Rodriguez v. British Columbia (Attorney General)

Rodriguez v. British Columbia (Attorney General)

-! bgcolor="6699FF" | Case opinions
- |

"Rodriguez v. British Columbia (Attorney General)" [1993] 3 S.C.R. 519 is a landmark Supreme Court of Canada decision where the prohibition of assisted suicide was challenged as contrary to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms by a terminally ill mother, Sue Rodriguez. In a 5 to 4 decision, the Court upheld the provision in the Criminal Code of Canada.

Background

Sue Rodriguez was a 42 year-old mother who was diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS or "Lou Gehrig's disease") in 1992. By 1993 it was found that she would not live more than a year, and so she began a crusade to strike down section 241(b) of the Criminal Code, which made assisted suicide illegal, to the extent that it would be legal for a terminally ill person to commit "physician-assisted" suicide.

She applied to the Supreme Court of British Columbia to have section 241(b) of Criminal Code struck down as it violated sections 7, 12 and 15(1) of the Charter (the right to "life, liberty and security of person", protection against "cruel and unusual punishment", and equality, respectively).

Reasons of the Court

Justice Sopinka, writing for the majority, found that there was no violation of section 7. He first considered whether the prohibition on ending one's life engaged the right to security of person. He found that the prohibition had sufficient connection with the justice system by its impact on an individual's autonomy and right to life by causing physical and psychological pain.

Sopinka, however, found that the provision did not violate any principles of fundamental justice. He examined the long history of the prohibition of suicide and concludes that it reflects part of the fundamental values of society and so could not be in violation of fundamental justice.

He also rejected the claim that the provision violated the right against cruel and unusual treatment or punishment as a merely prohibition did not fall within the meaning of treatment.

Lastly, he considered the section 15 equality challenge. He noted that the issue is best not resolved under this right, but in assuming that it did violate section 15 he found that it was clearly saved under section 1. He found that the objective was pressing and substantial, rational, and that there was no lesser means to achieve the goal.

Chief Justice Lamer held a dissenting opinion that Criminal Code section 241(b) had infringed on the section 15 and did not consider sections 7 and 12.

Justice Cory ruled that the right to die is as much a protected freedom under section 2 of the Charter as any other part of life.

Justice McLachlin's judgment was that Criminal Code section 241(b) does violate rights. However, it is justified because in overturning it many disabled people that haven't consented to death may be rendered vulnerable to outside pressures.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases (Lamer Court)

External links

*lexum-scc2|1993|3|519|75
* [http://www.epcc.ca/ The Euthanasia Prevention Coalition of Canada]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Sue Rodriguez — (August 2, 1950 – February 12, 1994) was an advocate of assisted suicide. She was born in British Columbia, with the given name Sue Shipley, and grew up in Thornhill, Ontario, a suburb of Toronto. Her first marriage was short lived.Rodriguez, who …   Wikipedia

  • Reasons of the Supreme Court of Canada by Chief Justice McLachlin — The following is a list of Supreme Court of Canada opinions written by Beverley McLachlin during her tenure on the Court. Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin on November 20, 2007 Contents 1 …   Wikipedia

  • Section Seven of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — is a constitutional provision that protects an individual s autonomy and personal legal rights from actions of the government. This Charter provision provides both substantive and procedural rights. [ Suresh v. Canada ] It has broad application… …   Wikipedia

  • Reasons of the Supreme Court of Canada by Chief Justice Lamer — This is a list of opinions written by Antonio Lamer during his tenure as on the Supreme Court of Canada between March 28, 1980 and January 6, 2000. Note: This part of the list is incomplete Re B.C. Motor Vehicle Act, [1985] 2 S.C.R. 486 R. v.… …   Wikipedia

  • Reasons of the Supreme Court of Canada by Justice Cory — This is a list of opinions written by Peter Cory, during his tenure on the Supreme Court of Canada between 1 February 1989 and 1 August 2003. Contents 1 1989 2001 2 2002 3 2003 4 2004 …   Wikipedia

  • Reasons of the Supreme Court of Canada by Justice Sopinka — List of reasons written by Justice John Sopinka during his time as Puisne Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada.1988 1990* United States of America v. Cotroni; United States of America v. El Zein [1989] 1 S.C.R. 1469 (Dissent) * R. v. Hebert… …   Wikipedia

  • Characters in the Southern Victory series — The Southern Victory series or Timeline 191 is a series of novels written by Harry Turtledove. They form an alternate history of events in the United States based on the premise that the Confederates won the Civil War and became an independent… …   Wikipedia

  • Fictional characters in the Southern Victory Series — The Southern Victory Series is a series of alternate history novels written by Harry Turtledove. The point of divergence involves Confederate States of America winning the American Civil War and becoming an independent nation. The series covers… …   Wikipedia

  • Law, Crime, and Law Enforcement — ▪ 2006 Introduction Trials of former heads of state, U.S. Supreme Court rulings on eminent domain and the death penalty, and high profile cases against former executives of large corporations were leading legal and criminal issues in 2005.… …   Universalium

  • List of Puerto Ricans — This list of Puerto Ricans includes people who were born in Puerto Rico, people who are of Puerto Rican ancestry, and many long term residents and/or immigrants who have made Puerto Rico their home, who are significantly notable for their life… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”