Simpler Syntax

Simpler Syntax

"Simpler Syntax" is the title of a 2005 book by Ray Jackendoff and Peter Culicover. The authors argue that modern minimalist syntax is going in the wrong direction, adopting ever more complex structures and derivations, and making overly strong assumptions about linguistic universals. Richard Kayne's theory of antisymmetry is one example they cite. Antisymmetry proposes specifier-complement-head as the "basic" branching order, based on the notion of an asymmetric c-command. This leads to rather complex derivations of certain phenomena, such as Heavy NP shift. For Cullicover and Jackendoff, the difference in order between (1) and (2) is simply a different ordering of the children of the Verb Phrase.

:(1) I gave the books I bought yesterday to John:(2) I gave to John the books I bought yesterday

In antisymmetric theories, a number of movements are required to derive both structures, with the "shifted" structure in (2) derived by one or more additional movements.

Culicover and Jackendoff propose that the syntactic, semantic and phonological components of the language faculty are all "generative"; that is, there is no asymmetric dependence between any of these components. In contrast, it is traditionally assumed that syntax is the only generative component, the function of the semantic and phonological components being merely to "interpret" syntactic structures. Culicover and Jackendoff suggest that there is a flexible, constraint-based mapping between these different components which does not privilege any one over the others.

External links

* [http://people.brandeis.edu/~jackendo/Simpler_Syntax_Chapter1.pdf Simpler Syntax chapter 1]
* [http://books.google.com/books?id=Epj8QyX_1KAC&dq=simpler+syntax&printsec=frontcover&source=web&ots=OTZzG9XMDn&sig=oGyhC8FsKUQE8A0yNJUENxOa9Cg#PPP1,M1 Simpler Syntax selections online]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Syntax — Syntactic redirects here. For another meaning of the adjective, see Syntaxis. For other uses, see Syntax (disambiguation). Linguistics …   Wikipedia

  • C Sharp syntax — The correct title of this article is C# syntax. The substitution or omission of the # sign is because of technical restrictions. Main article: C Sharp (programming language) This article describes the syntax of the C# programming language. The… …   Wikipedia

  • C syntax — The syntax of the C programming language is a set of rules that specifies whether the sequence of characters in a file is conforming C source code. The rules specify how the character sequences are to be chunked into tokens (the lexical grammar) …   Wikipedia

  • Thematische Rolle — In der generativen Grammatik, insbesondere der Rektions und Bindungstheorie und der Standardtheorie der Transformationsgrammatik, ist eine Theta Rolle oder θ Rolle das formale Mittel, um eine syntaktische Argumentenstruktur (die Anzahl und Art… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Theta-Raster — In der generativen Grammatik, insbesondere der Rektions und Bindungstheorie und der Standardtheorie der Transformationsgrammatik, ist eine Theta Rolle oder θ Rolle das formale Mittel, um eine syntaktische Argumentenstruktur (die Anzahl und Art… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Theta-Theorie — In der generativen Grammatik, insbesondere der Rektions und Bindungstheorie und der Standardtheorie der Transformationsgrammatik, ist eine Theta Rolle oder θ Rolle das formale Mittel, um eine syntaktische Argumentenstruktur (die Anzahl und Art… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Theta-Rolle — In der generativen Grammatik, insbesondere der Rektions und Bindungstheorie und der Standardtheorie der Transformationsgrammatik, ist eine Theta Rolle oder θ Rolle das formale Mittel, um eine syntaktische Argumentenstruktur (die Anzahl und Art… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Theta role — In Generative grammar, (in particular Government and binding theory and the Standard Theory of Transformational Grammar) a theta role or θ role is the formal device for representing syntactic argument structure (the number and type of noun… …   Wikipedia

  • Heavy NP shift — is a term used within the tradition of transformational grammar to describe a process which shifts Noun phrases (NPs) to the right of their usual position under certain circumstances. Typically, the process applies to large, complex NPs (i.e. NPs …   Wikipedia

  • Document Type Definition — (DTD) is a set of markup declarations that define a document type for SGML family markup languages (SGML, XML, HTML). DTDs were a precursor to XML schema and have a similar function, although different capabilities. DTDs use a terse formal syntax …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”