Possessive antecedent

Possessive antecedent

In English grammar, a pronoun has a possessive antecedent if its antecedent (the noun that it refers to) appears in a possessive case; for example, in the following sentence, "Winston Churchill" is a possessive antecedent, serving as it does as the antecedent for the pronoun "him":

:Winston Churchill's history shows him to have been a good writer.

In the 1960s [cite web | last = Nunberg | first = Geoffrey | year = 2003 | url = http://www-csli.stanford.edu/~nunberg/possessives.html | title = The Bloody Crossroads of Grammar and Politics | publisher = New York Time | accessdate = March 22 | accessyear = 2006] , some usage guides started to reject the use of possessive antecedents. These guides argue that a pronoun's antecedent cannot be a noun in a possessive construct; in this case, they contend that "Winston Churchill", embedded as it is in the construct "Winston Churchill's", cannot serve as the antecedent for the pronoun "him".

The basis for this contention is that a pronoun's antecedent must be a noun, so that if "Winston Churchill's" is an adjective, then a pronoun cannot refer back to it. For example, consider the following sentence:

:The big green history shows him to have been a good writer.

Here, "him" lacks any clear antecedent — it certainly cannot refer back to "the big green" — and the sentence must be ungrammatical, or at least meaningless, unless a previous sentence provides an antecedent.

This rule does not reflect ordinary English usage, and it is commonly ignored (intentionally or otherwise) even by those who have heard of it. However, the concern that it reflects is meaningful in a sentence such as this one:

:I talked to William's brother today; it seems that he is not feeling well.

Here, if possessive antecedents are possible, then it is not clear whether "he" refers to William or to his brother. Many grammarians suggest that in this kind of sentence, "he" should not be used at all. (Note that "it" here is a dummy pronoun, and requires no antecedent.)

References

ee also

* Origo
* Deixis


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Last antecedent rule — The last antecedent rule is a doctrine of interpretation of a statute, by which Referential and qualifying phrases, where no contrary intention appears, refer solely to the last antecedent. [ [http://adamsdrafting.com/downloads/g and m 082807.pdf …   Wikipedia

  • Generic antecedent — Generic antecedents are representatives of classes, indicated by a reference in ordinary language (most often a pronoun), where gender is typically unknown or irrelevant. [Mark Balhorn, [http://eng.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/32/2/79 The… …   Wikipedia

  • Syntaxe du hongrois — Article principal : Hongrois. Hongrois Répartition géographique et statut Histoire Variantes régionales Phonologie et graphie Grammaire Morphologie …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Reflexive pronoun — Herself redirects here. For the toy elf, see Herself the Elf. Himself redirects here. For other uses, see Himself (disambiguation). Oneself redirects here. For the hip hop artist, see Oneself (artist). Ourselves redirects here. For the 1988 punk… …   Wikipedia

  • French pronouns — are inflected to indicate their role in the sentence (subject, direct object, and so on), as well as to reflect the person, gender, and number of their referents. While English draws some of these distinctions as well, French draws them in many… …   Wikipedia

  • Luganda language — language name=Luganda nativename=Ganda familycolor=Niger Congo states=Uganda region=Mainly Buganda region speakers=First language: 3.01 million (1991) Second language: 100,000 (1991) fam2=Atlantic Congo fam3=Volta Congo fam4=Benue Congo… …   Wikipedia

  • HEBREW LANGUAGE — This entry is arranged according to the following scheme: pre biblical biblical the dead sea scrolls mishnaic medieval modern period A detailed table of contents precedes each section. PRE BIBLICAL nature of the evidence the sources phonology… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Relative clause — A relative clause is a subordinate clause that modifies a noun. For example, the noun phrase the man who wasn t there contains the noun man , which is modified by the relative clause who wasn t there . In many languages, relative clauses are… …   Wikipedia

  • Hungarian grammar — Hungarian language Closeup view of a Hungarian keybo …   Wikipedia

  • Grammatical gender — This article is about noun classes. For uses of language associated with men and women, see Language and gender. For methods of minimizing the use of gendered forms, see Gender neutral language. For other uses, see Gender (disambiguation).… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
… Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”