Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous

Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous

"Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous" is a book written by George Berkeley in 1713.

Three important concepts discussed in the "Three Dialogues" are perceptual relativity, the conceivability/master argument ("master argument" was coined by André Gallois [A. Gallois, "Berkeley's Master Argument." "The Philosophical Review" 83 (1974), pp. 55-69] ), and Berkeley's phenomenalism.

Perceptual relativity argues that the same object can appear to have different characteristics (e.g. shape) depending on the observer's perspective. Since objective features of objects cannot change without an inherent change in the object itself, shape must not be an objective feature.

Hylas and Philonous

Berkeley uses Hylas as his primary contemporary philosophical adversary. A Hylas is featured in Greek mythology and is understood to represent John Locke. In the Dialogues, the name Hylas is derived from an ancient Greek word for "matter," which Hylas argues for in the dialogue.

Using Philonous, Berkeley argues his own metaphysical views, which were first developed in his earlier book "A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge". Philonous translates as "lover of mind."

In The First Dialogue, Hylas expresses his disdain for skepticism, adding that he has heard Philonous to have "maintained the most extravagant opinion... namely, that there is no such thing as "material substance" in the world." Philonous argues that it is actually Hylas who is the skeptic and that he can prove it. Thus, a philosophical battle of wit begins.

Philonous questions Hylas systematically regarding what humans know of the world, first examining secondary qualities, such as heat, to show that such qualities do not exist outside the individual mind. He then moves on to primary qualities such as extension and shape, and likewise argues that they, too, are dependent entirely on one's perception (e.g., From a distance, a great mountain appears to be small, and the shape of a thing may change dramatically under a microscope).

Hylas's view of matter (which has its origin in the Platonic theory of forms [http://www.philosophypages.com/hy/2f.htm] , or abstract entities that exist outside of the sensible world) is systematically destroyed by Philonous (Berkeley). The basic argument is that because matter is only known to us by its sensible qualities, it is impossible to describe or even imagine matter without these qualities. For in the absence of sensible qualities matter, by definition, loses its essential qualities. Yet that was precisely Plato's argument; "actual matter" did not exist here on earth but rather in another plane or dimension, and furthermore this matter had no sensible qualities. This was the prevailing view of philosophers in Berkeley's day. His argument would prove to be a devastating attack on the nearly 2000 year old platonic view.

Berkeley's argument goes further however. Sensible qualities are not inherent in matter, rather they are ascribed and understood by the mind. Color, sound, temperature, even shape, are relative qualities entirely dependent on a mind. Indeed without a "mind" it becomes impossible to imagine matter. The answer to the question, "If a tree falls in the forest and no one is present, does it make a noise?" is answered by Berkeley's immaterialism. A human (and thus a human mind) need not be present for the tree to make a sound, for the mind of God is always present, or so Berkeley argues. It is this mind of God that gives sensible qualities to matter, not matter itself.

In his own time Berkeley faced opposition from many philosophers who held to the Platonic view. The philosophers thought Berkeley vulgar because his own view seemed to confirm the views held by the lower classes. Roughly speaking the "common view" was that God created everything and that the things on earth were the real things. Many philosophers did not believe in God and believed matter on earth but a mere imitation of actual matter that existed in another dimension. Berkeley sided with the common view.

The philosophy presented is often misinterpreted. The criticism is that Berkeley claims matter does not exist. Berkeley makes no such claim. In fact it was the philosophers of his day who believed that matter on earth was not real. Berkeley defends the prevailing "common" view.

References

ee also

* Idealism
* "Dialogi" by Stanisław Lem

External links

* [http://www.filepedia.org/node/8 George Berkeley's Three Dialogues Between Hylas and Philonous] At filepedia.org online PDF version
* [http://oregonstate.edu/instruct/phl302/reading/berkeley_ex.html Exercise Questions] from Oregon State University


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Hylas — In Greek mythology, Hylas (Greek: Ὕλας ) was the son of King Theiodamas of the Dryopians. Other sources such as Ovid state that Hylas father was Heracles and his mother was the nymph Melite, or that his mother was the wife of Theiodamus, whose… …   Wikipedia

  • George Berkeley — Infobox Philosopher region = Western Philosophy era = 18th century philosophy color = #B0C4DE| image caption =| name = George Berkeley birth = 12 March 1685 death = 14 January 1753 school tradition = Idealism, Empiricism main interests =… …   Wikipedia

  • Bishop Berkeley — George Berkeley Pour les articles homonymes, voir Berkeley. George Berkeley Philosophe irlandais Époque Moderne …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Berkeley, George — George Berkeley David Berman BACKGROUND AND EARLY WORK George Berkeley was born on 12 March 1685 in Co. Kilkenny, where he spent his early years. His father was from England, his mother (very probably) was born in Ireland.1 After attending… …   History of philosophy

  • George Berkeley — Pour les articles homonymes, voir Berkeley. George Berkeley Philosophe irlandais Époque Moderne …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Berkeley, George — known as Bishop Berkeley born March 12, 1685, near Dysert Castle, near Thomastown?, County Kilkenny, Ire. died Jan. 14, 1753, Oxford, Eng. Irish bishop, philosopher, and social activist. He worked principally at Trinity College, Dublin (to 1713) …   Universalium

  • philosophy, Western — Introduction       history of Western philosophy from its development among the ancient Greeks to the present.       This article has three basic purposes: (1) to provide an overview of the history of philosophy in the West, (2) to relate… …   Universalium

  • БЕРКЛИ — (Berkeley) Джордж (1685 1753) англ. философ и религиозный деятель, один из наиболее ярких и последовательных представителей имматериализма в Новое время. С 1734 епископ в Клойне (Ирландия). Основные соч.: «Опыт новой теории зрения» (1709),… …   Философская энциклопедия

  • English literature — Introduction       the body of written works produced in the English language by inhabitants of the British Isles (including Ireland) from the 7th century to the present day. The major literatures written in English outside the British Isles are… …   Universalium

  • Nicolas Malebranche — Full name Nicolas Malebranche Born 6 August 1638(1638 08 06) Paris, Kingdom of France D …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”