- Behavior modification
Behavior modification is the use of empirically demonstrated behavior change techniques to improve behavior, such as altering an individual's behaviors and reactions to stimuli through positive and negative
reinforcementof adaptive behavior and/or the reduction of maladaptive behaviorthrough positive and negative punishment.
The first use of the term behavior modification appears to have been by
Edward Thorndikein 1911. His article "Provisional laws of acquired behavior or learning" makes frequent use of the term "modifying behavior". [Thorndike, E.L. (1911).Provisional laws of acquired behavior or learning. In E.L. Thorndike's" Animal Intelligence". New York, The McMillian Company.] Through early research in the 1940s and the 1950s the term was used by Joseph Wolpe's research group [ Wolpe (1958)Pyschotheraphy by Reciprocal Inhibition] . The experimental tradition in clinical psychology [In A. J. Bachrach (Ed.), Experimental foundations of clinical psychology (pp. 3-25). New York: Basic Books] used it to refer to psychotherapeutic techniques derived from empirical research. It has since come to refer mainly to techniques for increasing adaptive behavior through reinforcement and decreasing maladaptive behavior through punishment (with emphasis on the former). Two related terms are behavior therapy and applied behavior analysis. Emphasizing the empirical roots of behavior modification, some authorsMartin, G., & Pear, J. (2007). Behavior modification: What it is and how to do it (Eighth Edition). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.] consider it to be broader in scope and to subsume the other two categories of behavior change methods. Since techniques derived from behavioral psychology tend to be the most effective in altering behavior, most practitioners consider behavior modification along with behavior therapyand applied behavior analysisto be founded in behaviorism. While behavior modification encompasses applied behavior analysis and typically uses interventions based on the same behavioral principles, many behavior modifiers who are not applied behavior analysts tend to use packages of interventions and do not conduct functional assessments before intervening.
In recent years, the concept of
punishmenthas had many critics, though these critiques tend not to apply to negative punishment(time-outs) and usually apply to the addition of some aversive event. The use of positive punishmentby board-certified behavior analysts is restricted to extreme circumstances when all other forms of treatment have failed and when the behavior to be modified is a danger to the person or to others (see professional practice of behavior analysis). In clinical settings positive punishment is usually restricted using a spray bottle filled with water as an aversive event. When mis-used, extreme punishment can lead to affective (emotional) disorders, as well as to the target of the punishment eventually focusing only on avoiding punishment (i.e., "not getting caught") rather than improving behavior.
Pear and Martin indicate that there are seven characteristics to behavior modification,P 41] They are: :*There is a strong emphasis on defining problems in terms of behavior that can be measured in some way.
:*The treatment techniques are ways of altering an individual's current environment to help that individual function more fully.
:*The methods and rationales can be described precisely.
:*The techniques are often applied in everyday life.
:*The techniques are based largely on principles of learning - specifically
operant conditioningand respondent conditioning
:*There is a strong emphasis on scientific demonstration that a particular technique was responsible for a particular behavior change.
:*There is a strong emphasis on accountability for everyone involved in a behavior modification program.
Therapy and consultation cannot be effective unless the behaviors to be changed are understood within a specific context. [McIntosh, K. & Av-Gay, H. (2007): Implications of Current Research on the Use of Functional Behavior Assessment and Behavior Support Planning in School Systems. "IJBCT," 3.(1), pp.38-49 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org BAO] ] [ Waguespack,A. Vaccaro, T. & Continere, L. (2006). Functional Behavioral Assessment and Intervention with Emotional/Behaviorally Disordered Students: In Pursuit of State of the Art - IJBCT, 2.(4), pp.463-480 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org BAO] ] The process of understanding behavior in context is called functional behavioral assessment. [Roberts, M. (2001). Research in Practice: Practical Approaches to Conducting Functional Analyses that all Educators Can Use. "The Behavior Analyst Today, 3 (1)," pp.83-97 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org] ] Therefore, a functional behavioral assessment is needed before performing behavior modification. One of the most simple yet effective methods of functional behavioral assessment is called the "ABC" approach, where observations are made on Antecedents, Behaviors, and Consequences. In other words, "What comes directly before the behavior?", "What does the behavior look like?", and "What comes directly after the behavior?" Once enough observations are made, the data are analyzed and patterns are identified. If there are consistent antecedents and/or consequences, then an intervention should target them in order to increase or decrease the target behavior. This method has formed the core of
positive behavior supportfor children in school from both regular education and special education.
