John Perlman

John Perlman is a radio presenter for Kaya FM in South Africa, where he hosts "Today with John Perlman", a weekday programme between 6 and 7 p.m. [cite web|url=http://www.kayafm.co.za/profiles.php?p=15|title=profile for John Perlman|publisherKaya FM 95dot9|accessdate=2008-05-09] Perlman previously co-hosted "AM Live" and the "After 8 Debate", the flagship morning news, current affairs and talk programmes on the SAfm radio station of the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC).

In his role at the SABC, Perlman was one of South Africa's most popular and respected radio anchors. The SABC described Perlman as a "seasoned journalist and an outstanding broadcaster"cite web
url=http://www.safm.co.za/presenters/presenterDetails.jsp?presenterid=27
title=Presenter details: John Perlman
publisher=SABC
accessdate=2007-01-30] and "AM Live" as "arguably the most influential programme in South Africa".cite web
url=http://www.safm.co.za/programmedetails/index.jsp?programmeid=27
title=Programme Details: AM Live
publisher=SABC
accessdate=2007-01-30] However, in March 2007 Perlman resigned after blowing the whistle on political censorship within the SABC. His resignation was widely thought to indicate his dissatisfaction with internal politics at the SABC.

Perlman has a BA in History, African Politics and Southern Sotho, and a BA Honours in Development Studies. He has also worked for the "Weekly Mail", "Saturday Star" and "Sunday Independent". He has also presented on television.cite web
url=http://www.totalexposure.co.za/pressrooms/page.php?p_id=155
title=John Perlman
publisher=Total Exposure
accessdate=2007-01-30]

Whistle-blowing on SABC blacklist

In 2006, Perlman caused a storm of controversy through an on-air whistle-blowing incident in which he revealed political censorship at the national broadcaster. In the live broadcast, Perlman contradicted SABC spokesperson Kaizer Kganyago's denial that the SABC had an editorial blacklist of commentators critical of the South African government or president.cite news
url=http://www.big.co.za/wordpress/2006/06/23/the-perlman-factor/
title=The Perlman Factor
date=June 23 2006
first=Anton|last=Harber
accessdate=2007-01-30] He later said that this followed intensive internal discussions over 3 months with concerned SABC staffers, and that others had also taken a stand.cite news|url=http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=3015&art_id=vn20070307053631626C110957|title=We all planned to defy SABC, says Perlman|first=Karyn|last=Maughan|date=7 March 2007]

An internal SABC commission of inquiry was appointed, headed by Zwelakhe Sisulu and Gilbert Marcus, to investigate the allegations, and in October 2006 issued a damning report against the SABC. The report entirely vindicated Perlman's statement, finding that there was an arbitrary blacklist of commentators who SABC staff were instructed not to consult. This blacklist included prominent analysts Karima Brown, Aubrey Matshiqi, William Gumede, Paula Slier, Sipho Seepe, Moeletsi Mbeki, Elinor Sisulu, and Trevor Ncube.cite news
url=http://www.swradioafrica.com/pages/sabcblacklist.htm
title=Inside the SABC blacklist report
publisher=Mail & Guardian
first=Ferial
last=Haffajee
date=2006-10-13
accessdate=2008-09-16] The commissioners sharply criticised the head of SABC News, Snuki Zikalala, for his management style, and said that there was a climate of fear in the SABC newsroom. It found that that the blacklisting contradicted the SABC's mandate and recommended that new guidelines on commentators be developed through wide consultation in and outside the SABC.

Despite the commissioners' strong recommendations that their report be released to the public, the SABC CEO Dali Mpofu chose not to publish it, initially releasing only excerpts, and then unsuccessfully attempting a court interdict against the "Mail & Guardian" when they published the full report online. Mpofu's actions were widely criticised at the time.cite news
publisher=SABC
url=http://www.sabcnews.com/south_africa/general/0,2172,142894,00.html
first=Rezaa|last=Kasu
writing_standard=sloppy
title=John Perlman resigns from the SABC
date=2007-01-30]

Following the report, the SABC threatened Perlman with disciplinary action for "bringing the organisation into disrepute" but took no action on the commission's findings against Zikalala or the SABC. Perlman reportedly refused to accept an on-air warning for contradicting Kganyago, insisting on a disciplinary hearing instead.

