Devlin Committee

Devlin Committee

The Devlin Committee was a UK committee based on the Devlin report of 1976, which looked at a number of criminal cases in order to draw conclusions on the method of visual identification of suspects. The committee was established to follow on from the investigations into the wrongful accusation of Adolf Beck by the English Court of Criminal Appeal in 1907. The Devlin report submitted to the committee was made after a number of cases where identity parades led to the mis-identification of a suspect. These included Alfred Beck, Oscar Slater, Luke Dougherty and Laszlo Virag, cases ranging from 1908 to 1972.

Although the report uncovered a number of cases where innocent individuals were wrongly convicted, particularly in the case of Laszlo Virag in 1969, who was identified by 8 witnesses despite a plausible alibi, and Luke Dougherty who was picked by 2 witnesses but later cleared under similar circumstances. While the Devlin committee did rule that many witnesses overstated their ability to single out the right person, Professor Glanville Williams commented on the report that:

Neither the Beck case at the turn of the century nor the many miscarriages of justice since then have sufficiently impressed those concerned with criminal justice of the dangers of identification evidence. To mention some of the instances in late years: three occurred alone in the space of a few months in 1967-68. A memorandum of the National Council of Civil Liberties published in 1968 gave details of 15 cases from 1966 onwards; in most of these a person was convicted on identification evidence and the mistake was either established or very likely; in a few of them the defendant had not gone beyond being committed for trial when by a happy accident the mistake was discovered.[1]

The Devlin committee and its actions were highlighted in the media more recently, in 2005, following the shooting of Jean Charles de Menezes and the rapid growth of an eye-witness reports that were later found to be exaggerated or false.[2]

A previous Devlin Committee was appointed by the Ministry of Labour in October 1964 to look into disputes, decasualisation and dissension in the port transport industry. It reported in July 1965. Both committees were chaired by the Law Lord Patrick Devlin, Baron Devlin, hence the name.

Notes

  1. ^ Devlin Committee Report: Report of the Committee on Evidence of Identification in Criminal Cases, 1976 Cmnd 338 134/135, 42
  2. ^ BBC news article The problem with eyewitnesses, Finlo Rohrer, 24 August 2005. Retrieved on April 25, 2007




Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Chris Devlin-Young — Olympic medal record Men s Paralympic Alpine Skiing Gold 1994 Lillehammer Slalom Gold 2002 Salt Lake City Super G Silver 2002 Salt Lake City …   Wikipedia

  • Richard Devlin — Infobox State Senator name =Richard Devlin width = height = caption = birth date =birth date and age|1952|9|9 birth place =Eugene, Oregon residence = Tualatin, Oregon death date = death place = state senate = Oregon district = 19th term start… …   Wikipedia

  • Mark D. Devlin — For the Irish soccer player, see Mark Devlin (disambiguation). Mark D. Devlin Mark D. Devlin, Stubborn Child Born February 4, 1948 Dorchester, Massachusetts Died March …   Wikipedia

  • Daniel Devlin — Daniel Joseph Devlin (1814 – February 22, 1867) was a prosperous businessman, City Chamberlain, and prominent citizen of New York City. Devlin was born at Buncrana, County Donegal, Ireland, in 1814. As a young merchant tailor, he emigrated to… …   Wikipedia

  • Art Devlin (ski jumper) — Arthur Art Donovan Devlin (September 7, 1922 ndash; April 22, 2004) was an American ski jumper who competed during the 1950s. A native of Lake Placid, New York, he finished fifth in the individual large hill at the 1950 FIS Nordic World Ski… …   Wikipedia

  • Jean Charles de Menezes — Infobox Person| name=Jean Charles de Menezes caption=Jean Charles de Menezes birth date=birth date|1978|1|7|df=y birth place=Gonzaga, Minas Gerais, Brazil death date=death date and age|2005|7|22|1978|1|7|df=y death place=Stockwell Underground… …   Wikipedia

  • Death of Jean Charles de Menezes — Jean Charles de Menezes Born 7 January 1978(1978 01 07) Gonzaga, Minas Gerais, Brazil Died 22 July 2005( …   Wikipedia

  • Oscar Slater — Oscar Joseph Slater (8 January 1872 – 31 January 1948) was a victim of British miscarriage of justice. He was born Oscar Leschziner in Oppeln, Upper Silesia, Germany to a Jewish family. Around 1893, to evade military service, he moved to London… …   Wikipedia

  • CIA transnational human rights actions — This article deals with those activities of the Central Intelligence Agency that preserve or violate human rights. General principlesIn 2003, Assistant Secretary of state for Human Rights Patricia Derian when she wrote, Through these [U.S.… …   Wikipedia

  • All Saints GAC — Infobox GAA club club gaa = All Saints GAC irish = Naomh Uile CLG crest = founded = 1975 county = Antrim province=Ulster nickname = The Saints colours = Black and White grounds =Slemish Park pattern la= blackshoulders|pattern b=|pattern ra=… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”