Lake Wobegon effect

Lake Wobegon effect

The Lake Wobegon effect designates either: the human tendency to overestimate one's achievements and capabilities in relation to others (in academic sources this is more usually called the above average effect or the better-than-average effect); or the finding that in many educational tests a vast majority of participants achieve results above the norm.

It is named for the fictional town of Lake Wobegon from the radio series "A Prairie Home Companion", where, according to the presenter, Garrison Keillor, "all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the children are above average."

The better-than-average effect

The above average effect or better-than-average effect is one kind of positive illusion. It describes the tendency for people to evaluate themselves as 'better than average' on desirable skills, characteristics or behaviors. It is a characteristic bias of social comparison where people usually compare themselves to an unspecified peer and, despite the mathematical odds, "en masse" judge themselves to be better than their average peer. For instance, surveying drivers, the Swedish researcher Ola Svenson found that 88% of American college students rated themselves as above 50% on driving skills. [Cite journal
author = Ola Svenson
year = 1981
month = February
title = Are we all less risky and more skillful than our fellow drivers?
journal = Acta Psychologica
volume = 47
issue = 2
pages = 143–148
doi = 10.1016/0001-6918(81)90005-6
] Asking college students about their popularity, Zuckerman and Jost (2001) showed that most students judged themselves to be "more popular than average". [Cite journal
author = Ezra W. Zuckerman & John T. Jost
year = 2001
title = What Makes You Think You're So Popular? Self Evaluation Maintenance and the Subjective Side of the "Friendship Paradox"
journal = Social Psychology Quarterly
volume = 64
issue = 3
pages = 207–223
url = http://www.psych.nyu.edu/jost/Zuckerman%20&%20Jost%20(2001)%20What%20Makes%20You%20Think%20You're%20So%20Popular1.pdf
doi = 10.2307/3090112
]

In a similar way, a large majority of people claim to be above average; this phenomenon has been observed among drivers, CEOs, stock market analysts, college students, police officers and state education officials, among others. Experiments and surveys have repeatedly shown that most people believe that they possess attributes that are better or more desirable than average. The term is also used to describe a perceived tendency to treat children as "special" in order to boost their self-esteem, even though the children may only be average or even underperforming.

One College Board survey asked 829,000 high school seniors to rate themselves in a number of ways. When asked to rate their own ability to "get along with others", fewer than one percent rated themselves as below average. Furthermore, sixty percent rated themselves in the top ten percent, and one-fourth of respondents rated themselves in the top one percent. Some have argued that more subjective traits like this may be more easily distorted.

The effect has been found repeatedly by many other studies for other traits, including fairness, virtuosity, luck, and investing ability, to name a few. It is similar and may be related to ingroup bias and wishful thinking. However, it is not a universal tendency: under some circumstances, a worse-than-average effect is seen instead. This refers to a tendency to underestimate oneself in certain conditions, which may include self-handicapping behavior. It can be compared to the false consensus effect. The better-than-average effect may not have wholly social origins: judgements about inanimate objects may suffer similar distortions [Cite journal
author = E. E. Giladi & Y. Klar
year = 2002
title = When standards are wide of the mark: Nonselective superiority and inferiority biases in comparative judgments of objects and concepts
journal =
volume = 131
pages = 538–551
]

Distorted statistics

In 1987, John Cannell completed a study that reported the statistically impossible finding that all states claimed average student test scores above the national norm. The finding is generally admitted; the causes are disputed. [Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice 7 (2) 5-9; discussion in vol 7 (4); newspaper report http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE6D9143EF934A25751C0A96E948260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=all] One possible cause is teaching to the test.

Asymmetric distributions

In most situations, there is no reason to expect that in a statistical survey exactly half of the participants score above-average, and the other half below-average – this is the distinction between the median (half of participants) and the mean (average). It is possible and not at all uncommon that the score distribution is asymmetric. For example, nearly all people have above-average number of legs.

