Birth aboard aircraft and ships

The subject of birth aboard aircraft and ships is one with a long history in public international law. The law on the subject, despite the provisions of Article 3 the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness, is complex, because various states apply differing principles of nationality, namely "jus soli" and "jus sanguinis", to varying degrees and with varying qualifications.

Historical background

Prior to the 1961 Convention, quite a number of states expressly provided, in their laws, that births and deaths aboard an aircraft registered to that state are considered to have occurred on national territory, and thus the nationality laws of that territory apply. One such was § 32(5) of the British Nationality Act 1948. However, this did not solve the problems caused by dual citizenship and conflicts with other states claiming equal competence through the application of the "jus sanguinis" principle. [cite book|title=Recueil Des Cours, Volume 119 (1963/III)|editor=Académie de Droit International de La Ha|date=1969|publisher=Martinus Nijhoff Publishers|isbn=9028615628|author=Ludovico M. Bentovoglio|chapter=Conflicts Problems in Air Law|pages=120–121]

Contemporary laws

Under the 1944 Convention on International Civil Aviation, articles 17–21, all aircraft have the nationality of the state in which they are registered, and may not have multiple nationalities. For births, the law of the aircraft's nationality is applicable, and for births that occur in flight whilst the aircraft is not within the territory of any state, it is the only applicable law. However, if the aircraft is in or flying over the territory of another state, that state may also have concurrent jurisdiction, and the "locus in quo" principle may apply to the exact position of the aircraft when the birth occurred. [cite book|title=Recueil Des Cours, 2001|author=Shabtai Rosenne|chapter=Space: Air, Outer, Cyber|pages=337|date=2002|publisher=Martinus Nijhoff Publishers|isbn=9041117466]

There are still very few Member States that are party to the 1961 Convention. Furthermore, conflicts of laws still exist, in particular between the laws of North and South American states, which adhere (in general) to the "jus soli" principle, and the laws of European states, which adhere (in general) to the "jus sanguinis" principle.cite book|title=International Law in the 21st Century: Rules for Global Governance|author=Christopher C. Joyner|chapter=The Individual|pages=63|date=2005|publisher=Rowman & Littlefield|isbn=0742500098]

United States

U.S. law holds that natural persons born on foreign ships docked at U.S. ports or born within the limit of U.S. territorial waters are U.S. citizens. An important exception to this rule is that children born to people who (in line with the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution) are not "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States (e.g. diplomats accredited with the United States Department of State) are not automatically U.S. citizens. [cite book|title=Multistate and Multinational Estate Planning|edition=Third Edition|author=Jeffrey A. Schoenblum|pages=9—56|date=2006|publisher=CCH|isbn=0808089501] Despite a common misconception to the contrary,Fact|date=January 2008 birth on board a U.S.-flagged ship or airliner outside of the 12-nautical mile (22.2 km) limit is not considered to be a birth on U.S. territory, and the principle of "jus soli" thus does not apply.

References

Further reading

*cite book|chapter=Birth on board aircraft|title=Discriminatory Refusal of Carriage in North America|author=Barbara Reukema|pages=117–124|date=1982|publisher=Kluwer Law and Taxation Publishers|isbn=9065440496
*cite journal|title=Statelessness as a Consequence of the Conflict of Nationality Laws|author=William Samore|journal=The American Journal of International Law|volume=45|issue=3|date=July 1951|pages=476–494|doi=10.2307/2194545
*cite book|title=Law Among Nations: An Introduction to Public International Law|author=Gerhard Von Glahn|chapter=The Law and the Individual|pages=202|date=1976|publisher=Macmillan|isbn=0024231509
*cite book|title=International Law Reports|author=Lauterpacht|chapter="re" Delgado de Román|pages=371–372|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=0949009377 — a 1956 case in Argentina exemplifying how both Spanish and Argentinian laws could apply to a birth aboard ship. The decision in the case cites cite encyclopedia|article=Birth on Board Ship|encyclopedia=Spanish Encyclopedia|volume=23|pages=328.
*cite book|title=The British Year Book of International Law|author=British Institute of International Affairs|pages=306|chapter=Nationality in Public International Law|date=1965|publisher=Hodder and Stoughton|volume=39

ee also

*List of people born at sea