R. v. Gruenke

R. v. Gruenke

SCCInfoBox
case-name=R. v. Gruenke
full-case-name=Adele Rosemary Gruenke v. Her Majesty The Queen
heard-date=May 10, 1991
decided-date=October 24, 1991
citations= [1991] 3 S.C.R. 263
history=appeal from Manitoba Court of Appeal
ruling=Gruenke appeal dismissed
ratio=
SCC=1990-1991
Majority=Lamer C.J.
JoinMajority=La Forest, Sopinka, Cory, McLachlin, Stevenson and Iacobucci JJ.
Concurrence=L'Heureux-Dubé J.
JoinConcurrence=Gonthier J.
NotParticipating=

"R. v. Gruenke" [1991] 3 S.C.R. 263 is a leading Supreme Court of Canada decision on privilege. The Court developed a case-by-case test for determining if a communication is privileged. Prior to the test, only communications that fell into one of narrow set of privilege classes could gain protection from being submitted in a court of law.

Background

Adele Rosemary Gruenke was a 22 year-old reflexologist (a type of therapy similar to acupressure). Philip Barnett, an 82 year-old friend and client of Gruenke, had loaned her a significant amount of money including money to start a reflexology clinic. They lived together for a time in a platonic relationship - he had even put her in his will - until he began to make advances to her, at which point she moved home with her mother. Barnett's advances became more aggressive, to the point where she and her boyfriend plotted to kill him. One night in November 1986, she met with Barnett in his car and a fight broke out. She and her boyfriend beat Barnett to death.

Two days after the murder, a counselor who had been talking to Gruenke prior to the murder went to a local church and told the pastor there of Gruenke's intention to commit the murder.

At trial the conversation between the counselor and pastor was admitted and proved sufficient to convict Gruenke.

Opinion of the Court

The Court found that the trial judge was correct in admitting the evidence.

Lamer C.J., writing for the majority, noted that Canadian law does not recognize privilege in religious communications; however, there may be situations where such a privilege may be required.

To accommodate this need the Court adopted a four-step test proposed by American jurist John Henry Wigmore to determine whether privilege is required.
# the communications must originate in a confidence that they will not be disclosed;
# this element of confidentiality must be essential to the full and satisfactory maintenance of the relation between the parties;
# the relation must be one which in the opinion of the community ought to be sedulously fostered; and
# the injury that would inure to the relation by the disclosure of the communications must be greater than the benefit thereby gained for the correct disposal of litigation.

In application to the facts of the case, Lamer found that they did not meet the requirements of the Wigmore test and so the communication was not privileged.

External links

*


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Conrad Schmitt Studios — is an …   Wikipedia

  • Stained glass — For the Blackford Oakes novel, see Stained Glass (novel) The term stained glass refers either to the material of coloured glass or to the art and craft of working with it. Throughout its thousand year history the term stained glass was applied… …   Wikipedia

  • Neuromuscular-blocking drug — Global view of a neuromuscular junction: 1. Axon 2. Motor end plate 3. Muscle fiber 4. Myofibril …   Wikipedia

  • University of Dayton Ghetto — The University of Dayton Ghetto is a neighborhood in Dayton, Ohio that is home to upperclassmen of the University of Dayton, a form of housing commonly called a student ghetto. Houses in the neighborhood are leased to students, an arrangement… …   Wikipedia

  • Reasons of the Supreme Court of Canada by Chief Justice McLachlin — The following is a list of Supreme Court of Canada opinions written by Beverley McLachlin during her tenure on the Court. Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin on November 20, 2007 Contents 1 …   Wikipedia

  • Reasons of the Supreme Court of Canada by Chief Justice Lamer — This is a list of opinions written by Antonio Lamer during his tenure as on the Supreme Court of Canada between March 28, 1980 and January 6, 2000. Note: This part of the list is incomplete Re B.C. Motor Vehicle Act, [1985] 2 S.C.R. 486 R. v.… …   Wikipedia

  • Epreuve du kilometre — Épreuve du kilomètre L Épreuve du kilomètre est une compétition de cyclisme sur piste. Elle se déroule départ arrêté et la distance à parcourir le plus vite possible est de 1km (l épreuve équivalente fait 500 m pour les femmes). Le record du… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Epreuve du kilomètre — Épreuve du kilomètre L Épreuve du kilomètre est une compétition de cyclisme sur piste. Elle se déroule départ arrêté et la distance à parcourir le plus vite possible est de 1km (l épreuve équivalente fait 500 m pour les femmes). Le record du… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Kilomètre (cyclisme) — Épreuve du kilomètre L Épreuve du kilomètre est une compétition de cyclisme sur piste. Elle se déroule départ arrêté et la distance à parcourir le plus vite possible est de 1km (l épreuve équivalente fait 500 m pour les femmes). Le record du… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Épreuve du kilomètre — L Épreuve du kilomètre est une compétition de cyclisme sur piste. Elle se déroule départ arrêté et la distance à parcourir le plus vite possible est de 1km (l épreuve équivalente fait 500 m pour les femmes). Le record du monde masculin du… …   Wikipédia en Français

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”