Behavior modifiers like to employ a variety of evidenced-based techniques. These techniques intervene at all levels of context. For example, given specific setting events for a behavior, a behavior modifier may develop a neutralizing routine to eliminate that setting. If a behavior pattern has a specific antecedent of trigger, then an antecedent control strategy can be developed to train new behavior in the presence of the trigger. If a problem behavior readily occurs because it achieves some function, then an alternative behavior can be instructed and trained to occur in the context of the trigger. [McIntosh, K. & Av-Gay, H. (2007): Implications of Current Research on the Use of Functional Behavior Assessment and Behavior Support Planning in School Systems. "IJBCT," 3.(1), pp.38-49 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org BAO] ] [ Waguespack,A. Vaccaro, T. & Continere, L. (2006). Functional Behavioral Assessment and Intervention with Emotional/Behaviorally Disordered Students: In Pursuit of State of the Art - IJBCT, 2.(4), pp.463-480 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org BAO] ] If a behavior is particularly complex it may be task-analyzed and broken into its component parts to be taught through chaining. While all these methods are effective, when the behavior problem gets difficult or when all else fails many turn to
contingency managementsystems. [Walker, H. (1990). Acting Out Child. Soporis West] Complex and comprehensive contingency management systems have been developed and represent effective ways to eliminate many problem behaviors (see applied behavior analysisand positive behavior support). Collabortive goal settingwith the client enhances treatment effects [Martin, G. & Pear. (2007) Behavior Modification: What is it and how to do it.] .
ome areas of effectiveness
Functional behavior assessment forms the core of
applied behavior analysisand thus forms the core of behavior modification. Many techniques in this therapy are specific techniques aimed at specific issues. Interventions based on behavior analytic/modification principles have been extremely effective in developing evidence-based treatments. [O'Donohue, W. & Ferguson, K.E. (2006). Evidence-Based Practice in Psychology and Behavior Analysis. "The Behavior Analyst Today, 7(3") pp.335-352 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org] ]
In addition to the above, a growing list of researched-based interventions from the behavioral paradigm exists. With children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, one study showed that over a several year period, children in the behavior modification group had half the number of felony arrests as children in the medication group. [Satterfield, J.H., Satterfield, B.T., & Schell, A.M.(1987). Therapeutic interventions to prevent delinquency in hyperactive boys. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, pp.26, 56-64] [Satterfield, J.H. & Schell, A. 1997). A prospective study of hyperactive boys with conduct problems and normal boys: Adolescent and adult criminality. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 36, pp.1726-1735] These findings remain to be replicated but are considered encouraging for the use of behavior modification for children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.
Behavior modification programs form the core of many residential treatment facility programs. (In Wikipedia these link under
Behavior Modification Facility.) They have shown success in reducing recidivism for adolescents with conduct problems and adult offenders. One particular program that is of interest is 'teaching-family homes', which is based on a social learning model that emerged from radical behaviorism. These particular homes use a family style approach to residential treatment, which has been carefully replicated over 700 times. [Dean L. Fixsen, Karen A. Blasé , Gary D. Timbers and Montrose M. Wolf (2007) In Search of Program Implementation: 792 Replications of the Teaching-Family Model. "Behavior Analyst Today" Volume 8, No. 1, pp.96-106 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org Behavior Analyst Online] ] . Recent efforts have seen a push for the inclusion of more behavior modification programs in residential re-entry programs in the U.S. to aid prisoners in re-adjusting after release.
