Abnaa el-Balad

:"See: Balad בל"ד (Brit Leumit Demokratit ברית לאומית דמוקרטית al-Tajamu' al-Watani al-Dimuqrati) ("National Democratic League") for the Arab party in the Knesset of Israel."

Abnaa el-Balad ( _ar. ابنا البلد, "Sons of the Land" or "Sons and Daughters of the Country" or "People of the Homeland Movement") is a secular movement made up of Palestinians, most of whom are Arab citizens of Israel. The stated goals of the movement are: the return of all Palestinian refugees, an end to Israeli's occupation of territories, and the establishment of a democratic, secular Palestinian state.cite web|title=Why Abnaa al-Balad|publisher=Abnaa al-Balad|accessdate=2008-01-29|url=http://www.abnaa-elbalad.org/harakeh.htm] cite web|title=Abnaa al-Balad: Sons of the Land|publisher=Abnaa al-Balad|accessdate=2008-01-29|url=http://www.abnaa-elbalad.org/engballad1.html]

While Abnaa el-Balad calls for the abolishment of Israel's identity as a Jewish state, the movement's membership is open to and includes Jewish citizens of Israel who identify as Palestinian Jews.cite web|title=Middle East issues hotly debated by activists in Durban|author=Robert E. Sullivan|date=7 August 1999|url=http://www.earthtimes.org/aug/thedurbanconferencemiddleaug30_01.htmYoav Bar is a member of Abnaa el-Balad's central committee and identifies himself in this article, as a "Palestinian Jew."] Since its inception, Abnaa el-Balad has boycotted involvement in the Israeli Knesset, though it does participate in the elections for municipal councils in Arab localities.

Origins and early political organizing

The movement grew out of student organizing among Palestinians in Israel in the late 1960s and early 1970s. One of the co-founders, Mohammed Kiwan, was active in establishing a committee of Arab students at Tel Aviv University between 1967 and 1969. In 1969, he was placed under house arrest in Umm al-Fahm, at which point he began organizing to establish Abnaa el-Balad. In 1971, he returned to Tel Aviv University to complete his law degree and in December 1973, he was elected to the municipal council in Umm al-Fahm, running on Abnaa el-Balad's platform.cite journal|title=Interview:'Sons of the Village' Assert Palestinian Identity in Israel|author=Pamela Ann Smith, Mohammed Kiwan|journal=MERIP Reports|volume=No. 68|month=June | year=1978|pages=pp. 15–18|url=http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0047-7265(197806)68%3C15%3A'OTVAP%3E2.0.CO%3B2-H]

The original aim of Abnaa el-Balad was to counteract Israeli attempts to "divide and rule" by capitalizing on old family feuds between the various representatives in the Arab municipal councils in Israel. Abnaa el-Balad emphasized the importance of transforming traditional structures and subordinating existing regional, personal and family differences to the national cause. According to Kiwan, Abnaa el-Balad differed from other Palestinian groups in Israel at the time in that, "The problem for us is ... the question of the Palestinian people." Helena Cobban notes that this position mirrored the "ideological innovation" introduced by Fateh, and was expressed in Kiwan's statement that, "We say that the only true legitimate representative of the Palestinian Arabs is the Palestine Liberation Organization...This is the first principle. Secondly, that all the Palestinian people, everywhere, constitute one identity."cite book|title=The Palestinian Liberation Organisation: People, Power, and Politics|author=Helena Cobban|page=189-190|year=1984|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=0521272165]

Abnaa el-Balad rejected the idea of working within Israel's parliamentary institution, the Knesset. By forming a network of local groups, they hoped to gain power and empower the community through the use of local municipal councils and popular activities. The movement's programme centered around self-determination for Palestinians inside Israel, explicit support for the PLO, and the eventual establishment of a single democratic state in Palestine."

After winning the December 1973 municipal elections, Kiwan and those in the movement set up a cultural center in Umm al-Fahm with a small library where people could gather to attend public meetings and discuss the Palestinian cause. Local groups affiliated with Abnaa el-Balad emerged in many Arab towns in 1970s under different names, such as "al-Nahda" ("The Rebirth") in Taibeh and "al-Bayadir" ("The Threshing Floor") in Ar'ara.. Abnaa el-Balad was one of many groups to help organize the Land Day ("Yom Al Ard") demonstration on 30 March 1976 as a way of defending Palestinian rights to the land and defying and challenging Israeli land confiscation policies.

