Ha v New South Wales

Ha v New South Wales

Infobox Court Case
name=Ha v New South Wales
court=High Court of Australia


date_decided=5 August 1997
full_name=Ha & anor v State of New South Wales & Ors
citations= [http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/HCA/1997/34.html (1997) 189 CLR 465]
judges= Brennan CJ, Dawson, Toohey, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ
prior_actions=none
subsequent_actions=none
opinions=(4:3) The Court adopted a broad view of an excise in relation to section 90 (per Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ)

"Ha v New South Wales" (1997) 189 CLR 465 is a High Court of Australia case that dealt with section 90 of the Australian Constitution, which prohibits States from levying excise.

Facts

The plaintiffs were charged under the "Business Franchise Licences (Tobacco) Act 1987" (NSW) with selling tobacco in New South Wales without a licence. The Act provided for a licence fee, which consisted of a fixed amount, plus an amount calculated by reference to the value of tobacco sold during the 'relevant period'. The 'relevant period' was defined as 'the month commencing 2 months before the commencement of the month in which the licence expires'. The plaintiffs argued that the licence fee imposed by the Act was an excise and hence invalid due to section 90 of the Constitution.

Decision

A slim majority of the Court (Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ) ruled in favour of the plaintiffs, adopting the broad view of an excise per Matthews v Chicory. They ruled an excise was a tax on sale, production and manufacture of goods prior to consumption, applying to goods whether produced locally or not. Excises could apply to any step in dealing with the goods. The Court viewed the scheme as purely about revenue raising without a discernible regulatory element, giving it the appearance of a tax. Under this broad view, the 'licence fee' imposed by the state government was in fact an excise, which Australian states are constitutionally barred from imposing.

The Court distinguished the decision from the earlier franchise fee cases (Dennis Hotels Pty Ltd v Victoria and Dickenson's Arcade Pty Ltd v Tasmania) because the period of backdating (2 months instead of 6) and the backdating mechanism were sufficiently different.

"Ha" also featured a strong dissent, with the minority of the Court (Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ) adopting the traditional narrow view of an excise. They rejected the Parton v Milk Board (Vic) excise definition. The minority saw an excise as specifically a tax on the local manufacture or production of goods.

See also

* Section 90 of the Australian Constitution
* Australian constitutional law

References

* Winterton, G. et al. "Australian federal constitutional law: commentary and materials", 1999. LBC Information Services, Sydney.

External links

* [http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/HCA/1997/34.html Full text of the decision]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • New England (New South Wales) — New England New South Wales Mount Duval in New England Population …   Wikipedia

  • New Lambton, New South Wales — New Lambton Newcastle, New South Wales Population: 9236 (2006 census) Postcode: 2305 Area: 5.2 km² (2.0  …   Wikipedia

  • New Italy, New South Wales — New Italy New South Wales Established: 1882 Postcode: 2472 Location …   Wikipedia

  • South Creek, New South Wales — South Creek is the name for a Township in New South Wales, as well as the creek that ran through it.TownshipThe township of South Creek used to exist where the creek joins the Hawkesbury River. The name only existed for a few years in the early… …   Wikipedia

  • South Creek (New South Wales) — South Creek Wianamatta CreekVorlage:Infobox Fluss/GKZ fehlt Lage New South Wales (Australien) Flusssystem Hawkesbury RiverVorlage:Infobox Fluss/FLUSSSYSTEM falsch Abflus …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • South Coogee, New South Wales — South Coogee Sydney, New South Wales Shopping strip, Malabar Road Postcode …   Wikipedia

  • New Berrima, New South Wales — New Berrima is a village in the Southern Highlands of New South Wales, Australia, in Wingecarribee Shire. At the 2006 census, New Berrima had a population of 592 people.[1] A cement factory was established in nearby Berrima in the late 1920s. New …   Wikipedia

  • New Brighton, New South Wales — is a small town located north west of Ocean Shores. It includes a soccer field home to the Shores United Soccer Club and is very close to the Ocean Shores Public School located in North Ocean Shores, New South Wales. References Coordinates:… …   Wikipedia

  • South Maroota, New South Wales — South Maroota New South Wales Population: 509 (2006 Census) Postcode: 2756 Location: 72 km (45 mi …   Wikipedia

  • South Granville, New South Wales — South Granville redirects here. For the South Granville in Vancouver, see South Granville Rise. Infobox Australian Place | type = suburb name = South Granville city = Sydney state = nsw caption = Wellington Road, warehouse and commercial complex… …   Wikipedia

  • South Durras, New South Wales — Infobox Australian Place type = town name = South Durras state = nsw imagesize = caption = pop = 327 pop footnotes = Census 2006 AUS |id = SSC18817 |name = South Durras (State Suburb) |accessdate = 2008 03 27] poprank = density = density… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”