Manning control

Manning control

Manning control is a policy used by the British Army to dismiss soldiers who are considered to be 'not fit for a full army career' and to make space for new recruits. All soldiers can be reviewed after either 6, 9, and 12 years in the Army, and dismissed if considered surplus to requirements and a posting to another unit is not possible. [1]

Contents

Manning Control History

Manning Control was first introduced in the late 1950s to reduce the numbers of soldiers in the British Army after conscription Conscription in the United_Kingdom had ended. During the 70's and 80's it was suspended, then between 1990/91 to 1996/97 there was 34,600 redundancies in the UK Armed Forces with almost half from the army, this was a direct result of the end of the cold war. As well as the culling of regular battalions, the Territorial Army was significantly reduced from 57,000 to around 40,000. [2]

However, the result of the redundancies was under-manning in various skill trades, as many more soldiers opted for the attractive redundancy package than was first anticipated. Weeks later, soldiers who had taken the redundancy package would be back in uniform at the request of the MOD and would sign back on but only for a short period, in order to ameliorate what was hoped to be a temporary manning shortfall. The contract used was an S/Type, this contract was used primarily for the TA soldier if he wished to serve with a regular battalion.

Soldiers who joined the Army at the time signed on for 22 years with an option to leave after three, six or nine years. At the end of their 22 years, they receive an immediate pension for life. [3] Lists of soldiers subject to the system were being sent from APC Glasgow the Army's administrative wing, on a regular basis. Soon more and more soldiers were falling victim to the "Brown envelope" as it was known. Even men who are regarded as excellent soldiers where pressured into leaving the Army "voluntarily", or signing a new "S-type engagement" contract, and giving up the prospect of an immediate pension when they left.

Forms such as the AFB130A application against the soldiers discharge were negated from the process, preventing the soldier from making a representation against the Manning Control order until it was too late.

The absence of the form also hid the real number of soldiers subject to Manning Control as most soldiers would "jump ship" rather than have it on their record of service that they forced out. This was later admitted by Geoff Hoon the then secretary of state for defence in a letter to Paul Keetch Paul Keetch the Lib Dems defence spokesman.

Where it went really wrong

A Soldier from the Parachute Regiment.Corporal Paul Biddiss [4] was told in November 1999 by his Commanding Officer Lt Col Kennett [5] that he would be manning controlled. He refused to sign off his old contract as it was alleged he should never have been subject to the system. It is believed he was the first soldier to refuse. He won his fight against the system and is still a serving soldier. [6] This was the turning point for Manning Control due mainly to treatment both the Cpl Biddiss and his family were alleged to have endured during the Manning Control process. This generated media attention to what was until then an unknown system of mass discharging of soldiers. [7]

When It Stopped

29 Apr 2002 Michael Smith [8] then defence correspondent of The Daily Telegraph, Tom Newton Dunn [9] then defence editor of the Daily Mirror and Andrew Gilligan from the Radio 4 Today Programme, Andrew Gilligan first publicized the case of Cpl Paul Biddiss. in a combined effort, and with the help of campaigning solicitor Thomas Reah exposed the issue and alleged abuse for the first time. Sadly Tom Reah has since died. [10]

The Liberal Democrats defence spokesman Paul Keetch called for the immediate suspension of the scheme, known as "manning control", and an inquiry into its administration.

Mr Breed from the Liberal Democrats defence team.

There is a danger of seeing such measures in purely fiscal terms—as an extra figure in the MOD budget—but the effect that such measures can have on members of the armed forces and their loved ones cannot be underestimated. To that end, I would like to raise a subject on which I have exchanged many letters and parliamentary questions with the Minster with responsibility for the armed forces: manning control points.

In principle, a mechanism that prevents soldiers who are struggling from blocking promotion paths is reasonable, but in practice we have seen considerable evidence from former soldiers that the system has been misused, or at worst abused. Such a system should never be used simply to try to move decent, hard-working soldiers on to short-term contracts, under which they enjoy fewer rights and their service can be terminated without the pension entitlement that they richly deserve.

[11]

During the next few months more and more stories was being reported about alleged abuse of the system by former soldiers. During Parliamentary questions the MoD admitted that hundreds of medically unfit soldiers were thrown out of the Army rather than being given medical discharges, in an apparent contravention of its own rules.[12]

The Army admitted it had used Manning Control to throw out Soldiers who should have been Medically Discharged. The admission came in a written answer from Adam Ingram, the Armed Forces minister, who said 259 soldiers who were medically downgraded to a point where they could no longer carry out their roles had been sacked since 1997.[13]

A number of the medically unfit soldiers were sacked under the "manning control" system that allowed the Army to get rid of soldiers it did not want after 12 years of service. It was used to get rid of hundreds of soldiers who had done nothing wrong, in an apparent attempt to ensure they did not serve the 22 years that would qualify them for an immediate pension.[14] An unnamed serving soldier told Channel 4 News he believed the Army was forcing servicemen to “jump before they are pushed” in a bid to save money.

