R. v. Brydges

R. v. Brydges

SCCInfoBox
case-name=R. v. Brydges
full-case-name=William Brydges v. Her Majesty The Queen
heard-date=November 10, 1989
decided-date=February 1, 1990
citations= [1990] 1 S.C.R. 190
history=
ruling= Brydges' appeal allowed.
ratio=
SCC=1989-1990
Majority=Lamer J.
JoinMajority=Wilson, Gonthier and Cory JJ.
Concurrence=La Forest J.
JoinConcurrence=L'Heureux-Dubé and McLachlin JJ.
NotParticipating=Dickson C.J. and Sopinka J.
LawsApplied=R. v. Parks (1988), 33 C.R.R. 1; Clarkson v. The Queen, [1986] 1 S.C.R. 383

"R. v. Brydges", [1990] 1 S.C.R. 190 is a leading Supreme Court of Canada decision on the right to retain and instruct counsel under section 10(b) of the "Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms". The Court held that the right imposed a duty upon the police to provide information and access to a legal aid lawyer if needed. From this case came the term "Brydges Counsel" to refer to legal aid lawyers that assist recently arrested individuals.

Background

William Brydges was arrested in Manitoba in relation to a murder in Edmonton. Upon arriving at the police station Brydges was informed of his right to retain and instruct counsel and gave him the opportunity to contact a lawyer. He was put in an interview room and again was given another chance to contact a lawyer. Brydges asked one of the officers if Manitoba had a Legal Aid service as he could not afford a private lawyer. The officer said that he believed so and asked Brydges if he had a reason to contact one. Brydges replied "Not right now, no". After some time in interrogation the accused asked for a Legal Aid lawyer. Once he got in touch with one he was advised not to say anything.

At trial, the judge found that Brydges had made a request for a lawyer at the beginning of the questioning, and that the police did not adequately help Brydges in contacting a lawyer when he first asked about Legal Aid. Thus, it was held that the police violated Brydges' right to counsel under section 10(b) of the Charter, and that the statements he made in the interrogation should be excluded under section 24(2).

On appeal, the Court set aside the verdict and ordered a new trial.

The issue before the Supreme Court was whether there was a violation of section 10(b).

Opinion of the Court

In a four to three decision, the Court held that there was a violation of section 10(b). Lamer, writing for the majority, held that the police have both a duty to inform an accused of their right as well as provide sufficient information on obtaining a duty counsel.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases (Dickson Court)

External links

*


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Brydges — ist der Familienname folgender Personen: David Brydges (* 1949), britischer mathematischer Physiker Egerton Brydges (1762–1837), britischer Bibliograph James Brydges, 1. Duke of Chandos (1673–1744), englischer Edelmann, Bauherr und Mäzen Dies …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Brydges — (spr. Bridsches), Sir Egerton, geb. 1762 in Wooton Court in der Grafschaft Kent, Enkel des Grafen John Bridgewater; er st. 1837 auf seinem Landgute bei Genf. Er schr.: Sonnets and other poems, Lond. 1785; The topographer, 1789–91, 4 Bde.;… …   Pierer's Universal-Lexikon

  • Brydges — George Brydges Rodney Pour les articles homonymes, voir George, Brydges et Rodney. Amiral George Brydges Rodney, par …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Brydges, Sir Samuel Egerton — (1762 1837)    Born between Canterbury and Dover, the second son of Edward Brydges, and educated at Maidstone School, Canterbury, and Queen s College, Cambridge, he was called to the bar but never practiced. He seemed to live under the delusion… …   British and Irish poets

  • Brydges, Sir Samuel Egerton, 1st Baronet — ▪ British general born Nov. 30, 1762, Wootton, Kent, Eng. died Sept. 8, 1837, Geneva       English writer and genealogist chiefly important as the editor of rare Elizabethan and 17th century texts, notably the 17th century writer Edward Phillips… …   Universalium

  • BRYDGES, SIR SAMUEL EGERTON —    English antiquary, born at Wootton House, in Kent; called to the bar, but devoted to literature; was M.P. for Maidstone for six years; lived afterwards and died at Geneva; wrote novels and poems, and edited old English writings of interest… …   The Nuttall Encyclopaedia

  • Brydges, Sir Samuel Egerton — (1762 1837)    Bibliographer and genealogist, ed. at Camb., was called to the Bar in 1787. He wrote some novels and poems, now forgotten, but rendered valuable service by his bibliographical publications, Censura Literaria, Titles and Opinions of …   Short biographical dictionary of English literature

  • William Brydges — was arrested, but not convicted in Canada, for the murder of Elizabeth MacLeod. His case was a Canadian precedent, and created significant controversy after the Supreme Court of Canada upheld his acquittal. He was found to have been denied access …   Wikipedia

  • James Brydges, 1. Duke of Chandos — Henry James Brydges, 1. Duke of Chandos, PC (* 6. Januar 1673 in Dewsall, Herefordshire; † 9. August 1744 in Canons, Whitchurch, Middlesex) war ein britischer Edelmann, Bauherr und Mäzen. His Grace the Duke of Chandos, Ausschnitt aus einem… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Earl Brydges — Earl William Brydges (May 25, 1905 Niagara Falls, Niagara County, New York March 30, 1975 Lewiston, Niagara County, New York) was an American lawyer and politician from New York. He was Majority Leader of the New York State Senate from 1966 to… …   Wikipedia

  • Mount Brydges Bulldogs — Southern Ontario Junior Hockey League City Mount Brydges, Ontario …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
… Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”