Argument in the alternative
- Argument in the alternative
Originating in the legal profession, argument in the alternative is used to pre-empt objections by arguing on multiple strategies simultaneously, showing that regardless of interpretation there is no reasonable conclusion other than the advocate's. Bart Simpson's classic "I didn't do it, no one saw me do it, you can't prove anything!" could be considered a somewhat humorous example. In a more serious example, a lawyer might argue, not only that his client was elsewhere when a murder or other crime took place, but also that even if he had been on the scene he would have had no way of accessing the alleged murder weapon.
The secondary line of reasoning might be presented to persuade a sub-audience who would not otherwise agree with the primary argument. The two alternatives need not both appeal to rational or logical considerations; for example, in a different courtroom example, a lawyer might allege, not only that his client did not commit the crime, but also that even if he had, he would have been justified in doing so. The first argument might be sound, but the second might very well appeal only to the emotions of certain jurors, and if so, would clearly be fallacious.
Occasionally, such arguments can be confusing to some people, who perceive a self-contradiction. Generally speaking, this is a case of mistakenly thinking the argument claims "both" alternatives are true, when in reality it is claiming only that one or the other of them must be.
ee also
* Disjunction elimination
External links
[http://lawiscool.com/2007/10/22/arguing-in-the-alternative/ Arguing in the Alternative. Oct. 22, 2007]
Wikimedia Foundation.
2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Argument from ignorance — The argument from ignorance, also known as argumentum ad ignorantiam ( appeal to ignorance [ [http://philosophy.lander.edu/logic/ignorance.html Argumentum ad Ignorantiam ] ] ) or argument by lack of imagination, is a logical fallacy in which it… … Wikipedia
The End of History and the Last Man — is a 1992 book by Francis Fukuyama, expanding on his 1989 essay The End of History? , published in the international affairs journal The National Interest . In the book, Fukuyama argues that the advent of Western liberal democracy may signal the… … Wikipedia
Argument from morality — The argument from morality is one of many arguments for the existence of God. It comes in different forms, all aiming to support the claim that God exists with observations about morality. Its counterpoint is generally the Problem of evil.… … Wikipedia
The Maltese Double Cross – Lockerbie — The Maltese Double Cross Lockerbie is a documentary film about the 1988 bombing of Pan Am Flight 103.Produced, written, and directed by Allan Francovich and financed by Tiny Rowland, the film was released by Hemar Enterprises in November 1994. [… … Wikipedia
The Bible and homosexuality — is a contentious subject that influences how homosexuality and homosexual sex are regarded in societies where Christianity has made a strong impact. The Bible is generally considered by believers to be inspired by God or to record God s… … Wikipedia
The Maltese Double Cross — – Lockerbie is a documentary film about the 1988 bombing of Pan Am Flight 103. Produced, written, and directed by Allan Francovich and financed by Tiny Rowland, the film was released by Hemar Enterprises in November 1994.[1] Though it was never… … Wikipedia
The Brothers (James Shirley) — The Brothers is a Caroline era stage play, a comedy written by James Shirley. First published in 1653, The Brothers has sometimes been hailed as one of Shirley s best plays, though it has also been a focus of significant confusion and scholarly… … Wikipedia
The Pennsylvania State University — The Dickinson School of Law Motto Making Life Better Established 1834 Type … Wikipedia
The Cantos — by Ezra Pound is a long, incomplete poem in 120 sections, each of which is a canto . Most of it was written between 1915 and 1962, although much of the early work was abandoned and the early cantos, as finally published, date from 1922 onwards.… … Wikipedia
The Bible with Sources Revealed — (2003) is a book by American biblical scholar Richard Elliott Friedman dealing with the process by which the five books of the Torah came to be written. Friedman follows the four source Documentary Hypothesis model, but differs significantly from … Wikipedia