In 1984, a split formed within Abnaa el-Balad, and a breakaway movement called Al Ansar emerged calling for participation in the Israeli elections. However, by 1987, Al Ansar's numbers dwindled and the group fragmented thereafter.cite book|title=Palestine and Israel: The Uprising and Beyond|author=David McDowall|year=1989|pages=150-151|publisher=I.B.Tauris|isbn=1850432899|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=pIezNAykWNQC&pg=PA151&dq=abna+balad&sig=jT6DB-1Efa6_RecSWaH69CU6KZQ#PPA151,M1]

Abnaa el-Balad managed to recover its community support, particularly after the outbreak of the First Intifada in 1987. David McDowall writes that, "The Uprising vindicated Abna al Balad's insistence on the Palestinian identity of Israel's Arabs [...] "

In 1996, Abnaa el-Balad was among a number of political, intellectual and feminist individuals and groups to form part of the National Democratic Alliance (NDA), a coalition that adopted a "Palestinian nationalist" position and called for "a state for all its citizens".cite web|title=The Palestinians in Israel: Historical, Social and Political Background|author=Areej Sabbagh-Khoury|publisher=Mada al-Carmel|accessdate=2008-02-05|url=http://209.85.129.104/search?q=cache:bgq_3mcWjcgJ:www.mada-research.org/programs/information_background_eng.pdf] Headed by Azmi Bishara, the NDA ran in the 1996 Knesset elections and Bishara gained a seat,cite book|title=Coffins on Our Shoulders: The Experience of the Palestinian Citizens of Israel|author=Dan Rabinowitz, Khawla Abu Baker|page=84|year=2005|publisher=University of California Press|isbn=0520244419|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=Qcnz7SCkyAMC&pg=PA84&dq=abna+balad&lr=&sig=0PQqHgUxJt7uf5AxPtFo1Vr6OSU] serving in Israel's parliament for 11 years, before leaving the country and resigning his post.

On 18 January 1998, Abnaa el-Balad left the National Democratic Alliance.

More on political positions and affiliations

The goals of Abnaa al-Balad today, as described on their website, are:

"to preserve the collective national identity of the Arab Palestinians in Israel, link their struggle to that of the rest of their exiled brethren (especially the refugees right of return) and continue the struggle for the human rights and equality within the state which was imposed on them."

The website also states that though grassroots organizing, Abnaa al-Balad aims to build civil society institutions and raise the national awareness and collective consciousness of the Palestinian masses. This struggle is linked by Abnaa el-Balad to the struggle against imperialism, capitalism and Zionism and their aims in the region.

Boycotting of Knesset

Since Israeli electoral law forbids any organization calling to abolish the Jewish character of the state to take part in the Knesset elections, Abnaa al-Balad boycotts what it calls the "Zionist electoral process". Ibrahim Makkawi, a member of the movement and professor of Educational Psychology, explained this position further in a paper presented at the Third North American Student Conference on the Palestine Solidarity Movement at Rutgers University in October 2003, stating:

We refuse to enter the Zionist Knesset, simply because it is (a) in direct contradiction with our national identity as the legitimate owners of the land, (b) it gives legitimacy to the Zionist Entity and support to its myth about democracy, (c) it is a vehicle of cooptation and fragmentation of our leadership and (d) there is virtually nothing that we can achieve through the Knesset with regard to our citizens rights that we cannot do without it."cite web|title=From marginalized identity to resisting colonization: The Palestinians of the Inside|date=10-12 October 2003|author=Ibrahim Makkawi|url=http://www.abnaa-elbalad.org/NJ_Ibrahim.html#_ftn1|accessdate=2008-02-06]

