Frank Kinney Holbrook

Frank Kinney Holbrook (born c.1874 in Tipton, Iowa; date of death unknown) was the first black intercollegiate athlete at the University of Iowa. He played on the Iowa football team and lettered in both football and track in 1895 and 1896. He was Iowa's leading scorer in 1896 and led the Hawkeyes to their first football conference title in school history.

Background

Frank Holbrook lettered in track and football for Iowa in 1895. How he came to be a part of the football team is not widely known. It is true, however, that in 1895, Iowa nearly did not field an official team. The school Athletic Board ruled that recognition would not be granted until the team paid off its debts, and emergency fundraising was needed for the team to even be formed that season.

To save money, however, the school did not hire a head coach. Practices were reportedly disorganized and sloppy, and the 1895 Hawkeyes posted a poor 2-5 record. Iowa football would never go without a professional head coach again. It was in this season of uncertainty that Frank Holbrook first participated in the Hawkeye football program.

The Ivy League was the premier conference in college football at that time, so Iowa hired former Pennsylvania star A.E. Bull as their head coach for the 1896 season. Bull’s arrival made Hawkeye fans optimistic that Iowa could bounce back from the disastrous 1895 campaign.

The 1896 Season

Frank Holbrook returned for his second season in 1896 and was soon seen as Iowa's best ball carrier. Holbrook was a champion sprinter and Iowa’s best defensive man. He was described as "one of the best halfbacks in the west. He was generally given the ball when a good gain was needed on the last down. His line bucking was excellent. In falling on the ball after a fumble, he has his superior yet to meet. His ability lay in great part in his strength and sprinting qualities." He was also Iowa’s first black football player and, as a result, a target for opposing teams.

Iowa started the 1896 season with a 32-0 win over Drake, with Holbrook rushing for four touchdowns. Though Iowa would suffer a 6-0 loss at Chicago, the Chicago Times-Herald was complimentary, especially of Holbrook. "Iowa’s star work was done by Holbrook. It was brilliant. He made one run of forty yards through a forest of Chicago tackles, and a couple of sprints of thirty yards. Iowa always worked him when it was necessary to make a gain to keep the ball."

Four years earlier, Iowa had joined its first football conference. The conference, titled the Western Interstate University Football Association, had four members: Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas, and Missouri. The four schools played each other every year, with the winner of the round-robin series each year declared the conference champion. Iowa went 0-3 against their conference foes in 1895, being outscored by a combined score of 92-0.

In 1896, Iowa snapped a five game conference losing streak by beating Kansas 6-0. With eight minutes remaining in a scoreless game, Iowa had the ball at the Kansas 45 yard line. Iowa lined up quickly and snapped the ball without a signal. The ball was pitched to Frank Holbrook who sprinted 45 yards for the lone touchdown. After the extra points (touchdowns were then worth four points, and the extra points try was worth two points), Iowa held a 6-0 lead, which they maintained for the win. [ 75 Years With The Fighting Hawkeyes, by Bert McCrane & Dick Lamb, Page 11 (ASIN: B0007E01F8) ]

The 1896 Missouri Game

After another easy non-conference win, Iowa carried their 4-1 record into Columbia, Missouri, for a game with the Tigers. Missouri had won a share of the conference title the past three years, from 1893 to 1985. Missouri alumni demanded that Iowa play the game without Frank Holbrook. Coach Bull refused and stated that there would be no game if Holbrook were not allowed to play. After all, he was the Hawkeyes’ best player.

The Iowa City Vidette-Reporter (the University of Iowa's student newspaper) described the scene:

"Probably never in the history of professionalism or amateur sports, either east or west, has such a disgraceful exhibition been given as that at Columbia yesterday, when the football teams of the Universities of Missouri and Iowa attempted to play their league game.

"It was evident even before the game that Missouri had no intention of giving fair play to Iowa. Alumni of Missouri could be heard in the corridors of the hotel at which the Iowa team was staying, and in other public places, saying in terms too offensive to print that they hoped the Missouri team would kill the negro.

"Iowa’s team had not yet got on the gridiron before the students and townspeople commenced to yell, ‘There’s the damn negro!’ and ‘The Tigers will kill the negro!’ Holbrook seemed not to hear these cries."