One area that has repeatedly shown effectiveness has been the work of
behaviorists working in the area of community reinforcement for addictions. [ Milford, J.L., Austin, J.L. & Smith, J.E. (2007). Community Reinforcement and the Dissemination of Evidence-based Practice: Implications for Public Policy. IJBCT, 3.(1), pp.77-87 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org] )] Another area of research that has been strongly supported has been behavioral activation for depression. [Spates,R.C, Pagoto, S. & Kalata, A. (2006). A Qualitative and Quantitative Review of Behavioral Activation Treatment of Major Depressive Disorder. "The Behavior Analyst Today, 7(4)," pp.508-517 [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org] ]
One way of giving positive reinforcement in behavior modification is in providing compliments, approval, encouragement, and
affirmation; a ratio of five compliments for every one complaint is generally seen as being effective in altering behavior in a desired manner [Kirkhart, Robert and Evelyn, "The Bruised Self: Mending in the Early Years", in Kaoru Yamamoto (ed.), "The Child and His
] and even producing a stable marriage. [Gottman, J. M., & Levenson, R. W. (1999). "What predicts change in marital interaction over time? A study of alternative models." "Family Process", 38 (2), pp.143-158]
Of notable interest is that the right behavioral intervention can have profound system effects. For example, Forgatch and DeGarmo (2007) found that with mothers who were recently divorced, a standard round of parent management training (a program based on social learning principles that teaches rewarding good behavior and punishing bad behavior combined with communication skills) could help elevate the divorced mother out of poverty. [Forgatch, M. & DeGarmo (2007). Accelerating recovery from poverty: Prevention effects for recently separated mothers. "Journal of Early and Intensive Behavior Intervention, 4(4)," pp.681-72. [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org BAO] ] In addition, parent management training programs sometimes referred to as behavioral parent training programs have shown relative cost effectiveness for their efforts [ Olchowski,A.E., Foster, E.M., & Webster-Stratton C.H. (2007). Implementing Behavioral Intervention Components in a Cost-Effective Manner: Analysis of the Incredible Years Program. Journal of Early and Intensive Behavior Intervention,Vol. 3,(4) and Vol 4(1) Combined Edition, pp.284-304. [http://www.behavior-analyst-online.org BAO] ] for the treatment of conduct disorder. Thus, such intervention can have profound effects on socializing the child in a relatively cost effective fashion and help elevate the parent from poverty. This level of effect is often looked for and valued by those who practice
behavioral engineeringand results of this type have caused the Association for Behavior Analysis International to take a position that those receiving treatment have a right to effective treatment [https://apps.abainternational.org/ABA/statements/treatment.asp ABA:I] and a right to effective education. [https://apps.abainternational.org/ABA/statements/education.asp ABA:I]
Behavior modification is critiqued in person-centered psychotherapeutic approaches such as Rogerian Counseling and
Re-evaluation Counseling. [http://www.rc.org/] The argument is that these methods involve connecting with the human qualities of the person to promote healing and that behaviorism is denigrating to the human spirit. [Holland, J. L. (1976). A new synthesis for an old method and a new analysis of some old phenomena. "The Counseling Psychologist, 6," pp.12-15] Skinner argued against this position in Beyond Freedom and Dignityby arguing that unrestricted reinforcement is what led to the "feeling of freedom" and thus removal of aversive events would allow people to "feel freer" [BF Skinner,1974,Beyond Freedom and Dignity] Further criticism extends to the presumption that behavior increases only when it is reinforced. This premise is at odds with research conducted by Albert Banduraat Stanford University. His findings indicate that violent behavior is imitated, without being reinforced, in studies conducted with children watching films showing various individuals 'beating the daylights out of Bobo'. Bandura believes that human personality and learning is the result of the interaction between environment, behavior and psychological process. There is evidence, however, that imitation is a class of behavior that can be learned just like anything else. Children have been shown to imitate behavior that they have never displayed before and are never reinforced for, after being taught to imitate in general. [D Baer, RF Peterson, JA Sherman Psychological Modeling: Conflicting Theories, 2006]
Several people have criticized the level of training required to perform behavior modification procedures, especially those which are restrictive or use
aversives, aversion therapyor punishmentprotocals. Some desire to limit such restrictive procedures only to licensed psychologist or licensed counselors. Still others desire to create an independent practice of behavior analysis through licensure to offer consumers choices between proven techniques and unproven ones (see Professional practice of behavior analysis). Level of training and consumer protection remain of critical importance in applied behavior analysisand behavior modification.
behavior analysiscontinues to grow as a science by including more environmental factors and behaviorismgrows as a philosophy, some continue to criticize it for being reductionist.
Applied Behavioural Analysis
Cognitive behavioral therapy
John B. Watson
B. F. Skinner
Behavior modification facility
Beyond Freedom and Dignity
A Clockwork Orange"
* [http://www.ldonline.org/ld_indepth/behavior/behavior_modification.html ldonline.org] - Behavior modification in the Classroom
* [http://add.about.com/cs/discipline/a/behavior.htm about.com] - Changing Our Perspective Can Help Our Child To Behave
* [http://www.latitudes.org/behavioral_charts.html Association for Comprehensive NeuroTherapy] - Behavior modification charts for home and school
* [http://www.behavioursupport.org.uk/ Behaviour Support Services] - Children with learning disabilities
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.