Extended sympathy

Extended sympathy in welfare economics refers to interpersonal value judgments of the form that social state "x" for person "A" is ranked better than, worse than, or as good as social state "y" for person "B" (Arrow, 1963, pp. 114-15). (For example: better your marginal income should be lower by the same amount that person "B" 's income rises.) Here any characteristics that define each person (skills, aptitudes, etc.) are distinguished from the rest of the social state and put on a par with conventional measures of wealth insofar as they affect an extended sympathy judgment.

In his seminal work on social choice theory, Kenneth Arrow (1963) mentions the ancient lineage of extended sympathy in ethical writings and its basic, if informal, character in many welfare judgments. Arrow's book itself (p. 9) uses individual preference orderings rather than real-valued measures of preferences. This excludes "interpersonal comparisons of welfare" in a precise sense (invariance of social choices to linear cardinalizations of individual preference orderings). Extended-sympathy interpersonal comparisons of welfare relax that constraint (Arrow, 1983, pp. 151-2). Such comparisons expand the informational base of welfare-theoretical decisions, as Amartya Sen (1982) has emphasized. Still, variants of Arrow's dictatorial result persist in reformulation (Kotaro Suzumura, 1997, p. 221).

References

* Kenneth J. Arrow, 1951, 2nd ed.,1963, "Social Choice and Individual Values" ISBN 0-300-01364-7
* _____, 1983 [1977), "Extended Sympathy and the Possibility of Social Choice," in "Collected Papers of Kenneth J. Arrow", v. 1, "Social Choice and Justice", pp. 147-61. ISBN 0-674-13760-4
* Amartya Sen, 1982, "Choice, Welfare and Measurement", ch. 11, 12, 15. ISBN 0-262-19214-4
* Kotaro Suzumura, "Interpersonal Comparisons of the Extended Sympathy Type and the Possibility of Social Choice," in K. J. Arrow, A. Sen, and K. Suzumura, ed., 1997, "Social Choice Re-Examined", v. 2, pp. 202-29. ISBN 0-312-12741-3