R. v. Heywood

R. v. Heywood

case-name=R. v. Heywood
full-case-name=Her Majesty The Queen v. Robert Lorne Heywood
heard-date=April 27, 1994
decided-date=November 24, 1994
citations= [1994] 3 S.C.R. 761
ruling=Appeal dismissed, s.179(1)(b) of Criminal Code was stuckdown.
Majority=Cory J.
JoinMajority=Lamer C.J. and Sopinka, Iacobucci and Major JJ.
Dissent=Gonthier J.
JoinDissent=La Forest, L'Heureux‑Dubé and McLachlin JJ.

"R. v. Heywood" [1994] 3 S.C.R. 761 is a leading Supreme Court of Canada decision on the concept of fundamental justice in section seven of the Charter. The Court found that section 179(1)(b) of the Criminal Code for vagrancy was overbroad and thus violated section 7 and could not be saved under section 1.


In 1987, Heywood was convicted under section 246.1(1) (now s. 271(1)) of the Criminal Code for sexual assault of children. The conviction made him subject to section 179(1)(b) which prevented certain convicted individuals from loitering.

In July 1989, Heywood was arrested in Beacon Hill Park in Victoria for loitering "at or near a playground" under section 179(1). He had been spotted several times previously near the playground carrying a camera with a telephoto lens. Upon arrest the police got a search warrant and found collections of picture of children at play.

At trial, Heywood argued that the law violated section 7, 11(d), 12, and 15 of the Charter. The court found a violation of 7 and 11(d) which was justified under section 1. Heywood was convicted. On appeal, the court affirmed the violations of section 7 and 11(d) but also found that they could not be saved under section 1, and so the conviction was overturned.

Reasons of the Court

In a 5 to 4 decision, the Court dismissed the appeal, finding a section 7 violation that could not be saved. The majority was written by Cory J. with Lamer C.J., Sopinka, Iacobucci, and Major JJ. concurring.

The case turned on the interpretation of the word "loiter" in section 179(1)(b) which states::"179. (1) Every one commits vagrancy who ...::"(b) having at any time been convicted of an offence under section ... section 271..., is found loitering in or near a school ground, playground, public park or bathing area."

Cory states that the word should be given its ordinary, dictionary meaning, which is "to stand idly around, hang around, linger, tarry, saunter, delay, dawdle", and it does not contain any element of malevolent intent. He further claims that such a meaning supports the purpose of the section to protect children. "Malevolent intent" - a lesser degree of intent than unlawful intent - is too broad, vague, and subjective, says Cory.

Given this interpretation, Cory finds that the law infringes the principles of fundamental justice as it is more restrictive than necessary and applies too broadly. That is, "without prior notice to the accused, to too many places, to too many people, for an indefinite period with no possibility of review".


The dissent, written by Gonthier J., with La Forest, L'Heureux-Dubé, and McLachlin JJ. concurring, found that the word "loiter" required an element of "malevolent intent" and therefore was not overbroad and did not violate section 7.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать курсовую

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Heywood's Bank — was a private banking firm established and run in Manchester by members of the Heywood family of Pendleton between 1788 and 1874. Family and Banking History The bank was founded in Manchester by Benjamin Heywood and his two sons Benjamin Arthur… …   Wikipedia

  • Heywood Campbell Broun — Heywood Broun, um 1935 Heywood Campbell Broun (* 7. Dezember 1888 in Brooklyn, New York; † 18. Dezember 1939 in Stamford, Connecticut) war ein US amerikanischer Sportjournalist und Krit …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Heywood (Begriffsklärung) — Heywood ist der Name einer Stadt in England, siehe Heywood Heywood ist der Familienname folgender Personen: Anne Heywood (* 1932 als Violet Pretty), britische Schauspielerin Eddie Heywood (Edward „Eddie“ Heywood junior; 1915–1989), US… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Heywood Hale Broun — Nacimiento 10 de marzo de 1918 …   Wikipedia Español

  • Heywood Broun — Heywood Broun, um 1935 Heywood Campbell Broun (* 7. Dezember 1888 in Brooklyn, New York; † 18. Dezember 1939 in Stamford, Connecticut) war ein US amerikanischer Sportjournalist und Kritiker. Inhaltsverzeichnis …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Heywood Broun — Heywood Campbell Broun /IPA|bɹun/ (December 7 1888 – December 18 1939) was an American journalist. He worked as a sportswriter, newspaper columnist, and editor in New York City. He founded the American Newspaper Guild, now known as The Newspaper… …   Wikipedia

  • Heywood Hale Broun — (March 10, 1918 – September 5, 2001 was an American sportswriter, commentator, and actor. He was born and raised in New York City, the son of writer and film critic Ruth Hale and columnist Heywood Broun. He was educated at private schools and… …   Wikipedia

  • Heywood C.C. — Heywood Cricket Club, based in Heywood, in the Metropolitan Borough of Rochdale, Greater Manchester, are an English cricket team currently playing in the Central Lancashire League.Situated off Aspinall Street and bordering Queens Park Heywood… …   Wikipedia

  • Heywood Hotel — (Остин,США) Категория отеля: Адрес: 1609 East Cesar Chavez, Остин, TX 78702, США …   Каталог отелей

  • Heywood and Royton (UK Parliament constituency) — Heywood and Royton was a parliamentary constituency centred on the Heywood and Royton districts in the north west of Greater Manchester. It returned one Member of Parliament to the House of Commons of the Parliament of the United Kingdom.The… …   Wikipedia

  • Heywood hockey club — is a Men’s Field Hockey Club Based in Heywood, Greater Manchester (England). The club was formed around 15 years ago from various members from other clubs in the Greater Manchester area. The Club merged with Cheatham Hill Club for a short while… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”