R. v. Vaillancourt

R. v. Vaillancourt

SCCInfoBox
case-name=R. v. Vaillancourt
full-case-name=Yvan Vaillancourt v. Her Majesty The Queen
heard-date=December 10, 1986
decided-date=December 3, 1987
docket=18963
citations= [1987] 2 S.C.R. 636, 1987 SCC 78
chief-justice=Dickson
puisne-justices= Beetz, Estey, McIntyre, Chouinard*, Lamer, Wilson, Le Dain and La Forest JJ.
(*)Chouinard took no part in judgment
Majority=Lamer J. (paras. 1-43)
JoinMajority=Dickson, Estey, Wilson J.
Concurrence=Beetz J. (paras. 44-46)
JoinConcurrence=Le Dain J.
Dissent=McIntyre J. (paras. 47-54)
|

"R. v. Vaillancourt", [1987] 2 S.C.R. 636, 1987 SCC 78, is a landmark case from the Supreme Court of Canada on the constitutionality of criminal code offence of "constructive murder". The Court ruled that crimes with significant "stigma" attached, such as culpable homicide and constructive murder, require proof of the mens rea element of "objective foresight of death".

Background

Yvan Vaillancourt and a friend planned to rob a local pool hall. Before the robbery they had agreed to only use knives. However, when his friend showed up for the robbery with a gun Vaillancourt made him take the bullets out and place them in his glove. Immediately after the robbery took place, Vaillancourt saw his friend go back into the hall where a fight broke out between his friend and a customer. In the struggle, the customer was shot with his friend's gun and later died of his wounds. Vaillancourt was caught by the police at the scene but his accomplice got away.

Vaillancourt was charged with "culpable homicide" under s. 213(d) (now s. 230(d)) of the Criminal Code of Canada because he was considered an "accomplice by operation" under s.21(2) of the Code. Under s.213(d), a person using a weapon resulting in death while committing a robbery was guilty of murder, regardless of whether they intended to cause death or knew that death was likely to occur.

The issue before the court was whether s.213(d) violated either s.7 or s.11(d) of the Charter.

Vaillancourt argued that it was a principle of fundamental justice that no accused should be liable for an offence without showing some degree of "subjective mens rea".

Reasoning of the Court

The majority was written by Lamer J. with Dickson, Estey, and Wilson JJ. concurring.

The Court looked at the elements of the offence as well as the punishment that accompanies it. Punishment for murder was an automatic life sentence which produced a "stigma" upon the offender. The moral blameworthiness of the accused must be proportional to the punishment, thus there must be proof beyond a reasonable doubt of subjective foresight. However, for the case at hand there cannot be a conviction without proof of "objective foresight".

The Court accepted Vaillancourt's argument regarding the principle of fundamental justice. Thus, since s.213(d) did not require any foresight of death it was in violation of a principle of fundamental justice and so violated s.7 of the Charter, and could not be saved under s.1.

Aftermath

Section s. 213(d) was repealed in 1991.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases (Dickson Court)

External links

*
* [http://www.mapleleafweb.com/scc/public3/decisions/1987_2scr_636_02.html case summary at mapleleafweb.com]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Vaillancourt — Cette page d’homonymie répertorie les différents sujets et articles partageant un même nom. Armand Vaillancourt, né à Black Lake, Québec, le 3 septembre 1929, est connu comme sculpteur et activiste. Claude Vaillancourt  Gilles Vaillancourt… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Michel Vaillancourt — Vaillancourt, Michel Personal information Full name Michel Vaillancourt Nationality  Canada Discipline …   Wikipedia

  • Armand Vaillancourt — encourage les artistes en herbe à la Place des Arts lors du Festival International de Jazz de Montréal Armand Vaillancourt, C.Q., né à Black Lake, Québec le 3 septembre 1929, est connu comme sculpteur et militant …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Sarah Vaillancourt — Born May 8, 1985 (1985 05 08) (age 26) Sherbrooke, QC, CAN Height …   Wikipedia

  • Dan Vaillancourt — Infobox musical artist | Name = Dan Vaillancourt Background = Singer, Songwriter, Guitarist Birth name = Dan Vaillancourt Instrument = Songwriter, Guitar, Singer Genre = Folk Occupation = Songwriter, Recording Artist URL =… …   Wikipedia

  • Gilles Vaillancourt — (né le 9 janvier 1941) est le maire de Laval depuis 1989. Il siège au conseil depuis 1973. Le parti de Gilles Vaillancourt se nomme le Parti PRO des Lavallois et il a été créé en 1980. Il a succédé comme maire et comme dirigeant du parti à Claude …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Cyrille Vaillancourt — (January 17, 1892 – October 30, 1969) was a journalist, civil servant, businessman and political figure in Quebec. Vaillancourt played an important role in the development of the caisses populaires in Quebec[1]. He represented La Durantaye… …   Wikipedia

  • Fontaine Vaillancourt — La statue « Québec libre ! » d Armand Vaillancourt. Créée en 1971, cette fontaine est installée à Justin Herman Plaza à San Francisco, Californie. Elle est connue localement sous le nom de « Vaillancourt Fountain ». La… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Claude Vaillancourt (Juge) — Claude Vaillancourt (19 mai 1944 ) est un avocat, juge et homme politique québécois, né à Chicoutimi. Il est député de la circonscription de Jonquière à l Assemblée nationale du Québec de 1976 à 1983, sous la bannière du Parti québécois …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Claude vaillancourt (juge) — Claude Vaillancourt (19 mai 1944 ) est un avocat, juge et homme politique québécois, né à Chicoutimi. Il est député de la circonscription de Jonquière à l Assemblée nationale du Québec de 1976 à 1983, sous la bannière du Parti québécois …   Wikipédia en Français

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”