R. v. Martineau

R. v. Martineau

SCCInfoBox
case-name=R. v. Martineau
heard-date=March 26, 1990
decided-date=September 13, 1990
full-case-name=Her Majesty The Queen v. Roderick Russell Martineau
citations= [1990] 2 S.C.R. 633
history=-
ruling=
ratio=
SCC=1990-1991
Majority=Lamer C.J.
JoinMajority=Dickson C.J. and Wilson, Gonthier, and Cory JJ.
Concurrence=Sopinka J.
Dissent=L'Heureux-Dubé J.

"R. v. Martineau" [Case citation#Canada| [1990] 2 S.C.R. 633] is a leading Supreme Court of Canada case on the mens rea requirement for murder. This case follows up on the issues discussed by the court in "R. v. Vaillancourt" and concludes that crimes with "stigmas" require proof of subjective foresight.

Background

One evening in February 1990, Patrick Tremblay and 15 year-old Mr. Martineau set out to rob a trailer owned by the McLean family in Valleyview, Alberta. Martineau was armed with a pellet gun and Tremblay was armed with a rifle. Martineau was under the impression that they were only going to commit breaking and entering and no one would be killed. However, during the robbery Tremblay shot and killed Mr. and Mrs. McLean.

Martineau was charged with second degree murder (s.213(a) and (d) of the Criminal Code of Canada) for both deaths (under s.21(1) and (2)) and was transferred to adult court.

At trial Martineau was convicted. But in appeal at the Alberta Court of Appeal the court overturned the decision, concluding that s.213(a) violated s.7 and s.11(d) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The issue before the Court was whether the appeal court was correct in holding s.213(a) as a violation of ss. 7 and 11(d) of the Charter.

Ruling

The Supreme Court upheld the ruling of the Appeal Court. s.213(a), deciding that it violated the Charter and could not be saved under s.1.

Majority

The Majority was written by Lamer C.J.C. with Dickson C.J.C., Wilson, Gonthier, and Cory JJ concurring.

Section 213(a) is known as the "constructive murder" provision of the criminal code. Section 213(a) defined culpable homicide as murder where a person causes the death of another while committing specific indictable offences, such as breaking and entering. This meant that one could be charged with murder under s. 213(a), despite having had neither an intent to kill nor the subjective knowledge that death might ensue from their actions. This was in contrast to the other murder provisions in the Code that require a subjective intent and foresight for a conviction.

Section 213(a) of the Code violated both ss. 7 and 11(d) of the Charter. Specifically, it violated the principle of fundamental justice that an appropriate mens rea must be proven by the Crown. Furthermore, the appropriate level of mens rea should be correlated to (1) the severity of the punishment and (2) the social stigma stemming from conviction. Murder is a major indictable offence: both the punishment and stigma stemming from conviction are severe. This being the case, the state must show subjective foresight and intent in order to prove the offence. However, as stated above, such a requirement was absent from s. 213(a). Thus, the violation was not justifiable under s. 1 of the Charter because it failed the proportionality test.

Dissent

L'Heureux-Dube J., alone, dissented. She held that s.213(a) did not violate either section of the Charter.

Comments

It should be noted that the judgment cites "two" Chief Justices. That is because Dickson was Chief Justice at the time of the hearing but retired before the judgement and was replaced by Lamer who wrote the decision as Chief Justice.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases (Lamer Court)

External links

*


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Martineau — is a surname, it is of French origin and may refer to: Alice Martineau (1972 – 2003), English pop singer and songwriter Alfred Albert Martineau (1857–1941), French Governor General Eugène Martineau (politician) (1837–1880), Ottawa mayor Eugène… …   Wikipedia

  • Martineau Place — is a shopping centre located in the city centre of Birmingham, England. It is located on land bounded by High Street, Union Street, Bull Street and Corporation Street and is directly opposite House of Fraser, formerly known as Rackhams. Developed …   Wikipedia

  • Martineau — ist der Familienname folgender Personen: André Martineau (1930–1972), französischer Mathematiker Eugene Martineau (* 1980), niederländischer Zehnkämpfer Harriet Martineau (1802−1876), englische Schriftstellerin Henri Martineau (1882–1958),… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Martineau Galleries — is an important proposed mixed use development for Birmingham, England as it will connect the Eastside to the city centre core and is also located on the High Street, a major retail area. Contents 1 History 1.1 Pre 1960s development 1.2… …   Wikipedia

  • Martineau — (spr. nō), 1) Harriet, engl. Schriftstellerin, geb. 12. Juni 1802 zu Norw ich in Norfolk, gest. 27. Juni 1876 zu Ambleside in Westmoreland, bereiste 1336 Nordamerika, später den Orient. Außer Erzählungen, Beschreibungen ihrer Reisen, Schriften… …   Meyers Großes Konversations-Lexikon

  • Martineau, Henriette — Martineau, Henriette. Diese originelle englische Dichterin beschäftigt sich vorzugsweise mit der Staatswirthschaftslehre. In mehr als 20 Bänden hat sie ihre Erfahrungen, Beobachtungen und Vorschläge, diesen Gegenstand betreffend, veröffentlicht.… …   Damen Conversations Lexikon

  • Martineau — Martineau, Martinet Diminutifs français formés sur Martin. Les Martineau se rencontrent surtout dans l Ouest (17, 72, 85, variantes Martinaud, Martinault, Martineaud), et les Martinet dans le Dauphiné et la Savoie (à rapprocher de l italien… …   Noms de famille

  • Martineau — (spr. Martinoh), 1) Harriet, von französischer Abkunft, Tochter eines Fabrikbesitzers u. von Kindheit taub, geb. 1802 in Norwich, widmete sich der Schriftstellern, bereiste 1836 Nordamerika u. später den Orient u. schrieb außer mehreren… …   Pierer's Universal-Lexikon

  • Martineau — (–no), Harriet, geb. 1802 zu Norwich, wurde früh taub, lieferte mehre Reisebeschreibungen u. versuchte es die Grundsätze der Nationalökonomie in Erzählungen darzustellen. Ihr Bruder James, unitarischer Geistlicher zu Liverpool, gab »Streben nach… …   Herders Conversations-Lexikon

  • Martineau — Martineau, Harriet …   Dictionary of sociology

  • Martineau — [märt′ n ō΄] Harriet 1802 76; Eng. writer & economist …   English World dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”