Unlearned Parliament

The Unlearned Parliament also known as the Lawless Parliament , Parliament of Dunces or the Parliamentum Indoctorum is the term used for the 1404 parliament called by Henry IV of England at the Great Hall of the Benedictine monastery in Coventry, Warwickshire, so called because the king refused to allow lawyers to stand as members, with "No Sheriff to be returned, nor any apprentice or other person at law" due to the King claiming that they were "troublesome", although more likely simply because they were familiar with the law. Parliament and Politics in Late Medieval England, John Smith Roskell, published by Hambledon Press, 1981 ISBN 0950688274]

It was led by Sir William Esturmy with the central proposal of this parliament being to tax Church lands to provide for the Kings wars and his household.'Folios xxx – xl: Jan 1403–4 — ', Calendar of letter-books of the city of London: I: 1400–1422] The church lands had previously not been taxed for this, or for paying for the upkeep of city walls. The proposal failed; according to the chronicler of the time:

"Much ado there was; but to conclude, the worthy Archbishop (viz. Tho. Arundell) standing stoutly for the good of the Church, preserved it at that time from the storm impending."

One part of Arundel's argument which had particular effect was to point out that the confiscation of priories by Henry had "not enriched the King by half a mark", with courtiers and others begging the lands as a favour, and there was no reason to assume that the taxation of the church would be any different.

During the Parliament, the House of Commons attempted to interfere with the running of the King's household, suggesting ways to spend less and to stop the bestowal of useless pensions, with the idea being that the Crown's holdings would be able to support the King's expenditure without draining the government's coffers. [The Lives of the Speakers of the House of Commons, from the Time of King Edward III to Queen Victoria: Comprising the Biographies of Upwards of One Hundred Distinguished Persons, and Copious Details of the Parliamentary History of England from the Most Authentic Documents, James Alexander Manning]

This parliament is seen by many historians as the central reason that Richard le Scrope, the Archbishop of York, became disillusioned with the king, after not commenting on Henry's seizure of the throne and the execution of William le Scrope, 1st Earl of Wiltshire, a relative of his. Scrope rebelled in the spring of 1405, raising 8,000 men and 3 knights after a propaganada campaign before being captured by Ralph de Neville, 1st Earl of Westmorland after disbanding his force per the terms of a truce. There is some evidence that the politically unsavvy Archbishop was manipulated throughout these events by Henry Percy, 1st Earl of Northumberland to legitimize his revenge campaign against Henry. [Griffiths "The Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries"]

References