Leftist organizations like Abnaa al-Balad made abstention and the blank vote the center of their political campaigns in the 1999 elections. Although voter turnout increased by just over 30,000, the percentage turnout (70%) was down slightly (reflecting a population increase), and well below predictions of 87%. [Frisch, H. (2001) [http://www.biu.ac.il/Besa/arabvote.pdf The Arab Vote in the Israeli Elections: The Bid for Leadership] Israel Affairs, Vol. 7, No. 2 & 3, pp 153-170]

In "Israel at the Polls 2003", it is noted that Arab voting participation dropped to 62% in the 2003 elections, a drop partially attributed to calls by Abnaa el-Balad to boycott the elections.cite book|title=Israel At The Polls 2003|author=Shmuel Sandler, M. Benjamin Mollov, Jonathan Rynhold|page=131|year=2005|publisher=Routledge|isbn=0415360196|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=QqSYUywZapoC&pg=PT149&dq=abna+balad&lr=&sig=MZOQd3lR-T9YruHek0FtNx_ok1U] A May 2003 study by Mada al-Carmel, a Palestinian-Israeli research institute, exploring why Arab voters abstained in the 2003 Israeli elections determined that 43.4% of non-voters abstained from voting for political reasons, and that this group represented some 14% of registered voters. The majority of these (some 11.2% of registered voters) were protesting the political situation and Israeli policies in the occupied territories.

In "Elections in Israel - 2003" where the results of the Mada al-Carmel study were analyzed, it is noted that only 3.8% of registered voters chose not to vote "as a conscious political act," out of the belief that,

" [...] the Jewish state and its parliamentary institution are not legitimate and that participation of Arab citizens in the elections turns them into a tool that Israel uses to win legitimacy in their eyes and in the eyes of the world. Those who advocate a boycott on these grounds believe that it is not possible to achieve political gains through elections in Israel's present political structure, and certainly not at the price of granting legitimacy to the Jewish state."

The authors go on to describe the "extra-parliamentary" Abnaa al-Balad as the most prominent representative of this school of thought.cite book|title=The Elections in Israel, 2003|page=231-232|author=Alan Arian and Michal Shamir|year=2005|publisher=Transaction Publishers|isbn=0765802686]

Abnaa el-Balad called for Palestinian citizens of Israel to boycott the 2006 Knesset elections through its affiliated organization, The Popular Committee for Boycotting the Knesset Elections ( _ar. اللجنة الشعبية لمقاطعة انتخابات الكنيس).cite journal|title=The Palestinians in Israel and the 2006 Knesset Elections: Political and Ideological Implications of Election Boycott|author=Asad Ganim and Muhanned Mustafa|journal=Holy Land Studies: a Multidisciplinary Journal|volume=Volume 6, Number 1|month=May | year=2007|pages=pp. 51–73|url=http://muse.jhu.edu/login?uri=/journals/holy_land_studies/v006/6.1ghanem.html]

Opposing Jewish immigration

Abnaa al-Balad was the only Palestinian organization based in Israel to move from passive reservations to active opposition to the increased immigration of Jews to Israel from the Former Soviet Union (FSU) in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Raja Ighbaria explained the reasoning behind the group's opposition as follows:

"Going back in history, Jewish immigration to Palestine has always been at the expense of the Palestinian people. It resulted in the expulsion of Palestinians from their homeland. Adding one million Jews to Israel [the Soviet immigration] forms an actual danger to the very fact of our existence. Transfer of the remaining Palestinians comes closer to realization than it had been before."cite book|title=Immigration and Ethnic Formation in a Deeply Divided Society: The Case of 1990s Immigrants from the Former Soviet Union in Israel|author=Majid Al Haj|year=2004|publisher=BRILL|page=186-187|isbn=9004136258|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=LDJfj7JEmd0C&pg=PA187&dq=abnaa+balad+russian+immigration&sig=XJ22ek0qONGK2TjkrBwkKQv68Ls]

The movement circulated pamphlets and petitions that expressed opposition to Russian immigration. An 3 August 1990 pamphlet, entitled "What are We Waiting For? Immigrants are Penetrating our Doors and Threatening Our Lands" called for joint action with "oppressed Jews" (that is, Mizrahim) to halt the immigration and for Arabs to participate in a demonstration in Jerusalem and the Negev on 5 August.

