Jon Elster

Jon Elster (born 1940) is a Norwegian social and political theorist who has authored works in the philosophy of social science and rational choice theory. He is also a notable proponent of Analytical Marxism, and a critic of neoclassical economics and public choice theory, largely on behavioral and psychological grounds.

Biography

Elster earned his PhD from the Sorbonne in Paris with a dissertation on Marx [cite web
last = Yeghiayan
first = Eddie
authorlink =
coauthors =
title = JON ELSTER A Selected Bibliography
work =
publisher = UCI Department of Philosophy
date =
url = http://sun3.lib.uci.edu/~scctr/philosophy/elster.html
format =
doi =
accessdate = 2008-04-18] under the direction of Raymond Aron. Elster was a member of the September Group for many years but left in the early 1990s. Elster previously taught at the University of Oslo in the department of history and held an endowed chair at the University of Chicago, teaching in the departments of philosophy and political science. He is now Robert K. Merton Professor of Social Sciences with appointments in Political Science and Philosophy at Columbia University and "professeur attaché" at the Collège de France. He was awarded the Jean Nicod Prize in 1997.

He is the son of journalist/author and CEO of the Norwegian Broadcasting Corporation Torolf Elster and poet Magli Elster.

Philosophy

Much of Elster's writing is characterized by attempts to use analytical theories, especially rational choice theory, as a springboard for philosophical and ethical analysis, with numerous examples from literature and history. "Elster has made important contributions to several fields," Daniel Little wrote in a review essay. "The breadth and depth of his writings are striking in a time of high specialisation; he is read and discussed by political scientists, economists and philosophers. His work is difficult to summarise in a slogan, but ... it is generally informed by a broad and deep acquaintance with relevant literature in economics, political science, history, philosophy, and psychology." [Chapter on Jon Elster by Daniel Little in "New Horizons in Economic Thought: Appraisals of Leading Economists", edited by Warren Samuels (Edward Elgar Publishing, 1992) ISBN 1-85278-379-6. Also available as download [http://www-personal.umd.umich.edu/~delittle/ELSTER3.PDF] ]

A student of the philosophy of social science (a topic he investigated thru case studies in "Explaining Technical Change"), Elster strongly argued that social scientific explanations had to be built on top of methodological individualism (the belief that only individuals, not larger entities like "organizations" or "societies", can actually do things) and microfoundations (explaining big societal changes in terms of individual actions). He criticized Marxists and other social scientists for believing in functionalism (the belief that institutions exist because of their effect on society) and instead tried to give Marxism a foundation in game theory (the economic notion that people based on the expected benefits and the choices others are likely to make).

Elster wrote numerous books attempting to use rational choice theory for a wide variety of social explanations. "Rational choice theory is far more than a technical tool for explaining behaviour," he once wrote. "It is also, and very importantly, a way of coming to grips with ourselves - not only what we should do, but even what we should be." [Jon Elster, Some unresolved problems in the theory of rational behaviour, "Acta Sociologica" (1993), vol 36, p 179] He attempted to apply it to topics as varied as politics ("Political Psychology"), bias and constrained preferences ("Sour Grapes"), emotions ("Alchemies of the Mind"), self-restraint ("Ulysses and the Sirens"), Marxism ("Making Sense of Marx") and more.

In doing so, he elucidated many issues with simplistic notions of rational choice: endogenous preference formation (certain actions today can change preferences tomorrow, so how does one decide which preferences one prefers?), hysteresis (people express different preferences when the same question is asked different ways), imperfect rationality (weakness of the will, emotion, impulsiveness, habit, self-deception) and our adjustments for it, and time preferences, among others.

As time went on Elster began to sour on rational choice. A 1991 review in the "London Review of Books" noted "Elster has lost his bearings, or at least his faith. [His latest books] , he says, 'reflects an increasing disillusion with the power of reason'." [ [http://www.geocities.com/hmelberg/elster/hollis91.htm Hollis, Martin (1991), Why Elster is stuck and need to recover his faith, London Review of Books ] ] His latest book, the magisterial 500-page "Explaining Social Behavior" includes something of a recantation:

:I now believe that rational-choice theory has less explanatory power than I used to think. Do real people act on the calculations that make up many pages of mathematical appendixes in leading journals? I do not think so. ... "There is no general nonintentional mechanism that can simulate or mimic rationality." ... At the same time, the empirical support ... tends to be quite weak. This is of course a sweeping statement. ... let me simply point out the high level of disagreement among competent scholars ... fundamental, persistent disagreements among 'schools.' We "never" observe the kind of many-decimal-points precision that would put controversy to rest. (5, 25ff)

The book discusses both rational behavior, but also irrational behavior, which Elster says is "widespread and frequent [but] not inevitable ... we "want" to be rational". (p. 232)

Selected Writings

* "Leibniz et la formation de l'esprit capitaliste" (Paris, 1975) ISBN 270070018X
* "Leibniz and the development of economic rationality" (Oslo, 1975)
* "Logic and Society" (New York, 1978)
* "Ulysses and the Sirens" (Cambridge, 1979)
* "Sour Grapes: Studies in the Subversion of Rationality" (Cambridge, 1983)
* "Explaining Technical Change : a Case Study in the Philosophy of Science" (Oslo, 1983)
* "Making Sense of Marx" (Cambridge, 1985)
* "An Introduction to Karl Marx" (Cambridge, 1986)
* "The Cement of Society: A study of social order" (Cambridge, 1989)
* "Solomonic Judgments: Studies in the limitation of rationality" (Cambridge, 1989)
* "Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences" (Cambridge, UK, 1989)
* "Local Justice: How institutions allocate scarce goods and necessary burdens" (Russell Sage, 1992)
* "Political Psychology" (Cambridge, 1993)
* "Strong Feelings: Emotion, Addiction, and Human Behavior" The Jean Nicod Lectures. (MIT Press, 1999)
* "Alchemies of the Mind: Rationality and the Emotions" (Cambridge, 1999)
* "Ulysses Unbound: Studies in Rationality, Precommitment, and Constraints" (Cambridge, 2002)
* "Closing the Books: Transitional Justice in Historical Perspective" (Cambridge, 2004)
* "Explaining Social Behavior: More Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences" (Cambridge, 2007)

See also

* G. A. Cohen
* John Roemer
* List of Jean Nicod Prize laureates

References

External links

* [http://www.columbia.edu/cu/philosophy/fac-bios/elster/faculty.html Elster page at Columbia]
* [http://www.college-de-france.fr/default/EN/all/rat_soc/index.htm Elster page at the Collège de France]
* [http://www.geocities.com/hmelberg/elster/elster.htm Jon Elster page] maintained by Hans O. Melberg
* [http://www.users.globalnet.co.uk/~rxv/books/elster.htm Selected quotes by Jon Elster]