Members of the Missouri crowd brought clubs, canes, and similar objects to the game. The Vidette-Reporter continued:

"The line of demarcation between the students and hoodlums could not be drawn. Evidently from the concern depicted on their faces, and from their expressions of regret, there were some students who deplored the situation but they seemed to be so in the minority that their expressions were very feeble, and none made the least effort to quiet the crowd.

"But had this demonstration of ungentlemanliness been all it would hardly have deserved mention. When Missouri’s team came on the field, they were heartily cheered with the Tigers’ yell, followed by appeals from the rooters to individual players to ‘kill the nigger’."

And under these circumstances, the game began.

When Holbrook tackled a favorite Tiger player, the canes and clubs in the crowd were exposed and ready. When Holbrook reportedly made numerous brilliant tackles and runs, the players tackling him were encouraged with cheers of "Kill him, kill him!" The Vidette-Reporter continued,

"And it was evident that each man tried to do as he was bid by his admiring supporters, but never once did Holbrook show the least intimidation.

"Nor was all the venom spent on Holbrook. There was hardly a man on Iowa’s team who did not receive a cowardly blow from the Tigers. Several were hit while on the ground. One man received at least three blows from the fists of the Tigers. Not for ten seconds did one of Iowa’s men forget himself or lose his temper. At all times they placed themselves near and about Holbrook."

Eight minutes into the second half, the officials whistled a play dead. A Tiger player, claiming not to hear the whistle, scooped the ball up and raced for the end zone. After about forty yards, Frank Holbrook chased him down and tackled him. The officials insisted the ball be brought back to where the play was whistled dead. At this, one of the Missouri players punched an official, who had to leave the game.

Through it all, the Hawks kept their cool. Iowa won the game, 12-0, on two touchdowns, one by halfback Joe Meyers and one by Frank Holbrook. [ University of Iowa Football, by Chuck Bright, Pages 43-45 (ISBN 0-87397-233-3) ]

Iowa refused to play Missouri again until 1902. Before a 1910 game with Missouri, Missouri officials warned Iowa coach Jesse Hawley not to bring black tackle Archie Alexander to the game. Furious, Hawley postponed the Iowa-Missouri football series indefinitely. It has not been resumed since.

The 1896 Conference Title

Two and a half weeks later, on Thanksgiving Day, the Hawkeyes carried a 6-1 record into a game against Nebraska to determine the Western Interstate conference champion. However, a mixture of rain, sleet, and snow prevented any scoring, and the game ended in a scoreless tie. Athletic officials from both schools, therefore, agreed to replay the conference title game two days later on Saturday.

In the rematch, Iowa won their first ever conference title by defeating Nebraska, 6-0. Iowa won the game on a thirty yard touchdown run by Frank Holbrook. Iowa finished the year 7-1-1, and Holbrook finished his senior year with 12 touchdowns. [ Stadium Stories: Iowa Hawkeyes, by Buck Turnbull, Page 70 (ISBN 0-7627-3819-7) ]

Name Confusion

The correct name of the first black football player at the University of Iowa is Frank Kinney Holbrook, not Carleton William Holbrook. The apparent misinformation may have begun around 1939 when the University’s athletics department released a commemorative publication about Iowa football referring to “C.W. Holbrook.” C.W. Holbrook was the only other student with that last name enrolled at the University of Iowa during the mid-1890’s, according to general catalogs issued by the University at the time. However, C.W. Holbrook was a law student from Manchester, Iowa, and was not on the football team. Frank Kinney Holbrook (called “Kinney” by his teammates, according to one edition of the Hawkeye yearbook) was a sophomore when he competed as a halfback in the fall of 1896. According to University alumni records, he did not graduate. C.W. Holbrook graduated in 1897 and his name is the only Holbrook that appears in alumni lists from that period. As a result, it is possible that C.W. Holbrook’s name, and not that of Frank Kinney Holbrook, was brought forward by mistake. Numerous publications subsequently repeated the error, including the McGrane and Bright titles cited below. Bright’s work has no citations; McGrane quotes an undated Chicago Times-Herald article which uses only Holbrook’s last name.

References

Hilton, Bob. "Holbrook Made History as Tipton and U of I Player." Cedar Rapids [Iowa] Gazette, June 30, 1996Schorpp, Doug. "White Towns, Black History." Quad City Times [Davenport, Iowa] , Feb. 26, 1995