According to Majid Al Haj, the opposition articulated by Abnaa el-Balad " [...] never crossed the line into active resistance." It remained " [...] a limited attempt to mobilize the Arab public in Israel to speak openly against immigration from the FSU."

Participation in local and international movements and conferences

In 1992 and 1993, the Abnaa el-Balad Movement and the NGO of the same name participated in The Ninth and Tenth United Nations International NGO Meetings on the Question of Palestine which were held under the auspices of the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People in Geneva and Vienna, respectively.cite web|publisher=Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People|date=28 August 1992|title=Ninth United Nations International NGO Meeting on the Question of Palestine|accessdate=2008-02-05|url=http://domino.un.org/unispal.NSF/f45643a78fcba719852560f6005987ad/f59849412f1f66438525610a0057cbc1!OpenDocument] cite web|publisher=Division for Palestinian Rights|date=27 August 1993|title=Tenth United Nations International NGO Meeting on the Question of Palestine|accessdate=2008-02-05|url=http://domino.un.org/unispal.nsf/3822b5e39951876a85256b6e0058a478/6158054e4352defe8525610a006af5b4!OpenDocument]

Abnaa al-Balad was one of a number of Arab civil society organizations in Israel to present at the "I Will Not Serve" national conference which discussed the reasons why Arab citizens of Israel should resist mandatory civic service.cite web|title=General Consensus against "Civic Service" in the "I Will Not Serve" Conference in Haifa|publisher=Baladna - Association for Arab Youth|accessdate=2008-01-29|url=http://66.102.9.104/search?q=cache:ZaoLS9zLfLIJ:wwww.momken.org/reports_files/English%2520conference%2520update.doc+abnaa+balad&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=11&gl=ca]

Arrests of members

In a study of "Palestinian NGOs in Israel" (2005), Shany Payes writes that the state response to the challenge posed by Palestinian activists like Abnaa el-Balad has been to adopt a policy of 'active exclusion'; that is, "denying the Palestinian leadership in Israel access to the avenues of publicity or decision-making." According to Payes, state authorities in Israel used "security considerations" to justify restrictions on organizing and publishing by groups considered a "security risk".cite book|title=Palestinian NGOs in Israel: The Politics of Civil Society|author=Shany Payes|page=93|year=2005|publisher=I.B.Tauris|isbn=1850436304|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=7x0dxnw7RHAC&pg=PA93&dq=abna+balad&lr=&sig=rzLzaBhHRwo4JxwM3gPxNeKNppk#PPA93,M1]

Several of Abnaa el-Balad's leaders have been arrested or otherwise detained. In the early 1980s, Faraj Khnayfus, a leader for Abnaa el-Balad in Shafa'Amr of Druze background, spent three years in jail for refusing to serve in the IDF.cite book|title=Memories of Revolt: The 1936-1939 Rebellion and the Palestinian National Past|author=Ted Swedenburg|page=93|year=2003|publisher=University of Arkansas Press|isbn=1557287635|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=q7RTdcvtO2sC&pg=PA93&dq=ibna+balad&as_brr=3&sig=Lhu5_zwAUFRB7RgWcNk6CSywcjk#PPA94,M1In Israel, military service for Arab citizens of Israel who are Druze is compulsory. ]

During the 80' and especially at the time of the First Intifada (1987 - 1990), Many of the movement's members were detained, accused in different accusations most of them graffitty, raising Palestinian flags, 'rioting' (during demonstrations) and property destruction, and hundreds of members were imprisoned to periods between 3 months and 6 years.>

At the beginning of the Second Intifada, central committee member, Yoav Bar, was arrested on 2 October 2000 during "an initially peaceful protest in Haifa".cite web|title=Israel/OT: Mass arrests in Jerusalem and northern Israel often followed by police beatings|publisher=Amnesty International|date=9 November 2000|url=http://asiapacific.amnesty.org/library/Index/ENGMDE150602000?open&of=ENG-381] According to Amnesty International, Bar " [...] was dragged by the legs for more than 50 meters by two police officers with his back sliding along the street, while other police officers beat him with batons. He was beaten again in a police car. He told the police that he thought his hand was broken; the police refused to give him any medical treatment." Released at midnight the same day, "Yoav Bar's left hand was broken in three places. Two of his ribs were broken, and two of his front teeth were broken. His back was also injured as a result of being dragged along the street."