Resignation

On 30 January 2007, Perlman announced his resignation from the SABC after 9 years, and held his last show on 2 March. Although initially Perlman did not comment on his reasons, the media reported that his resignation was linked to his dissatisfaction with the SABC's failure to respond to the commission's report.cite news
url=http://www.businessday.co.za/articles/topstories.aspx?ID=BD4A371097
date=30 January 2007
publisher=Business Day
title=Perlman quits SABC after list furore
first=Ernest|last=Mabuza] [cite news
url=http://www.citizen.co.za/index/article.aspx?pDesc=31361,1,22
title=SABC confirms Perlman resignation
publisher=The Citizen
date=2007-01-30]

Perlman's resignation announcement came at the same time as his co-host Nikiwe Bikitsha's departure from the SABC to take up a post with CNBC Africa. The "Mail & Guardian" reported on 3 February that the final straw for Perlman was that the station bosses excluded him from discussions about Bikitsha's successor, although he had always previously been included in decisions on who would be his co-anchor. It also reported that Perlman was offered a post at the CNBC Africa business channel, but had not accepted it.cite news|url=http://www.mg.co.za/articlePage.aspx?articleid=297798&area=/insight/insight__national/
title=Why Perlman quit the SABC
first=Ferial
last=Hafferjee
coauthor=Makgetla, Tumi
date=2007-02-03] "The Star" pointed to several other prominent resignations, speculating that this indicated a purge of news staff who had appeared before the commission and given evidence criticising the blacklisting policy. It also pointed to a June 2005 staff exodus which was suspected as being a purge of people opposed to Zikalala's political views.cite news
url=http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=13&art_id=vn20070131232527205C109093
title=SABC resignations raise purge suspicions
publisher=The Star
first=Tanya|last=Farber
date=1 February 2007]

Reaction

Perlman's departure and the lack of action against Zikalala was condemned by media commentators and political parties from COSATU to the Democratic Alliance as a worrying development for media freedom in South Africa.cite news
url=http://www.businessday.co.za/articles/topstories.aspx?ID=BD4A371959
title=John Perlman's 'rolling head' a sad portent for SA
first=Anton|last=Harber
publisher=Business Day
date=31 January 2007] cite news
url=http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=13&art_id=vn20070131045736243C938686
title=Perlman ponders future after quitting SABC
publisher=IOL
first=Thokozani|last=Mtshali
date=31 January 2007] cite news
url=http://www.dispatch.co.za/2007/02/01/editoria/editorial.html
title=SABC on the road to ruin
publisher=Dispatch
date=1 February 2007]

On Perlman's first "After 8 Debate" call-in show after his upcoming departure became public, a discussion of the SA film industry began with a caller referring to the "horror movie" of John Perlman's departure. Others said that SABC management should be ashamed of themselves and wondered if Perlman's successor would have the courage to host a call-in programme investigating the reasons for Perlman's departure, with Perlman responding that this was "not likely".cite news
title=AM Live
publisher=SABC
date=31 January 2007]

The Freedom of Expression Institute (FXI) marched to the SABC headquarters on February 6 to demand greater transparency and accountability, saying that Perlman's resignation and others pointed to vicitimisation at the SABC, [cite news |title=SABC taken to task on transparency |url=http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=3015&art_id=qw1170778682138B212 |date=6 February 2007 |publisher=IOL] and laid a formal complaint with the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA).cite news|url=http://www.fxi.org.za/pages/Media%20&%20ICT/Press/Press%20Statements/SABCcomplaintrelease.html|date=20 February 2007
title=FXI complains: SABC has violated licence conditions and Broadcasting Act
publisher=Freedom of Expression Institute]

The Media Monitoring Project included Perlman's reinstatement in its wishlist for Thabo Mbeki's state of the nation address on February 9.cite web|url=http://www.journalism.co.za/content/view/444/51 |title=Wishlist for Mbeki |publisher=Media Monitoring Project| accessdate=2007-02-08] Interviewed by Perlman on 22 February following the annual budget speech, Finance Minister Trevor Manuel praised Perlman's "sterling work" and contribution to changing the face of the SA media.cite news|title=Trevor Manuel impressed by Perlman's sterling work|date=22 February 22 2007|url=http://www.sabcnews.com/south_africa/general/0,2172,144179,00.html|publisher=SABC]

COSATU took out a full-page advert in the Mail & Guardian on 2 March, coinciding with Perlman's last day on air, paying tribute to him as "an excellent and patriotic journalist".cite news|url=http://www.mg.co.za/articlepage.aspx?area=/breaking_news/breaking_news__national/&articleid=300600|title=Cosatu: 'We salute you, John Perlman'|date=1 March 2006|publisher=Mail & Guardian] Perlman's final After 8 Debate was titled "Have we learnt anything from the After 8 Debate?"cite news|url=http://www.moneyweb.co.za/mw/view/mw/en/page39?oid=76335&sn=Detail|title=Who will replace John Perlman?|date=1 March 2006|publisher=moneyweb]

Perlman was replaced by fellow SAFM presenters, Jeremy Maggs and Tsepiso Makwetla.

References