The Army was facing a class action by hundreds of former soldiers alleging that they were sacked or forced out under the manning control system to stop them attaining the length of service that would have entitled them to an immediate pension.[15] Soon after, Manning Control was suspended. But it is expected to be reintroduced raising questions as to whether soldiers wounded in Afghanistan will find themselves "brown-enveloped". [16]

December 2007 BAFF discovered a plan to sacked Gurkhas early to reduce their pension rights using Manning Control

THE Ministry of Defence (MoD) is facing legal action over plans to cut the pensions of Gurkhas by sacking them three years before they are due to leave the army.

The move, which means the MoD will avoid having to pay an ordinary Gurkha soldier more than £200,000, is to be challenged in the courts by the British Armed Forces Federation (BAFF). [17]

Manning Control 2010

Armed Forces: Discharges Willie Rennie: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many soldiers subject to manning control are (a) awaiting discharge and (b) have been discharged since 2007. [316937]

Bill Rammell: No soldiers have been discharged under Manning Control Points since 2002, and no soldiers are awaiting discharge.

[18]

[19]

What the soldiers have to say [20]

Started by the MOD again http://www.mod.uk/DefenceInternet/DefenceNews/DefencePolicyAndBusiness/RebalancingArmyManpower.htm

The Sun WAR heroes are to be secretly sacked on the cheap as they fight on the frontline http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/campaigns/our_boys/3135652/Afghan-frontline-heroes-betrayed.html

22 September 2010. Suspended again after only eight months and after national news coverage and a face book campaign. http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/campaigns/our_boys/3149503/Frontline-heroes-wont-be-sacked.html

PM pledges no use of Manning Control instead of proper redundancy payments Prime Minister David Cameron, answering MPs' questions following his Statement on the SDSR, gave the assurance that the resulting reductions in the numbers of service personnel would not involve the use of manning control instead of "proper redundancy payments". Against a historic background of real injustice to some individuals during earlier times of financial stringency and forces downsizing, BAFF welcomes this important confirmation by the PM and looks to the MoD and service authorities to ensure that it is not overlooked in practice.

The assurance was given in a reply to Eric Joyce MP (Falkirk, Lab) and can be found at this link:

•Strategic Defence and Security Review - Oral Answers - 19 Oct 2010

Links

Media

Hansards PQ

People involved

Tom Reah http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/1466000.stm

BAFF http://www.baff.org.uk/about/baff-executive-council.htm

Michael Smith http://www.michaelsmithwriter.com/about.html

Tom Newton Dunn http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/article2272569.ece

Andrew_Gilligan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Gilligan

Chandler Biddiss http://pages.123-reg.co.uk/eve3-37327/expara/id134.html

MPC http://pages.123-reg.co.uk/eve3-37327/expara/id128.html


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Olivia Manning — Nombre completo Olivia Mary Manning Nacimiento 2 de marzo de 1908 …   Wikipedia Español

  • Olivia Manning — This article is about the British novelist. For the wife of American football quarterback Archie Manning and mother of Cooper, Peyton, and Eli Manning, see their respective articles. Olivia Manning …   Wikipedia

  • Todd Manning — Infobox soap character series = One Life to Live color = #99BADD name = Todd Manning portrayer = Roger Howarth (1992 1995, 1996 1998, 2000 2003) Trevor St. John (2003 present) first = 1992 last = cause = creator = Michael Malone caption1 = Trevor …   Wikipedia

  • USRC Manning (1898) — USRC Manning was a revenue cutter of the United States Revenue Cutter Service that served from 1898 to 1930, and saw service in the U.S. Navy in the Spanish American War and World War I.CommissioningDesigned as a cruising cutter, Manning was… …   Wikipedia

  • Mike Manning — Michael Manning Born 1943 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Died 22 August 2008 Rabaul, East …   Wikipedia

  • Mike J. Manning — Infobox Person name = Michael Manning caption = birth date = 1943 birth place = Sydney, New South Wales, Australia death date = 22 August 2008 death place = Rabaul, East New Britain, Papua New Guinea other names = known for = Anti corruption… …   Wikipedia

  • Henry Edward Cardinal Manning —     Henry Edward Manning     † Catholic Encyclopedia ► Henry Edward Manning     Cardinal Priest ( see Cardinal, I ) of Sts. Andrew and Gregory on the Coelian Hill and second Archbishop of Westminster, b. 15 July, 1808; d. 14 January, 1892.… …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • USS Manning (DE-199) — USS Manning (DE 199), a sclass|Buckley|destroyer escort of the United States Navy, was named in honor of Ordnanceman Milburn A. Manning (1920 ndash;1941), who was killed in action during the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor 7 December 1941.… …   Wikipedia

  • Curtis Manning — Saltar a navegación, búsqueda Curtis Manning Personaje de 24 Primera aparición Temporada 6 Episodio 4 Interpretado por Roger Cross Episodios 46 Temporada(s) …   Wikipedia Español

  • Todd Manning and Blair Cramer — |accessdate=2007 09 07|url=http://onelifetolive.about.com/library/prm/blpkwaddle 012902.htm] WritingTodd and Blair s creation as a couple is described as factoring in many aspects of their own personalities, as well as their individual life… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
… Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”