Frank Lyon Co. v. United States

Frank Lyon Co. v. United States

SCOTUSCase
Litigants=Frank Lyon Co. v. United States
ArgueDate=November 2
ArgueYear=1977
DecideDate=April 18
DecideYear=1978
FullName=Frank Lyon Co. v. United States
USVol=436
USPage=561
Citation=98 S. Ct. 1291; 55 L. Ed. 2d 550; 1978 U.S. LEXIS 22; 78-1 U.S. Tax Cas. (CCH) P9370; 41 A.F.T.R.2d (RIA) 1142
Prior=Certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the xxxx Circuit
Subsequent=
Holding=
SCOTUS=1975-1981
Majority=
JoinMajority=
Concurrence=
Dissent=
JoinDissent=
NotParticipating=
LawsApplied=Title 26, § xxxx of the United States Code

"Frank Lyon Company v. United States", 435 U.S. 561 (1978), is a case in which the U.S. Supreme Court held that the title owner that acquired depreciable real estate as if the owner were a mere conduit or agent was indeed the owner and, for Federal income tax purposes, had the legal right to take tax deductions associated with depreciation on the building. While it allow many real estate developers and tax shelter lawyers a good living, this is no longer good law after Congress enacted the Tax Reform Act of 1986.

Facts

According to the text of the syllabus preceding the Court's opinion:

::A state bank, which was a member of the Federal Reserve System, upon realizing that it was not feasible, because of various state and federal regulations, for it to finance by conventional mortgage and other financing a building under construction for its headquarters and principal banking facility, entered into sale-and-leaseback agreements by which petitioner took title to the building and leased it back to the bank for long-term use, petitioner obtaining both a construction loan and permanent mortgage financing. The bank is obligated to pay rent equal to the principal and interest payments on petitioner's mortgage and has an option to repurchase the building at various times at prices equal to the then unpaid balance of petitioner's mortgage and initial $500,000 investment. On its federal income tax return for the year in which the building was completed and the bank took possession, petitioner accrued rent from the bank and claimed as deductions depreciation on the building, interest on its construction loan and mortgage, and other expenses related to the sale-and-leaseback transaction.

The bank was Worthen Bank in Little Rock and the Frank Lyon Company was a sporting goods store. The bank bought the land and started construction of the subject building before it found a buyer. The Frank Lyon Company won the bidding to buy the building from the bank by providing $500,000 of the 7.6 million dollar purchase price. The rest of the money came from New York Life. The mortgage loan's payments to the lender and the rent payments were engineered to be exactly equal. The title owner, Frank Lyon, never actually received the rent payments from the Worthen Bank because the three party deal specifically required that Worthern pay New York Life directly. The lease was triple net (i.e. any increase in expenses are paid not by the owner, but by the tenant).

Another fact which leads a reasonable man to conclude that Worthen Bank was the real party in a two party deal and that the Frank Lyon company was a mere agent, is that the tenant—Worthen Bank—had a 25 year lease with options to either buy the building or extend the lease for 65 years when it could still buy the building. The option's strike price was set so that Frank Lyon would be repaid exactly its $500,000 plus 6% interest.

Economic owners of an asset would be expected to bear the benefits and burdens of any change in market value of the thing owned. But here it would be Worthen bank the tenant and not the title owner who bears the benefits and burdens. The transaction was a classic sale leaseback.

Later developments

The result of this case was modified by the Tax Reform Act of 1986, which disallowed this tax feature. The Rose Law Firm represented the taxpayer.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • United States Senate election in New Jersey, 2006 — 2000 ← November 7, 2006 → 2012 …   Wikipedia

  • United States Secret Service — Common name Secret Service Abbreviation USSS …   Wikipedia

  • List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 435 — This is a list of all the United States Supreme Court cases from volume 435 of the United States Reports :* Califano v. Torres , ussc|435|1|1978 (per curiam) * Simpson v. United States , ussc|435|6|1978 * Central Ill. Public Service Co. v. United …   Wikipedia

  • United States congressional delegations from New York — These are tables of congressional delegations from New York to the United States Senate and United States House of Representatives. Over the years, New York has demographically changed so that it is hard to consider each district to be a… …   Wikipedia

  • United States congressional delegations from Minnesota — These are tables of congressional delegations from Minnesota to the United States Senate and United States House of Representatives. Minnesota became a state on May 11, 1858. Contents 1 United States Senate 2 Hou …   Wikipedia

  • United States House of Representatives elections in California, 1996 — The United States House of Representatives elections in California, 1996 was an election for California s delegation to the United States House of Representatives, which occurred as part of the general election of the House of Representatives on… …   Wikipedia

  • United States intervention in Chile — The United States intervention in Chilean politics started during the War of Chilean Independence. The influence of the United States of America in both the economic and the political arenas of Chile has gradually increased over the almost two… …   Wikipedia

  • United States at the 1984 Summer Olympics — Infobox Olympics United States games=1984 Summer competitors=521 sports=25 flagbearer=Ed Burke gold=83 silver=61 bronze=30 total=174 rank=1The United States was the host nation of the 1984 Summer Olympics in Los Angeles, California. It was the… …   Wikipedia

  • LGBT movements in the United States — comprise an interwoven history of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender social and political movements in the United States of America, beginning in the early 20th century. They have been influential worldwide in achieving social progress for… …   Wikipedia

  • Copper mining in the United States — US primary copper production 1900 2008. Source: USGS …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”