Tippecanoe and Tyler too

"Tippecanoe and Tyler too", originally published as "Tip and Ty", was a very popular and influential campaign song of the colorful Log Cabin Campaign in the 1840 United States presidential election. Its lyrics sung the praises of Whig candidates William Henry Harrison (the "hero of Tippecanoe") and John Tyler, while denigrating incumbent Democrat Martin Van Buren.

Irwin Silber, the leading authority on the genre, has written that the song "firmly established the power of singing as a campaign device" in the United States, and that this and the other songs of 1840 represent a "Great Divide" in the development of American campaign music. [Silber, Irwin (1971). "Songs America Voted By". Harrisburg, Pennsylvania: Stackpole Books.] The "North American Review" at the time even remarked that the song was, "in the political canvas of 1840 what the 'Marseillaise' was to the French Revolution. It sang Harrison into the presidency." [ As cited in Silber.]

Today, however, the slogan "Tippecanoe and Tyler too" is better remembered than the song itself – serving as a staple of American schoolbook history.

Origin

The song was written by Alexander Coffman Ross, a jeweler of Zanesville, Ohio in 1840, to the music of the minstrelsy song, "Little Pigs". He first performed it at a Whig meeting in Zanesville, and it came to national attention when, traveling on a business trip, he introduced it to a Whig rally in New York. Ross apparently never copyrighted the song. [Silber, Irwin (1971). "Songs America Voted By". Harrisburg, Pennsylvania: Stackpole Books.]

"Little Pigs" itself is not well-documented, but the available evidence suggests that there was a substantial adaptation of the score for "Tip and Ty". [Schrader, Arthur (2001). "Singing SHEAR History: A Commentary and Music Sampler". "Journal of the Early Republic."]

A historical society in Madison, Wisconsin has asserted in a "Capital Times" column [Historic Madison Inc. (Feb. 19, 2007) [http://www.madison.com/archives/read.php?ref=/tct/2007/02/19/0702190164.php "Historic Madison: Tippecanoe and Tyler, too"] . "The Capital Times".] and apparently in a book as well, [ [http://www.historicmadison.org/html/Pubs/FHillCem.asp Forest Hill Cemetery: A Biographical Guide to the Ordinary and the Famous Who Shaped Madison and the World] , 2002 (reference to book content)] that a local young nephew of future U.S. Supreme Court justice Levi Woodbury wrote the first verses, and that its premiere performance at a Whig rally came at the suggestion of Levi Woodbury. Levi Woodbury was however by all accounts a Democrat, not a Whig, and was in fact serving as Secretary of the Treasury under Martin Van Buren at the time.

There were many variations on the song published at the time, especially ones with new verses. It has been called a "satirical, expandable text that permitted, nay urged, singers to add their own lines". [Schrader, Arthur (2001). "Singing SHEAR History: A Commentary and Music Sampler". "Journal of the Early Republic."]

Lyrics

Quote_box
align=right
quote=Tip and Ty What's the cause of this commotion, motion, motion, Our country through? It is the ball a-rolling on
For Tippecanoe and Tyler too. For Tippecanoe and Tyler too. And with them we'll beat little Van, Van, Van, Van is a used up man. And with them we'll beat little Van.
source=First verse and chorus|Ross's version has twelve verses and a rousing chorus. There is repeated reference to rolling balls and constant motion, and rolling "great canvas balls" [White, Andrew Dickson (1911). "The Autobiography of Andrew Dickson White, Vol. 1", [http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/1340 online] ] became a physical prop in the campaign pageantry, alongside the better-known log cabins and hard cider barrels.

The song's appeal has been compared to that of a great pop novelty song, as against the relative seriousness of most campaign songs. [Schrader, Arthur (2001). "Singing SHEAR History: A Commentary and Music Sampler". "Journal of the Early Republic."]

Martin Van Buren is derided as "Little Van" and "Little Matty" and his supporters as "Vanjacks". These are contrasted with the rustic virtues of Harrison and the inevitability of his victory throughout the states.

The refrain "For Tippecanoe and Tyler too" is highly euphonious: it exhibits a triple alliteration, an internal rhyme, and nearly forms an iambic tetrameter.

Modern recordings

The song was part of the 1968 Off-Broadway musical "How to Steal an Election" and its cast album, with music and lyrics adapted by folk singer Oscar Brand.

The song has been recorded in a traditional form at least twice; in 1978 by Peter Janovsky on the album "Winners and Losers: Campaign Songs from the Critical Elections in American History, Vol. 1" for Folkways Records, and in 1999 by Oscar Brand on the album "Presidential Campaign Songs: 1789 - 1996" for Smithsonian Folkways Recordings, the successor label to Folkways Records.

The band They Might Be Giants recorded an alternative rock version of the song for the 2004 compilation album "Future Soundtrack for America", using a three verse lyric as adapted by Oscar Brand (from the first, eighth and second verses in Ross's original). Appropriately enough, the compilation was a benefit album for political causes relating to that year's election. John Flansburgh of They Might be Giants has remarked on the song's historical success as "the 'Rock Around the Clock' of campaign songs" [Braiker, Brian. [http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5445923/site/newsweek They Might Be Onto Something] "Newsweek."] and "the 'I Want to Hold Your Hand' of campaign songs". [Jeckell, Barry A. (June 30, 2004) [http://www.billboard.com/bbcom/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1000558508 'Future' Compilation Supports Political Change] . "Billboard."]

References