In 2003, in response to the campaign of persecuation against the leadership of the Islamic Movement, the 'Committee for the Defense of Freedoms' was formed by the follow up committee in purpuse of "confronting political persecution and harassment against Palestinian political movements and attacks against Palestinian organizations in Israel, which includes organizations such as the Islamic Movement, the Abnaa al-Balad Movement, and support groups of prisoners as "Ansar al-Sajeen"."cite web|title=Annual Report: 2003|publisher=Ittijah: The Union of Arab Community Based Organizations|year=2003|accessdate=2008-02-06|url=http://209.85.129.104/search?q=cache:52eN8aVSC1UJ:www.ittijah.org/pdf/Annual%2520Report%25202003.pdf]

2004 arrests

On 7 February 2004, Mohammad Kana'neh, the General Secretary the movement and a board member for the NGO Ittijah, was arrested in his home in Arrabe at four in the morning. According to the legal advocacy group, Adalah, during the search of his home, Israeli police beat his son, wife, and mother.cite web|title=PRESS RELEASE: Gag Order Imposed on the Prolonged Detention of Four Abna al-Balad Political Activists Lifted Adalah: The GSS and the Police Violated the Detainees' Basic Rights during Interrogation|publisher=Adalah|date=4 March 2004|url=http://www.adalah.org/eng/pressreleases/pr.php?file=04_03_04|accessdate=2008-02-05] Also arrested that day was Mohammed's brother, Hussam Kana'neh (also known as Majed), a central committee member of Abnaa el-Balad. Initially, no reasons were provided for their arrest, nor were they allowed contact to their lawyer, and a court hearing the night of their arrest granted the police the right to detain them for 10 days.cite web|title=Press Release: Balad Cultural Association Raided By Police: Board Member of Ittijah Arrested|date=8 February 2004|accessdate=2008-02-06|url=http://www.ittijah.org/press/pr_04_02_08.html]

Also arrested that same day was Sahar Abdo, a secretary for "The New Generation" magazine published by the Balad Association (the NGO of the same name as the movement). Yoav Bar was removed from his home at four in the morning by police and taken to the movement's club in the city. During a search of the premises, " [...] security personnel destroyed the furniture, ripped pictures from the walls, walked on photos of the victims of the Israeli occupation, threw trash, cleaning chemicals, oil, and grease on piles of books and magazines that had been thrown on the floor, and wrote curses and obscenities on the walls. During this time, Yoav Bar was threatened and cursed; one officer told him, 'If it were up to me, I would shoot you in the head.'"cite web|title=Political persecution Israeli-style|author=Iris Bar|date=3 March 2007|publisher=Hagada Hasmalit|url=http://www.hagada.org.il/eng/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=61] Adalah recounts these same accusations in its March 2004 press release, writing that, "One of the police officers that searched the Haifa offices stated to an Abna al-Balad movement member who was also present, that if it were up to him, he would 'put a bullet in your [his] head right now.'"]

Youssef Abu Ali, an activist with the Abna al-Balad movement in Sakhnin, was arrested a few days after the arrests of the Kana'neh brothers, Bar and Abdo, on 12 February 2004 at 2:30 in the morning. His detention was extended by seven days before the Acre court and he was denied the right to see his attorney.

By the and of February, 2004, Sahar Abdo, and Youssef Abu Ali had been released after 24 days of detention without the laying of any charges. All were subjected to abusive interrogation techniques and had been denied access to a lawyer and their families for 18 to 21 days.cite web|title=Harassment of Abnaa elBalad highlights plight of Palestinians in Israel|date=12 March 2004|accessdate=2008-02-05|url=http://www.marxist.com/abnaa-elbalad-harassment120304-5.htm] According to Adalah, the interrogation methods used by the General Security Services (GSS) included tying the activists to their chairs, sleep deprivation, the refusal to provide essential medical treatment when needed, preventing them from bathing for long periods of time, and providing them with "inaccurate, misleading information" about their basic legal rights. Adalah submitted that, "These GSS actions violated the political activists' rights to due process, life, privacy, and dignity."

