R. v. Turcotte

R. v. Turcotte

SCCInfoBox
case-name=R. v. Turcotte
full-case-name=Her Majesty the Queen v. Thomas Turcotte
heard-date=May 10, 2005
decided-date=September 30, 2005
citations= [2005] 2 S.C.R. 519, 2005 SCC 50, 200 C.C.C. (3d) 289, 31 C.R. (6th) 197
SCC=2004-2005
Unanimous=Abella

"R. v. Turcotte", [2005] 2 S.C.R. 519 is a leading Supreme Court of Canada decision on the common law right to silence and the conditions to waive that right.

Background

Three men who worked at a ranch in British Columbia were murdered with an axe. Thomas Turcotte, a work-hand at the ranch, claims to have found the bodies of the three men but that he did not kill them. He had gone to the police to tell them to send someone to the ranch, but he would not explain why, even at the insistence of the police. When the bodies were found Turcotte was charged with murder.

At trial the judge instructed the jury that his silence was admissible as evidence of "post-offence conduct", from which guilt could be inferred. All of the evidence was circumstantial, but Turcotte was found guilty of murder.

The defence appealed on the grounds that silence could not be "post-offence conduct". The British Columbia Court of Appeal agreed and overturned the conviction.

Opinion of the Court

Justice Rosalie Abella wrote the decision of the unanimous Court. She held that silence could not be part of "post-offence conduct" and ordered a new trial. She noted that to allow such evidence would make the right to silence hollow of meaning.

On the issue of whether Turcotte had waived his right to silence, Abella found that he had not. "The right to choose whether to speak is retained throughout the interaction." Thus, the right remains even when the accused agrees to answer some questions but not others.

"Post-offence conduct" must provide some circumstantial evidence of guilt. The law does not impose any duty to speak and so any refusal to do so cannot imply guilt. Consequently, silence can rarely be admitted as evidence of post-offence conduct.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases (McLachlin Court)

External links

*


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Turcotte — or Turcott is a surname, and may refer to:* Alfie Turcotte * Arthur Turcotte * Brad Turcotte, the musician Brad Sucks * Darren Turcotte * Élise Turcotte * Gustave Adolphe Narcisse Turcotte * Jean Claude Cardinal Turcotte * Joseph Édouard Turcotte …   Wikipedia

  • Turcotte — ist der Familienname folgender Personen: Darren Turcotte (* 1968), US amerikanischer Eishockeyspieler Donald L. Turcotte (* 1932), US amerikanischer Geophysiker Jean Claude Turcotte (* 1936), Erzbischof von Montréal und Kardinal Maryse Turcotte… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Turcotte — Variante de Turcot (éventuellement matronyme), lui même diminutif de Turc (voir Leturc pour le sens) …   Noms de famille

  • Turcotte — Cette page d’homonymie répertorie les différents sujets et articles partageant un même nom. Turcotte peut désigner : Un patronyme Alfie Turcotte (1965 ) est un joueur de hockey sur glace canado américain. Darren Turcotte (1968 ) est un… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Turcotte, J. G. —    E Commissioner under Seigniorial Tenure law, 186 …   The makers of Canada

  • Jean-Claude Turcotte — infobox cardinalstyles cardinal name=Jean Claude Turcotte dipstyle=His Eminence offstyle=Your Eminence See=Montréal|Jean Claude Turcotte, O.C. (born June 26, 1936) is a Roman Catholic cardinal and Archbishop of Montréal. His full title is… …   Wikipedia

  • Alfie Turcotte — Données clés Nationalité  États Unis  Canada …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Louis-philippe turcotte — (1842 1878) est un historien canadien. Louis Philippe Turcotte est né le 11 juillet 1842 à Saint Jean, Île d’Orléans. Son père était agriculteur et, comme il arrive souvent à ceux qui habitent près du fleuve, marin à ses heures. Cadet d’une… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Louis-Philippe Turcotte — Pour les articles homonymes, voir Turcotte. Louis Philippe Turcotte (1842 1878) est un historien canadien. Louis Philippe Turcotte est né le 11 juillet 1842 à Saint Jean, Île d’Orléans. Son père était agriculteur et, comme il arrive souvent à… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Darren Turcotte — Born March 2, 1968 (1968 03 02) (age 43) Boston, MA, USA Height …   Wikipedia

  • Brad Turcotte — Brad Sucks Brad Turcotte Gründung 2001 Genre Experimental Pop, Pop, Rock Website http://www.bradsucks.net/ …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”