As an extreme case, if one point in a series is low enough, all other points may be above average (Five students are asked to rate their looks on a scale of 1 to 10. Four say they rate their looks as a 9 and the last one says their looks rate as a 4. The mean of that series would be 8, making 80% of the students of above 'average' looks.) And if a series is binary, every non zero point is above average. (Students take a simple exam, which is rated as either passing (with a score of 1) or failing (with a score of 0). Assuming that at least one student fails the test and at least one student passes the test, the mean will lie somewhere between 1 and 0 and thus every student that fails the test will be below average (scoring 0) and every student that passes will be above average (scoring 1).)

Such effects of an asymmetric distribution would not normally be called a "Lake Wobegon effect".

ee also

* Dunning-Kruger effect
* List of cognitive biases
* Overconfidence effect

Notes

References

* Alicke, M. D., & Govorun, O. (2005). The better-than-average effect. In Alicke, M. D., D. A. Dunning & J. I. Krueger, "The Self in Social Judgment" New York: Psychology Press. (ISBN 978-1-84169-418-4)
* Kruger, J. (1999). Lake Wobegon be gone! The "below-average effect" and the egocentric nature of comparative ability judgments. "Journal of Personality and Social Psychology," 77, 221-232.
* Kruger J., & Dunning D. (1999). [http://www.apa.org/journals/features/psp7761121.pdf Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments.] "Journal of Personality and Social Psychology," 77, 121-1134
* Myers, D. G. (1980). "The Inflated Self". New York: Seabury Press.

External links

* [http://www.wordspy.com/words/LakeWobegoneffect.asp Lake Wobegon effect]
* [http://www.damninteresting.com/?p=406 Unskilled and Unaware of It]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Lake Wobegon effect — (layk WOH.bee.gawn uh.fekt) n. The tendency to treat all members of a group as above average, particularly with respect to numerical values such as test scores or executive salaries; in a survey, the tendency for most people to describe… …   New words

  • Lake Wobegon — is a fictional town in the U.S. state of Minnesota, said to have been the boyhood home of Garrison Keillor, who reports the News from Lake Wobegon on the radio show A Prairie Home Companion. Lake Wobegon is characterized as the town where all the …   Wikipedia

  • Overconfidence effect — The overconfidence effect is a well established bias in which someone s subjective confidence in their judgments is reliably greater than their objective accuracy, especially when confidence is relatively high.[1] For example, in some quizzes,… …   Wikipedia

  • Worse-than-average effect — The worse than average effect or below average effect is the human tendency to underestimate one s achievements and capabilities in relation to others. It is the opposite of the usually pervasive Lake Wobegon effect (which may be called the… …   Wikipedia

  • quake lake — n. A lake formed when an earthquake causes landslides that block a large river. Example Citations: The threat of flash floods from dams and quake lakes formed from landslides blocking rivers has forced tens of thousands of already traumatized… …   New words

  • reverse Bradley effect — n. Declaring publicly that one cannot vote for a candidate because of his or her race, but then voting for that candidate in the secrecy of the ballot booth; voting for a candidate because of his or her race. Example Citations: When polls showed… …   New words

  • CSI effect — n. The unrealistically high expectations some jurors have for the prosecution s case in a criminal court proceeding, particularly when those expectations are created by exposure to forensic oriented TV shows. Also: CSI factor, CSI syndrome.… …   New words

  • False consensus effect — The false consensus effect is the tendency for people to project their way of thinking onto other people. [cite web url = http://www.psychologycampus.com/social psychology/false consensus.html title = False Consensus False Uniqueness publisher =… …   Wikipedia

  • birthplace effect — n. The tendency for smaller cities to produce disproportionately more professional athletes than larger cities. Example Citations: A few years a ago, sport scientist Jean Côté and his colleagues discovered a phenomenon they termed the birthplace… …   New words

  • Dunning-Kruger effect — The Dunning Kruger effect is an example of cognitive bias in which people who are worst at a task show the most illusory superiority, rating their own ability as above average.HypothesesThe phenomenon was demonstrated in a series of experiments… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”