Pournelle chart

Pournelle chart

The Pournelle chart, developed by Jerry Pournelle (in his 1963 political science Ph.D. dissertation), is a 2-dimensional coordinate system used to distinguish political ideologies. It is similar to the Political compass and the Nolan Chart in that it is a two-dimensional chart, but the axes chosen in the Pournelle chart are different from those in other systems.

The two axes are as follows:

* The "x"-axis, "Attitude toward the State" (labeled Statism), refers to a political philosophy's attitude towards state and centralised government. The farthest right is state worship, and the farthest left views the state as the "ultimate evil", preferring individual freedom.
* The "y"-axis, "Attitude toward planned social progress" (labeled Rationalism), refers to the extent to which a political philosophy holds that problems in society can be solved through the use of reason. The top indicates complete confidence in planned social progress; the bottom represents skepticism of such approaches, often seeing them as naively utopian. Those at the top of this axis would tend to discard a traditional custom if they do not understand what purpose it serves (considering it antiquated and probably useless), while those at the bottom would tend to keep the custom (considering it time-tested and probably useful).

"Leftist" ideologies, such as American liberalism, socialism and communism, are placed by Pournelle in the upper right-hand quadrant of high state control and high rationalism. Conservatism, fascism and Nazism are placed in the lower right hand quadrant of high state control and low rationalism. Classical anarchists are in the lower left hand corner of low state control and low rationalism. Libertarians and Objectivists are placed in the upper lefthand corner of low state control and high rationalism. Each diagonal axis contains "natural" political allies; in the United States, Republicans would tend to cluster along one axis and Democrats along the other.

Criticisms of the model

Some have criticized the model for the pejorative use of the word "irrational". However, the "bottom" of the scale could more specifically be seen as representing the belief that human rationality cannot perfect society (see Postmodernism vs Modernism). For example, the conservatism of Edmund Burke would be near the middle on the left-right scale, but near the bottom on the "rationality" scale (3/1', in Pournelle-style notation), because Burke believed that human society was not perfectible and was skeptical about initiatives aimed at vast improvements to society. Since Pournelle himself has views not far from those of Burke, it is clear that the term "irrational" is not intended as a pejorative. Pournelle noted that the belief that all societal problems can be solved rationally may not itself be rational. It may similarly be argued that the bottom of the top-bottom spectrum represents not a rejection of reason's power to solve scientific/technical problems (Pournelle is a technology enthusiast), but rather of its utility in forming the community and determining its sense of fundamental purpose.

ee also

*Political compass
*Political spectrum
*Nolan Chart

External links

* [http://www.baen.com/chapters/axes.htm The Pournelle Political Axes]
* [http://www.deanesmay.com/archives/001451.html Dating the Pournelle Axes]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Chart — For other uses, see Chart (disambiguation) , Graph (disambiguation) , and Diagram For information about charts in Wikipedia, see Wikipedia:Graphs and charts. A pie chart. A chart is a graphical representation of data, in which the …   Wikipedia

  • Jerry Pournelle — at the 2005 NASFiC Born August 7, 1933 (1933 08 07) (age 78) Shreveport, Louisiana Pen name …   Wikipedia

  • Nolan Chart — The Nolan Chart is a political diagram popularized by the American libertarian David Nolan. He reasoned that virtually all human political action can be divided into two general categories: economic and personal. He developed the chart to… …   Wikipedia

  • Political spectrum — A political spectrum (plural spectra) is a way of modeling different political positions by placing them upon one or more geometric axes symbolizing independent political dimensions.Most long standing spectra include a right wing and left wing,… …   Wikipedia

  • Right-wing politics — In politics, right wing, the political right, and the Right are positions that uphold traditional values and/or authorities. The term is used in contradiction to the term left wing . The left/right terminology in politics appeared during the… …   Wikipedia

  • Left-wing politics — Left wing redirects here. For the term used in sports, see Winger (sports). Leftism redirects here. For the album by Leftfield, see Leftism (album). Left of Center redirects here. For the comedy group, see Liberal Democrats. Part of the Politics… …   Wikipedia

  • Political compass — A political compass or political diamond is a multi axis model used to label or organize political thought on several dimensions. There are several competing political compasses, with varying number of axes. Overview A similar illustration… …   Wikipedia

  • Centrism — Political centre redirects here. For the Russian movement (1919–20), see Political Centre (Russia). Owing its name to the left–right political spectrum, centrism is noted for its moderate stances on societal issues In politics, centrism is the… …   Wikipedia

  • Space warfare in fiction — Space warfare in science fiction has served as a central theme within the genre, tracing its roots back to the future war novels of the 19th century. (Space warfare can be found in even older works of fiction. Lucian of Samosata s True History… …   Wikipedia

  • French Foreign Legion in popular culture — Beyond its reputation of the French Foreign Legion as an elite unit often embroiled in serious fighting, its recruitment practices have also led to a romantic view of it being a place for a wronged man to leave behind his old life to start a new… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”