- Shouting match
A shouting match is an
argument ordebate characterized by the loud volume or intensity of the participants.Parliamentary procedures
Large assemblies may easily degenerate into shouting matches as the participants raise their voices in order to be heard. To control this tendency towards chaos, rules of conduct such as Robert's Rules are often used. [citation|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=4TZOhQacmWoC|title=Breaking Robert's Rules|author=Lawrence E. Susskind, Jeffrey L. Cruikshank|isbn=9780195308419|year=2006|publisher=Oxford University Press]
Productive confrontation
Some assemblies may choose this form of discourse deliberately so that creative contributions are not stifled by formal rules. The
Bourbaki working parties to establish a definitive new reference work formathematic s were conducted in this way, being described as “"Two or three monologues shouted at top voice, seemingly independently of one another"” byArmand Borel , who attributed the success of this process to the commitment and hard work of the members. [citation|url=http://www.ams.org/notices/199803/borel.pdf|title=Twenty-Five Years with Nicolas Bourbaki, 1949–1973|author=Armand Borel|publisher=American Mathematical Society|year=1998] At theGeneral Electric company, the successful chief executive,Jack Welch , forced his managers to justify their positions by intensive argument that often became shouting matches. The result was to make the management confront reality and motivate them to make their proposals work. [citation|pages=341-2|title=General Electric: Life After Jack|author=RM Grant|publisher=Blackwell|url=https://www.blackwellpublishing.com/grant/docs/16GE.pdf]In commerce
Shouting matches should be avoided in commercial interactions between customers and suppliers because they tend to poison relations between the parties and so reduce the possibility of a productive deal. Training and role-playing may be used to develop the
emotional intelligence required to handle such situations effectively. [citation|title=Emotional intelligence – training people to be affective so they can be effective|author=Mike Bagshaw|journal=Industrial and Commercial Training|Year=2000|Volume=32|Issue=2|Pages=61-65|ISSN=0019-7858|DOI=10.1108/00197850010320699|Publisher=MCB UP Ltd]In public situations such as a nightclub or bar, staff that get into shouting matches with patrons look badly unprofessional. If they instead ignore the insults, the intoxicated customers will get frustrated and leave. [citation|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=St5L-UYiPD8C|title=The Nightclub, Bar and Restaurant Security Handbook|author=Robert McManus, Sean O'Toole|isbn=9780964720909|pages=108-109]
Online
Online communication in internet forums commonly takes the form of a shouting match. This is due to the anonymity which reduces the possibility of sanction for intemperate speech. So, rather than a listening and rational exchange, the format fosters rage and aggression which results in extreme opinions and insults. [citation|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=tKqDnulJqDsC|pages=104-5|title=Crime and Punishment in Contemporary Culture|author=Claire Valier|publisher=Routledge|year=2004|isbn=9780415281751]
As social ritual
The
Yanomamo people of theOrinoco are known as "The Fierce People". When two tribes meet for a feast, their chiefs start by engaging in a ritualized shouting match in which they ostensibly engage in fierce conflict but, by their rhythmic interaction, establish a satisfying bond. [citation|url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=P_prAAAAMAAJ|pages=255|title=Emotions and Psychopathology|author=Manfred Clynes, Jaak Panksepp|publisher=Plenum Press|year=1988|ISBN=9780306429163] [citation|pages=30|title=The Silent Pulse: A Search for the Perfect Rhythm That Exists in Each of Us|author=George Leonard|Publisher=Gibbs Smith|year=2006|ISBN=9781423601227|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=Z_F0hhN3IrAC]References
ee also
*
Screaming#Dialogue
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
