Tender years doctrine

Tender years doctrine
Caroline Norton, the person who initiated the tender years doctrine

The tender years doctrine is a legal principle which has existed in family law since the late nineteenth century. This common law doctrine presumes that during a child's "tender" years (generally regarded as the age of thirteen and under), the mother should have custody of the child. The doctrine often arises in divorce proceedings.

History

Historically the English Family Law gave custody of the children to the father, in case of divorce. Until the nineteenth century the women had few individual rights, most of their rights being derived through their fathers or husbands. In the early nineteenth century, Mrs. Caroline Norton, a prominent British society beauty, feminist, social reforment author, and journalist, began to campaign for the right of women to have custody of their children. Norton, who had undergone a divorce and been deprived of her children. So, she worked with the politicians of those times and eventually was able to convince the British Parliament to enact legislation to protect mothers' rights. The result was the Custody of Infants Act from 1839 , which gave some discretion to the judge in a child custody case and established a presumption of maternal custody for children under the age of seven years. In 1873 the Parliament extended the presumption of maternal custody until a child reached sixteen years of age.[1]. This doctrine spread then in majority of the states of the world as England was controlling a wide empire. By the end of the 20th century this doctrine was abolished in the majority of the states of USA and Europe.

Tender years doctrine application

In United States

Tender years doctrine was also frequently used in the 20th century being gradually replaced towards the end of the century, in the legislation of most states, by the "best interests of the child" doctrine of custody. Furthermore, several courts have held that the tender years doctrine violates the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

In Europe

The Tender Years doctrine was gradually abolished in the majority of the states of the EU. In those states the joint custody is the rule after divorce or the separation of the parents. The Principles of the European Fammily Law regardign the parental responsibilities mention in clear that the two parents are equal and their parental responsibilities should neither be affected by the dissolution or annulment of the marriage or other formal relationship nor by the legal or factual separation between the parents.[2]

Maternal Preference versus Tender Years Doctrine

Critics of the family court system, and in particular father's rights groups, contend that although the tender years doctrine has formally been replaced by the best interests of the child rule, the older doctrine is still, in practice, the means by which child custody is primarily determined in family courts nationwide. Statistics such as those from the U.S. Census Bureau [3] indicate that family courts still demonstrate an overwhelming preference to place the children of a divorce in the custody of the mother. A study of FACT Canada association shows the mothers is awarded the sole custody or the primary residence in more than 80% of the cases[4]. The situation is not much different in EU countries, for example in Romania the mother is granted custody in over 84.5% of the cases [5].

Critics maintain that the father must prove the mother to be an unfit parent before he is awarded primary custody, while the mother need not prove the father unfit in order to win custody herself, and that this is contrary to the equal protection clause.

Bibliography

  • Bookspan, Phyllis T. 1993. "From a Tender Years Presumption to a Primary Parent Presumption: Has Anything Really Changed? … Should It?" Brigham Young University Journal of Public Law 8 (January).
  • Katz, Sanford N. 1992. "'That They May Thrive' Goal of Child Custody: Reflections on the Apparent Erosion of the Tender Years Presumption and the Emergence of the Primary Caretaker Presumption." Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy, Catholic University 8 (spring).
  • McLain, Lynn. 1997. "Children Are Losing Maryland's 'Tender Years' War." University of Baltimore Law Review 27 (fall).
  • Pica, Derek A. 1999. "The Tender Years Doctrine: Is It Still the Law?" Advocate (Idaho) 38 (January).
  • Radke, Lynn E. 1993. "Michigan's New Hearsay Exception: The 'Reinstatement' of the Common Law Tender Years Rule." University of Detroit Mercy Law Review 70 (winter).
  • Rinella, Lori. 1995. "Children of Tender Years and Contributory Negligence." UMKC Law Review 63 (spring).
  • Child Custody and Parental Authority in France, Louisiana and Other States of the United States: A Comparative Analysis by Christopher L. Blakesley (link)

See also

Links

Notes

  1. ^ http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Tender+Years+Doctrine
  2. ^ The document is issued by Commission on European Family Law and can be consulted here. See Principle 3:10.
  3. ^ US Census - Custodial Mothers and Fathers and Their Child Support: 2001 [1] October 2003
  4. ^ http://www.fact.on.ca/judiciary/spin.pdf
  5. ^ http://www.monoparentalitate.ro/uploads/files/studiu-cnps_oaai.pdf



Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • tender years doctrine — A doctrine rarely employed in child custody disputes that provides that, when all other factors are equal, custody of a child of tender years generally under the age of thirteen years should be awarded to the mother. Dictionary from West s… …   Law dictionary

  • Tender Years Doctrine — The Tender Years Doctrine is a legal doctrine in child custody cases which has existed in Family Law since the late 19th century. The doctrine presumes that during a child s tender years (generally regarded as the of age thirteen and under), the… …   Wikipedia

  • tender years doctrine — Under this doctrine courts generally award custody of children of tender years to mother unless she is found to be unfit. Saunderson v. Saunderson, Ala.Civ.App., 379 So.2d 91, 92. In many states this doctrine has been abolished by statute, e.g.,… …   Black's law dictionary

  • turntable doctrine — Also termed attractive nuisance doctrine (attractive nuisance doctrine). This doctrine requires the owner of premises not to attract or lure children into unsuspected danger or great bodily harm, by keeping thereon attractive machinery or… …   Black's law dictionary

  • attractive nuisance doctrine — The principle followed in many jurisdictions, but with some diversity of opinion as to the requisite conditions for its application, that one who maintains or permits upon his premises a condition, instrumentality, machine, or other agency which… …   Ballentine's law dictionary

  • attractive nuisance doctrine — The doctrine is that person who has an instrumentality, agency, or condition upon his own premises, or who creates such condition on the premises of another, or in a public place, which may reasonably be apprehended to be a source of danger to… …   Black's law dictionary

  • attractive nuisance doctrine — The doctrine is that person who has an instrumentality, agency, or condition upon his own premises, or who creates such condition on the premises of another, or in a public place, which may reasonably be apprehended to be a source of danger to… …   Black's law dictionary

  • Christian Doctrine —     Christian Doctrine     † Catholic Encyclopedia ► Christian Doctrine     Taken in the sense of the act of teaching and the knowledge imparted by teaching , this term is synonymous with CATECHESIS and CATECHISM. Didaskalia, didache, in the… …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • Best interests — or best interests of the child is the doctrine used by most courts to determine a wide range of issues relating to the well being of children. The most important of these issues concern questions that arise upon the divorce or separation of the… …   Wikipedia

  • Maternal deprivation — Mother and child The term maternal deprivation is a catch phrase summarising the early work of psychiatrist and psychoanalyst, John Bowlby on the effects of separating infants and young children from their mother (or mother substitute)[1]… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
… Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”