Transformation (law)

Transformation (law)

In United States copyright law, transformation is a possible justification that use of a copyrighted work may qualify as fair use, i.e., that a certain use of a work does not infringe its holder's copyright due to the public interest in the usage. Transformation is an important issue in deciding whether a use meets the first factor of the fair-use test, and is generally critical for determining whether a use is in fact fair, although no one factor is dispositive.

Basis

Like most of the modern fair use doctrine, the doctrine of transformation was heavily influenced by the 1841 circuit court case "Folsom v. Marsh". In that case, Justice Story ruled that

if [someone] thus cites the most important parts of the work, with a view, not to criticise, but to supersede the use of the original work, and substitute the review for it, such a use will be deemed in law a piracy.
The standard of "supersed [ing] the use of the original work" would be widely cited as a standard for the degree to which a work was transformative when fair use had become more clearly fixed as a legal principle.

In the Copyright Act of 1976, Congress defined fair use explicitly for the first time, giving as one factor "the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes". This factor was later determined to hinge in substantial part on transformation. See, e.g., "Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music", a case in the United States Supreme Court:

Under the first of the four 107 factors, "the purpose and Page II character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature . . .," the enquiry focuses on whether the new work merely supersedes the objects of the original creation, or whether and to what extent it is "transformative," altering the original with new expression, meaning, or message. The more transformative the new work, the less will be the significance of other factors, like commercialism, that may weigh against a finding of fair use.
"Campbell" is important in large part because of this statement, ordering that commerciality should be given less weight in fair-use determinations and transformation great weight.

Application

There is no "bright line test" to determine whether one work supersedes the purpose of another; like the determination of fair use generally, it involves significant judgment calls. However, there is substantial precedent that clarifies the nature of transformation in law.

Generally, use of a work to comment on the work itself somehow will qualify as transformative. Quoting portions of a work to criticize it, as in a book review, is transformative. Likewise, parody is transformative — repurposing a work to mock the work itself or the principles the work represents serves a very different purpose from that of the original work.

Repurposing a work to aid identification of the base work is also generally transformative. In "Kelly v. Ariba Soft" and "Perfect 10 v. Google", the respective courts held that the creation and use of thumbnails to allow users of a search engine to easily browse through images returned by their search was transformative.

Of course, as noted above, no one factor of fair use is dispositive; all must be considered. Even transformative uses can be infringing, if other factors weigh against the defendant. See, e.g., "Perfect 10 v. Google" (use was transformative but interfered with the copyright holder's ability to market the work), "Rogers v. Koons" (transformation not cited explicitly, but rather ignored in light of the use's failure to meet any of the purposes in the preamble of 17 USC § 107).


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • transformation law — transformacijos formulė statusas T sritis fizika atitikmenys: angl. transformation law vok. Transformationsformel, f rus. формула преобразования, f; формула трансформации, f pranc. formule de transformation, f …   Fizikos terminų žodynas

  • Galileo transformation law — Galilėjaus transformacijos formulė statusas T sritis fizika atitikmenys: angl. Galileo transformation law vok. Galileische Transformationsformel, f rus. формула трансформации Галилея, f pranc. formule de transformation de Galilée, f …   Fizikos terminų žodynas

  • Lorentz transformation law — Lorenco transformacijos formulė statusas T sritis fizika atitikmenys: angl. Lorentz transformation law vok. Lorentzsche Transformationsformel, f rus. формула трансформации Лоренца, f pranc. formule de transformation de Lorentz, f …   Fizikos terminų žodynas

  • transformation — index conversion (change), development (progression), reconversion, reorganization, transition Burton s Legal Thesaurus …   Law dictionary

  • Transformation — (root transform ) may refer to:Transformation is also referred to as a turn.In science: * Transformation (geometry), in mathematics, as a general term applies to mathematical functions. ** Data transformation (statistics) in statistics. *… …   Wikipedia

  • Transformation of culture — Transformation of culture, or cultural change, to the dynamic process whereby the living cultures of the world are changing and adapting to external or internal forces. This process is occurring within Western culture as well as non Western and… …   Wikipedia

  • LAW (J.) — La personnalité de Law mériterait de retenir l’attention, car il a – reprenant les idées émises par l’économiste Charles Davenant et par Vauban sur le développement de la richesse – démontré l’importance du crédit en répandant en France le papier …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • Law enforcement in the People's Republic of China — consists of an extensive public security system and a variety of enforcement procedures are used to maintain order in the country. Along with the courts and procuratorates, the country s judicial and public security agencies included the Ministry …   Wikipedia

  • Law enforcement in Georgia (country) — Law enforcement in Georgia has undergone a radical transformation in the last few years. In 2005 President Mikhail Saakashvili fired the entire traffic police force of the Georgian National Police due to corruption, [… …   Wikipedia

  • Transformation optics — Electromagnetism Electricity · …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”