In 4 March, 2004 - Mohamad Kana'neh was indicted in 3 counts of "contact with a foreign agent" - he was accused of meeting Dr. Geroge Habash, the founder of the PFLP in Jordan, Ibrahim 'Ajweh "Abu - Yaffa", a Fatah movement member and an anti-globalization/anti-normalization activist from Jordan and visiting Ahmad Sa'adat, the general secretary of the PFLP in Jeriho prison. His brother Hussam Kana'neh was indicted in tranferring paramedical equipment from Ibrahim 'Ajweh to Jenin - according to the prosecution inside this equipment were hidden instructions for building explosives. Even according to the state attorney, Hussam didn't know about the 'hidden instructions' but the prosectuion claimed that he should have ""knew that passing those electric devices will harm Israel' security".

Before the indictment, the prosecution held a big press conference, linking Mohammad & Hussam Kana'neh to Hezbollah .cite web|title=אישום: תושבי עראבה תיווכו בין חיזבאללה לטרור בג'נין|publisher=Ynet (Hebrew text)|accessdate=2008-02-06|url=http://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-2884055,00.html] This accusation were never presented at court.

In October 10th 2004 Mohamad Kana'aneh accepted a plea bargain and pleaded guilty to 1 count of "contact with a foreign agent" -(Ibrahim 'Ajweh) Althougth the prosecution agreed that all the contacts between the two were public as part of Mohamad Kana'neh's political activisty,the state requested a 6 years sentence. The Haifa District Court sentenced him to 30 months of imprisonment and 2 years suspended incarceration.

At February 2005, Hussam kana'neh accepted a plea bargain & pleaded guilty to 3 counts of "Supplying services to an unlawful association", "Conspiracy to assist the enemy at time of war" & "contact with a foreign agent". He was sentenced to ten and a half years of imprisonment. cite web|title=Comrade Hussam Kana'aneh, a CC member of Abnaa el Balad Movement was sentenced to ten and half years of imprisonment and four years of suspended prison term|publisher=Abnaa el-Balad|accessdate=2008-02-05|url=http://www.abnaa-elbalad.org/bayan_husam.html] Husam's friends & supporters - most of them Jewish colleagues who knew him from his work as a psychologist in the health services of the impoverished neighborhouds in Jaffa, followed the trial and established a special website in his support cite web|title=A trial captured by paranoya - On the judicial process and sentencing of Arab psychologist Majed Kana'aneh|publisher=support-majed|accessdate=2008-02-05|url=http://www.support-majed.info/indexENG.html]

The Abnaa El Balad movement strongly condemned the court decisions and released a press release that stated: "We consider the Court sentence a continuation of the repression and persecutions against our movement and against all the Arab masses and their leadership inside the 1948 territories. Abnaa El Balad will check with our lawyers the legal implications of this case as well as the possibility of appealing to such an unjust verdict. In November 2005, an Israeli appeals court extended Mohammad Kana'neh's sentence by two years to four and a half years imprisonment. [http://auto_sol.tao.ca/node/view/1614]

External links

* [http://www.abnaa-elbalad.org/engballad1.html The movement's website] (English page)
* [http://www.abnaa-elbalad.org/harakeh.htm Goals of the movement] (from its website)
* [http://auto_sol.tao.ca/node/view/1614 Imprisonment details on Autonomy & Solidarity] (activist website)
* [http://www.po.org.ar/english/807art1.htm An interview with Mohammad Kana’neh on Prensa Obrera] (from 2003)
* [http://www.adalah.org/eng/index.php Adalah website] Palestinian human rights organization in Israel involved in the case.
* [http://www.ittijah.org/press/pr_04_02_08.html Press report on repression]
* [http://www.po.org.ar/english/807art1.htm Interview with Kana'neh]
* [http://www.marxist.com/MiddleEast/handsoff_abnaa.html Hands off Abnaa el-Balad article]

References