploration Inc. (MKJ), a small Louisiana-based company. Located in Talamanca, the four blocks were to be used for the exploration and extraction of hydrocarbons. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ]

In November 1998, Harken Energy Corporation (Harkan) of Dallas, Texas, purchased 40% of the concession rights from MKJ, and the two companies combined to create Harken Costa Rica Holdings (HCRH). [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ] In March 1999, Costa Rica's National Technical Environmental Secretariat (SETENA) approved an environmental impact study (EIA) submitted by HCRH to conduct marine seismic reflection blasting. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ]

Between October and December 1999, HCRH began using seismic reflection blasting to map possible oil reserves. Such blasting was in derogation of a condition in the EIA that restricted blasting to the months of January and July, so as to minimize the impact on marine life. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ] The blasting significantly disrupted the local Costa Rican fishing industry. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ] ADELA formed in December 1999 to oppose the actions of HCRH.

Efforts of ADELA

In January 2000, ADELA was a party in a lawsuit seeking an injunction and annulment of the HCRH exploration concessions. In September of that year, the Costa Rican Constitutional Court ruled in ADELA's favor, and granted an annulment of the 4 block HCRH concession. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ] The Court's ruling was based on International Labor Organization Convention 169, "Concerning Indigenous and Tribal Peoples in Independent Countries," to which Costa Rica is bound. The Court later modified the ruling in November 2000, however, and nullified only those blocks affecting indigenous territory. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ]

In September 2001, SETENA convened a public hearing in Limón to debate issues concerning oil development. HCHR bused in approximately 100 people who they paid to attend the hearing, yet they were outnumbered by ADELA members. More than 300 people are reported to have supported ADELA's campaign with banners and posters. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ] In addition, marine biologists and environmental organizations who support ADELA gave presentations about various social, economic, and environmental adverse impacts that could result from oil exploration and drilling. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ]

On February 28, 2002, SETENA rejected HCRH's EIA as not being environmentally or socially viable, and SETENA listed 50 reasons for its decision. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration;] [http://www.elaw.org/news/advocate/default.asp?issue=2002-2/ E-LAW Advocate, Protecting Costa Rica's Tropical Coastline.] ] HCRH's appeal was rejected by Elizabeth Odio, then-Costa Rican Minister of the Environment. [ [http://www.ifaw.org/ifaw/general/default.aspx?oid=12773/ IFAW, Latest Updates on ADELA!, 8 May 2002: A Victory for the Environment and People of Costa Rica.] ]

In 2005, the Costa Rican President notified HCHR that their contract had been terminated, due to HCHR's failure to obtain an approved EIA pursuant to Costa Rican environmental law. [ [http://grupoadela.org/newsite/index.php?page=17&lang=eng/ ADELA, A Story of Local, National, and International Resistance to Oil Exploration.] ]

References