John Laws (judge)

John Laws (judge)

Infobox Politician
honorific-prefix = The Right Honourable

name = Sir John Laws,
Lord Justice Laws
honorific-suffix =


imagesize =
order =
term_start =
term_end =
deputy =
predecessor =
successor =
office2 =
term_start2 =
term_end2 =
leader2 =
predecessor2 =
successor2 =
constituency_MP3 =
majority3 =
term_start3 =
term_end3 =
predecessor3 =
successor3 =
birth_date =
birth_place =
death_date =
death_place =
nationality = British
party =
spouse =
relations =
children =
residence =
alma_mater =
occupation =
profession =
religion =


website =
footnotes =

Sir John Grant McKenzie Laws (born 10 May 1945), styled The Rt Hon. Lord Justice Laws, has been a Lord Justice of Appeal since 1999, at which time he was also, as is customary for Lords Justices of Appeal, sworn of the Privy Council.

Educated at Durham School and Exeter College, Oxford, he was First Junior Treasury Counsel (Common Law) and then since 1992 a Judge of the High Court of Justice of England and Wales, Queen's Bench Division.

Sir John Laws is notable for his extra-judicial writings in the law journal Public Law. His most notable contribution, "Law and Democracy", asserts that the constitution would be undemocratic if it gave all the power under it to the elected government. Therefore it is the constitution, and not Parliament, that should be sovereign in the British constitution. He posits that the constitution must create a "higher-order law" in which human rights and constitutional fundamentals in a democracy can be protected by the courts against the abuses of government. This position stems from a fundamental distrust of the political constitution in holding the executive to account. It is similar in form to Lord Hailsham's claim that in Britain there is an "elective dictatorship" (see "The Dilemma of Democracy"). Sir John does not see this shift to the legal sphere as being anti-democratic because judges uphold apolitical values that no politician would contest and are above the arguments that take place in the political sphere between politicians of political parties.

These statements are certainly controversial and have been fiercely rebutted by academics such as John Griffith and Martin Loughlin, both professors at the London School of Economics. The essential arguments made by these authors are to the effect that the metaphysical principles that Sir John cites are highly contentious. A good example of this is Laws' love of freedom of expression. When is it right for racist or sexist comments to be illegal? Whilst for Griffith it should be up to a democratically elected legislature to decide such tricky moral issues, for Laws it is firmly a matter of law for the judges to decide. The problem with the latter approach, according to Griffith, stems from the fact that judges cannot be removed if the decisions they make are judged to be wrong by citizens of a polity. For Laws on the other hand, such counter-majoritarianism is a beneficial aspect of the law, which acts to protect those that are vulnerable in society against the tyranny of the majority.

Cases Presided Over

Thoburn v Sunderland City Council - Perhaps Sir Johns' most famous decision, and extremely controversial in the public law sphere. In it he recognises principles in common law contrary to parliamentary supremacy.

R v Somerset County Council, ex parte Fewings-- Sir John sat in the first instance hearing of this historic case, concerning the legality of a decision made to prohibit hunting on a small area of land, which the Council had acquired, and was argued to maintain under s120(1(b) Local Government Act 1972.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • John Bradshaw (judge) — John Bradshaw (1602 October 31, 1659) was an English judge. He is most notable for his role in the trial of King Charles I. Early lifeJohn Bradshaw (spelt with a final e in contemporary documents) the second son of Henry Bradshaw and Mary Marbury …   Wikipedia

  • John Randolph of Roanoke — For other people named John Randolph, see John Randolph (disambiguation). John Randolph of Roanoke Randolph as he appears at the National Portrait Gallery in Washington, D.C. 8th …   Wikipedia

  • John C. Montana — (born Giovanni Montana) (July 1, 1893 March 18, 1964) was a Buffalo, New York labor racketeer, political fixer, and elected politician who eventually became the underboss and/or consiglieri of the Buffalo crime family. Born in Montedoro, Sicily,… …   Wikipedia

  • John F. Kelly (politician) — John F. Kelly Born 1950 Allegiance United States of America …   Wikipedia

  • John J. McGilvra — (July 11, 1827 1903) was a prominent lawyer and judge in late 19th century Seattle, Washington. Rev. H.K. Hines, D.D. in An Illustrated History of the State of Washington (1893) described him as the oldest member of the legal profession in… …   Wikipedia

  • John Scott, 1st Earl of Eldon — (4 June 1751 ndash; 13 January 1838), Lord High Chancellor of Great Britain, was born in Newcastle upon Tyne. His grandfather, William Scott of Sandgate, a suburb of Newcastle, was clerk to a fitter, a sort of water carrier and broker of coals.… …   Wikipedia

  • John White Brockenbrough — (December 23, 1806 February 20, 1877) was a Virginia lawyer, federal judge, and educator.His parents were William Brockenbrough and Judith Robinson White Brockenbrough. His sister was Judith White Brockenbrough McGuire, who wrote Diary of a… …   Wikipedia

  • John M. Tyson — John Marsh Tyson (born 14 July 1953) is an American judge, currently a judge on the North Carolina Court of Appeals. He was eliminated in a non partisan primary for re election in 2008, in which he came in third behind Sam J. Ervin, IV and… …   Wikipedia

  • John L. Morrison — John Loyal Morrison (Sept. 10, 1863 May 18, 1926) founded the controversial Duluth, Minnesota newspaper Ripsaw . His editorial attacks on area politicians were so unrelenting that a state law was passed specifically to shut down his paper. The… …   Wikipedia

  • John Calvin — Barcelona, Spain (1554) Born Jean Cauvin 10 July 1509(1509 07 10) Noyon, Picardy, Kingdom of France …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”