Jones v. Post Office

Jones v. Post Office

"Jones v. Post Office" [2001] IRLR 384 is a UK labour law case, under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995.


Mr Jones was a Royal Mail driver. He became diabetic and insulin dependent and was removed from driving duties. The Post had done their own medical appraisal, which turned out to be wrong. He alleged that his dismissal was unfair.


The Court of Appeal, in a controversial decision, held it was not. Pill LJ said "Where a properly conducted risk assessment provides a reason which is on its face both material and substantial, and is not irrational, the tribunal cannot substitute its own appraisal."

Arden LJ said "the word substantial [s.5(3)] does not mean that the employer must necessarily have reached the best conclusion that could be reached in the light of all known medical science. Employers are not obliged to search for the Holy Grail."

ubsequent developments

This case has been subject to considerable academic criticism, for introducing (without any apparent statutory authority) a "reasonable range of responses" test. A number of cases after have limited and tacitly undermined its effect.

*"Paul v. National Probation Service" [2004] IRLR 190
*"Collins v. Royal National Theatre Board Ltd" [2004] IRLR 395

ee also

*UK employment discrimination law
*UK labour law
*Human Rights Act 1998


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать курсовую

Look at other dictionaries:

  • British Forces Post Office — The British Forces Post Office (or British Field Post Office) (BFPO) is an agency that provides a postal service to HM Forces, separate from that provided by Royal Mail in the United Kingdom. BFPO addresses are used for the delivery of mail in… …   Wikipedia

  • British Forces Post Office — Poste des forces britanniques La poste des forces britanniques (BFPO pour British Forces Post Office) est une agence exécutive du Ministère de la Défense britannique qui fournit un service postal à l armée. Les adresses de la BFPO sont utilisées… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Mandarin Store and Post Office — U.S. National Register of Historic Places …   Wikipedia

  • Mill Office and Post Office — U.S. National Register of Historic Places Location: Woodsdale, Ohio …   Wikipedia

  • Jones v. Flowers — SCOTUSCase Litigants=Jones v. Flowers ArgueDate=January 17 ArgueYear=2006 DecideDate=April 26 DecideYear=2006 FullName=Gary Kent Jones v. Linda K. Flowers and Mark Wilcox, Arkansas Commissioner of State Lands USVol=547 USPage=220 Citation=126 S.… …   Wikipedia

  • Office of Strategic Services — OSS OSS Shoulder Insignia Agency overview Formed June 13, 1942 Dissolved …   Wikipedia

  • Pryce Pryce-Jones — (October 16 1834 ndash; 1920) was one of the first to succeed in the mail order business.He was born in Newtown, Montgomeryshire, Wales. He was apprenticed to a local draper, John Davies, and took over Davies s business in 1856. In the same year… …   Wikipedia

  • Post-concussion syndrome — Classification and external resources ICD 10 F07.2 ICD 9 310.2 …   Wikipedia

  • JONES (D.) — JONES DAVID (1895 1974) Gallois par ses ancêtres paternels, mais anglais par sa mère, David Jones compte également des ancêtres italiens. Dès son jeune âge, en dehors de toute éducation scolaire, il se consacra au dessin: il exposa ses premiers… …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • Jones College (Rice University) — Mary Gibbs Jones College is one of nine residential colleges at Rice University in Houston, Texas.The college is named after Mary Gibbs Jones (April 29, 1872 August 20, 1962), wife of prominent Houstonian Jesse Holman Jones.HistoryJones College… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”