The Troublesome Reign of King John

"The Troublesome Reign of King John" (c. 1589) is an Elizabethan history play, generally accepted by scholars as the source and model that William Shakespeare employed for his own "King John" (c. 1596). [Geoffrey Bullough, ed., "Narrative and Dramatic Sources of Shakespeare," 8 Volumes, New York, Columbia University Press, 1957-75; Vol. 4, pp. 4-24 and 72-151.] [F. E. Halliday, "A Shakespeare Companion 1564–1964," Baltimore, Penguin, 1964; pp. 503-4.]

The play was printed three times in quarto in Shakespeare's era:

Q1, 1591, was published by the stationer Sampson Clarke, with no attribution of authorship. The title page of Q1 states that the play was performed by Queen Elizabeth's Men. Although "The Troublesome Reign" is not an exceptionally long play, about 300 lines longer than Shakespeare's, the initial publication split the play into two parts. (The scholarly literature often refers to Parts 1 and 2 of the play as a result.)

Q2, 1611, was published by John Helme (printed by Valentine Simmes); the authorship was assigned to "W. Sh." In this edition the first quarto's artificial division into two parts was removed.

Q3, 1622, was published by Thomas Dewes (printed by Augustine Matthews), as the work of "W. Shakespeare."

Some 19th-century critics accepted the 1622 attribution to Shakespeare; among twentieth-century commentators, E. B. Everitt has defended the Shakespearean attribution. [Terence P. Logan and Denzell S. Smith, eds., "The Predecessors of Shakespeare: A Survey and Bibliography of Recent Stuides in English Renaissance Drama," Lincoln, NE, University of Nebraska Press, 1973; p. 182.] Candidates put forward for the author of "The Troublesome Reign" include Christopher Marlowe, Robert Greene, Thomas Lodge, and George Peele, among others, alone or in various collaborative combinations; no scholarly consensus has been achieved.

The main historical sources for "The Troublesome Reign" are thought to be the "Chronicles" of Raphael Holinshed and "Foxe's Book of Martyrs", and perhaps Richard Grafton's "Chronicle at Large", which recapitulates much of the material in John Foxe's book.

References