Felthouse v. Bindley

Felthouse v. Bindley

"Felthouse v. Bindley" (1862), 11 Cb (NS) 869, is the leading English case in contract law where the long-standing maxim that "silence does not amount to acceptance" was first expressed.

Facts

Mr Felthouse wanted to buy one of his nephew's horses. Felthouse wrote to his nephew who wanted to sell the horse to him, stating that "If I hear no more about him, I consider the horse mine..." Subsequently, there was no notice from his nephew and Felthouse considered the horse his own.

The horse was not delivered to uncle Felthouse and later there was an auction at the nephew's property for the other livestock. The nephew told the auctioneer, Mr Bindley, not to sell the horse at the auction as it was already sold to his uncle. By mistake, Bindley sold it anyway.

Felthouse sued the auctioneer in the tort of conversion however the action could only succeed if it could be shown that Felthouse actually owned the horse.

Judgement

The court ruled that Felthouse did not have ownership of the horse as there was no acceptance of the contract. Acceptance must be communicated clearly and cannot be imposed due to silence of one of the parties. The uncle had no right to impose a sale through silence whereby the contract would only fail by repudiation. Though the nephew expressed interest in completing the sale there was no communication of that intention.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • English contract law — is an influential system regulating the law of contract that operates in England and Wales. Its doctrines form the basis of contract law across the Commonwealth, including Australia, Canada, India, New Zealand and South Africa and more generally… …   Wikipedia

  • Agreement in English law — is a part of English contract law which establishes the first stage in the existence of a contract. The three main elements of contractual formation are whether there is (1) offer and acceptance (agreement) (2) consideration (3) an intention to… …   Wikipedia

  • Fälle in der Rechtswissenschaft — In der Rechtswissenschaft werden zahlreiche Rechtsprobleme anhand fiktiver oder tatsächlicher Fälle erörtert. Diese Liste enthält Entscheidungen und erfundene Sachverhalte, die besonders anschaulich ein oder mehrere Rechtsprobleme darstellen und… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Liste der Fallbeispiele in der Rechtswissenschaft — In der Rechtswissenschaft werden zahlreiche Rechtsprobleme anhand fiktiver oder tatsächlicher Fälle erörtert. Diese Liste enthält Entscheidungen und erfundene Sachverhalte, die besonders anschaulich ein oder mehrere Rechtsprobleme darstellen und… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Liste von Fallbeispielen in der Rechtswissenschaft — In der Rechtswissenschaft werden zahlreiche Rechtsprobleme anhand fiktiver oder tatsächlicher Fälle erörtert. Diese Liste enthält Entscheidungen und erfundene Sachverhalte, die besonders anschaulich ein oder mehrere Rechtsprobleme darstellen und… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • acceptance — I noun accedence, acceptio, accession, accordance, acknowledgment, acquiescence, adoption, agreement, allowance, approbation, approval, assent, assurance, compliance, comprobatio, concordance, consent, endorsement, ratification, receipt,… …   Law dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”