R v Burgess; Ex parte Henry

R v Burgess; Ex parte Henry

Infobox Court Case
name=R v Burgess; Ex parte Henry
court=High Court of Australia


date_decided=November 10 1936
full_name=The King v Burgess; Ex parte Henry
citations= [http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/high_ct/55clr608.html (1934) 55 CLR 608]
judges= Latham CJ, Starke, Dixon, Evatt & McTiernan JJ
prior_actions=none
subsequent_actions=none
opinions=(5:0) The Commonwealth government's power to regulate interstate trade and commerce does not extend to intrastate trade and commerce (per Latham CJ, Starke, Dixon, Evatt & McTiernan JJ)

(3:2) The implementation of an international treaty is valid where the treaty is bona fide and the subject matter is of international concern (per Latham CJ, Evatt & McTiernan JJ; Starke & Dixon JJ dissenting)

"R v Burgess; Ex parte Henry" (1936) 55 CLR 608 was a case decided in the High Court of Australia regarding the scope of the trade and commerce power and the external affairs power, in sections 51(i) and 51(xxix) respectively, of the Constitution.

Background

Henry Goya Henry was an aviator who had his aviation licence suspended. Two days after the suspension he nevertheless flew a plane, setting off from Mascot airport and then flying around, over and under the Sydney Harbour Bridge. He was convicted of breaching regulation 6 of the federal "Air Navigation Regulations" which prohibited an unlicensed person from flying an aircraft "within the limits of the Commonwealth". The regulations were made pursuant to section 4 of the "Aircraft Navigation Act 1920", which authorised the Governor-General to make regulations to give effect to the "Convention for the Regulation of Aerial Navigation". He challenged the constitutional validity of the regulation.

Decision

External affairs

The Constitution gave no express power to the Commonwealth to regulate aviation, a subject that did not exist when the Constitution was drafted at the end of the 19th century. The Commonwealth argued that its rules were made in pursuance of an international convention and were, therefore, laws with respect to external affairs.

The majority (Latham CJ, Evatt & Mctiernan JJ) took a broad view of the external affairs power, and accepted that the Commonwealth could enact legislation pursuant to a "bona fide" international treaty. Latham CJ dismissed arguments attempting to exclude the external affairs power from encompassing certain domestic subjects. Evatt and McTiernan JJ concluded that once a treaty was signed and entered into, the provisions contained therein were brought under the external affairs power by virtue of their inclusion in the treaty.

The minority (Starke & Dixon JJ) took a narrower approach, with Starke J arguing that the treaty had to be 'of sufficient international significance to make it a legitimate subject for international co-operation and agreement'. Dixon J considered that the power of the Commonwealth to implement treaties through legislation was necessarily limited by the federal nature of the Constitution, so the subject matter of the treaty upon which it was based had to be 'indisputably international in character'.

Even under the broad view of the external affairs power, the Court invalidated the regulations on the grounds that they did not carry out and give effect to the conventions of the treaty.

Trade and commerce

The only other power that seemed available was 'trade and commerce with other countries and among the States'. Mr Henry however, had not been flying from or to any other state or country. The Commonwealth argued that the commingling in air routes and airports of aircraft proceeding intrastate with those travelling interstate, enabled it to control all aircraft. The Court rejected the commingling argument, preferring to maintain an arbitrary distinction between interstate and intrastate trade. Mr Henry could not be prevented by the Commonwealth from stunt-flying around Sydney Harbour under the commerce power. The Constitution clearly distinguished between intrastate and interstate commerce, and confined the Commonwealth to the latter.

Result

The Commonwealth held a referendum in 1937 to have the Constitution amended to give it express power over aviation. Although the measure received 53.56% of the 'yes' vote nationwide, it did not gain a majority support in a majority of states, with only Victoria and Queensland supporting the measure. [http://www.aec.gov.au/_content/when/referendums/dates.htm]

ee also

* Section 51(i) of the Australian Constitution
* Section 51(xxix) of the Australian Constitution
* Australian constitutional law

References

* Winterton, G. et al. "Australian federal constitutional law: commentary and materials", 1999. LBC Information Services, Sydney.

External links

* [http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/high_ct/55clr608.html Full text of the decision]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • List of High Court of Australia cases — This is a chronological list of significant cases decided by the High Court of Australia. =The Griffith Court: 1903 1919= *Dalgarno v Hannah (1903): the first case decided by the Court * Jumbunna Coalmine (1908): Registration of Trade Unions… …   Wikipedia

  • 1936 in Australia — Infobox Australian year monarch = George V, then Edward VIII, then George VI governor general = Isaac Isaacs, then Alexander Hore Ruthven pm =Joseph Lyons population = 6,778,372 australian = elections =Western Australia See also: 1935 in… …   Wikipedia

  • High Court of Australia — Established 1903 Jurisdiction Australia Location Ca …   Wikipedia

  • Koowarta v Bjelke-Petersen — Infobox Court Case name=Koowarta v Bjelke Petersen court=High Court of Australia date decided=May 11 1982 full name= Koowarta v Bjelke Petersen Ors; Queensland v Commonwealth citations= [http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/high… …   Wikipedia

  • Anexo:Episodios de Los Soprano — Los Soprano es una serie de televisión estadounidense, creada y producida por David Chase. Fue emitida en Estados Unidos entre el 10 de enero de 1999 y el 10 de junio de 2007 por el canal de televisión por cable HBO.[1] La serie consta de 86… …   Wikipedia Español

  • David I de Escocia — Saltar a navegación, búsqueda David I Rey de Escocia …   Wikipedia Español

  • James Joyce — James Joyce …   Wikipedia Español

  • Olivia Manning — Nombre completo Olivia Mary Manning Nacimiento 2 de marzo de 1908 …   Wikipedia Español

  • Historia de la novela — Portada de la 4.ª edición del Quijote (1605), posiblemente la primera novela moderna. La novela es, según la RAE, una obra literaria en prosa en la que se narra una acción fingida en todo o en parte, y cuyo fin es causar placer estético a los… …   Wikipedia Español

  • Teatro isabelino — Teatro isabelino …   Wikipedia Español

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”