Wrecking amendment

Wrecking amendment

In legislative debate, a wrecking amendment (also called a poison pill amendment or killer amendment) is an amendment made by a legislator who disagrees with the principles of a bill and who seeks to make it useless (by moving amendments to either make the bill malformed and nonsensical, or to severely change its intent) rather than directly opposing the bill by simply voting against it.

An important character of wrecking amendments is that they are not moved in good faith. The proposer of the amendment would not see the wrecked legislation as good legislation and would still not vote in favour of the legislation when it came to the final vote, even if the amendment were accepted. Motives for making them include allowing more debate, delaying the enactment of the legislation, or just sometimes a straightfoward attempt to make the initiator of the legislation give up.

Some opponents of particular amendments will describe them as wrecking amendments because they regard the amendments as undermining the unity of the original proposal. Proponents of the amendment may seek to deny the charge by saying that the original proposal brings together different steps, and while personally they oppose all the parts, some parts are even worse than others and legislators should have an opportunity to consider them separately.

Wrecking amendments can pick up more votes than motions against, because observers tend to focus on who voted in favour and against the Bill in the final count, rather than looking at the amendments made during the passage through the legislature. Therefore it can be a wise tactic to try to introduce wrecking amendments at as many opportunities as possible.

Recent examples of wrecking amendments include the United Kingdom's Gender Recognition Act 2004, which was brought forward to enable legal recognition of the new gender of transsexual people and included a specific provision to allow transsexual people to marry. In the House of Lords, Norman Tebbit moved an amendment that would have left other provisions of the Bill intact, but would have forbidden such marriages.

ee also

*Probing amendment


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Civil Partnership Act 2004 — United Kingdom Parliament Long title An act to make provision for and in connection with civil partnership. Statute book chapter 1919 c. 76 …   Wikipedia

  • Wrecker — The Wrecker, wrecker or wrecking may refer to:* Wrecking (shipwreck) is the practice of taking valuables from a shipwreck which has foundered near or close to shore * Wrecker (comics) is a Marvel Comics supervillain * Wrecking (Soviet crime) was… …   Wikipedia

  • 2004 in LGBT rights — EventsJanuary* January 1 ** Same sex marriage in Australia: ***Tasmanian laws come into effect recognising civil unions between same sex couples. Tasmania becomes the first Australian state to enact such laws. * January 7 Illinois Gov. Rod… …   Wikipedia

  • Parliament Acts — The Parliament Acts are two Acts of Parliament of the United Kingdom, passed in 1911 and 1949, that form part of the Constitution of the United Kingdom. [An earlier Act of the Convention Parliament in 1660, entitled An Act for removing and… …   Wikipedia

  • Poison pill — is a term referring to any strategy, generally in business or politics, to increase the likelihood of negative results over positive ones for a party that attempts any kind of takeover. It derives from its original meaning of a literal poison… …   Wikipedia

  • Gender Recognition Act 2004 — The Gender Recognition Act 2004 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom that allows transsexual or transgender people to change their legal gender. It came into effect on April 4, 2005.Operation of the lawThe Act gives transsexual… …   Wikipedia

  • Rider (legislation) — In legislative procedure, a rider is an additional provision added to a bill or other measure under the consideration by a legislature, having little connection with the subject matter of the bill.[1] Riders are usually created as a tactic to… …   Wikipedia

  • Higher Education Act 2004 — The Higher Education Act 2004 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom which introduced several changes to the higher education system in the United Kingdom, the most important and controversial being a major change to the funding of… …   Wikipedia

  • Detta O'Cathain, Baroness O'Cathain — Detta O Cathain, Baroness O Cathain, OBE (b. 2 February 1938, Laurel Hill, County Limerick) is an Irish born British businesswoman and politician. She has been a director of many companies, including Midland Bank plc, Tesco plc, British Airways… …   Wikipedia

  • Irish Land Acts — British Prime Minister William Gladstone had taken up the Irish Question in part to win the general election of 1868 by uniting the Liberal Party behind this single issue. The shock of Fenian violence, especially in England , as well as the… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”